Daily writing prompt
What could you do more of?
Komal Ashok Raisinghani [1] & Bhupendra Nandlal Kesur [2],*
Abstract
This research investigates the evolution of the epistolary form in the digital age, using Alena Graedon’s The Word Exchange (2014) and Dave Eggers’ The Circle (2015) as primary texts. These novels exemplify how contemporary narratives integrate digital communication methods—such as emails, text messages, and social media—to reflect and critique modern societal changes. In The Word Exchange, Graedon presents a dystopian future where the overreliance on digital devices, like the Meme, leads to cognitive decline and societal fragmentation. Characters struggle with memory and language, illustrating the dangers of losing intellectual autonomy in a digitally dependent world. This aligns with theoretical perspectives on narrative immersion and cognitive effects, emphasizing the balance between connectivity and cognitive health. Conversely, The Circle critiques the pervasive surveillance and erosion of privacy in a hyper-connected society. The comparative analysis of these texts demonstrates the continuity and innovation within the epistolary tradition. Traditional epistolary narratives created intimacy and realism through letters, while modern digital epistolary forms maintain immediacy but reflect the fragmented nature of contemporary communication. The digital format’s impact on cognitive functions, social interactions, and personal identity is critically examined through thematic analysis. This study contributes to understanding the evolving nature of epistolary narratives, offering insights into how contemporary authors use digital communication to explore and critique the complexities of modern human interaction. The findings underscore the significance of technological advances in reshaping literary forms and their reflection of broader cultural and cognitive shifts. The study ultimately contributes to the broader discourse on the future of storytelling and the dynamic ways in which literature adapts to the digital landscape.
Keywords: Digital Epistolary Form, Modern Epistolary Narratives, Cognitive Impact, Technological Dependency, The Word Exchange, The Circle
In the realm of literary studies, the epistolary form has long held a unique place, offering readers an intimate glimpse into characters’ lives through their letters and personal writings. Traditionally, these narratives relied on handwritten letters to convey the depth and nuance of human relationships. The physical act of writing and the tangible nature of letters added layers of meaning and emotion, allowing readers to feel connected to the characters and their experiences. The epistolary novel, a genre that began in the early 18th century, involves storytelling through letters, diary entries, and other documents. Samuel Richardson’s Pamela (1740) and Clarissa (1748) are among the earliest examples of this form in English literature. These novels captivated readers by offering intimate glimpses into the characters’ thoughts and emotions, creating a sense of immediacy and personal connection that was unprecedented at the time. Although historically speaking the epistolary genre peaked in eighteenth-century Europe, producing such classics as Montesquieu’s Lettres persanes, Richardson’s Pamela and Clarissa, Rousseau’s La Nouvelle Héloïse, Smollett’s Humphry Clinker, Goethe’s Werther, and Laclos’s Les Liaisons dangereuses, the letter’s potential as artistic form and narrative vehicle has been explored by writers of many nationalities and periods—from Ovid in the Epistulae Heroidum to Saul Bellow in Herzog (Prince and Altman, 1983). These novels offered unprecedented intimacy, allowing readers to delve into characters’ thoughts and emotions through their personal correspondence. This format facilitated multiple perspectives, enriching the narrative complexity and engaging readers on a deeper emotional level. Moreover, Terry Castle, in Clarissa’s Ciphers: Meaning and Disruption in Richardson’s Clarissa (2016), elaborates on how Samuel Richardson’s use of letters in Clarissa adds layers of meaning and complexity, highlighting the act of communication as both a narrative device and a thematic focus.
“Clarissa’s remarkable form-the intricate, clumsy, strangely beautiful “Epistolary Manner of Writing”-allows for such movement between inner and outer dimensions of the text. It invites a jump between levels” (Castle, 2016, p.16). This form not only provides a unique narrative structure but also reflects the multifaceted nature of human experience.
Richardson’s reasons for choosing the epistolary “Manner,” its literary provenance and prototypes, the relation between the strategies and ideology of fictional correspondence and those of actual correspondence in the eighteenth century, or (as in Ian Watt’s classic discussion in The Rise of the Novel) on those more intangible cultural and intellectual changes that made the letter form seem to contemporary readers an eminently plausible and indeed preferred mode of narrative art (Castle, 2016, p.17).
The use of letters in Clarissa bridges personal introspection and social interaction, creating a narrative that resonates with the cultural context of its time.
The epistolary format allowed authors to explore multiple perspectives and develop complex, layered narratives that engaged readers deeply (Prince and Altman, 1983). As communication technologies evolved, so did the mediums through which epistolary narratives were conveyed. The advent of the telephone, followed by email and text messaging, transformed personal correspondence, influencing how stories could be told. The digital age has introduced new modes of communication that are immediate, interactive, and far-reaching. Unlike traditional letters, which required time to compose and deliver, digital messages can be sent and received instantly, altering the pace and nature of communication. These digital forms not only change how stories are told but also impact the development of characters and the portrayal of their relationships. In the digital age, the evolution of communication technologies has profoundly impacted narrative forms and character development in literature.
As society transitioned into the digital age, the medium of storytelling evolved, incorporating emails, text messages, and social media updates into the narrative fabric. This shift reflects contemporary modes of interaction and communication, offering new possibilities for narrative structure and character development. Digital narratives not only enhance immediacy and engagement but also introduce fragmentation and hypertextuality, challenging traditional linear storytelling. Marie-Laure Ryan’s (2001, p.15-20) Narrative as Virtual Reality emphasizes how digital tools facilitate immersive and interactive narrative experiences, transforming conventional forms. This evolution reflects broader cultural shifts, as digital communication redefines not only the form but also the essence of personal narratives. Increasingly, these narratives capture the fleeting, fragmented nature of communication in the digital age, emphasizing post-modern themes such as “fragmentation and the disappearance of the grand narrative” (Whitting, 2009). The integration of social media and instant messaging into narrative storytelling brings forth new dynamics of connection and isolation, thus inviting readers to engage with characters in novel ways while challenging traditional notions of authorship and voice. “Authors and filmmakers are expanding upon the epistolary narrative to include modern-day correspondences such as emails, text messages, and even social media posts. This blend of tradition with innovation provides a broad canvas for creativity and pushes the boundaries of storytelling” (Falmouth University).
This research situates The Word Exchange (2014) and The Circle (2015) within the broader context of digital narrative analysis, utilizing these theoretical insights to explore how digital communication forms influence narrative techniques and character development. These narratives showcase the complexity of maintaining relationships in an age defined by transient connections, blurring the distinctions between private thoughts and public personas. As literature continues to adapt to technological advancements, the epistolary novel remains a vital arena for examining the intersections of technology, identity, and human interaction. By examining the specific instances of digital communication in these novels, this study aims to illuminate the evolving role of digital media in contemporary literature and its implications for the future of narrative forms. In Alena Graedon’s The Word Exchange and Dave Eggers’ The Circle, the incorporation of digital communication forms such as emails, text messages, and social media is pivotal in constructing the narrative, shaping character development, and highlighting thematic concerns. Both novels use these modern modes of communication to explore the implications of technological advancements on language, identity, and social interactions. In both the novels, one can witness the seamless fusion of traditional and digital epistolary elements. Graedon’s novel explores a dystopian future where language itself is at risk, using digital forms of communication to build suspense and develop characters. Eggers’ The Circle delves into the pervasive impact of social media and surveillance, employing emails and instant messages to reveal the inner workings of a powerful tech company and its effects on personal identity and privacy.
The contemporary relevance of the epistolary form is underscored by its ability to engage readers with the immediacy of digital communication while maintaining the intimate, reflective quality that has always defined the genre. This duality is explored in various studies, highlighting the epistolary novel’s enduring appeal and its capacity to adapt to new media. “Through the exchange of letters, diary entries, or even digital messages, we witness a dynamic interaction between characters that often acts as a catalyst for the plot, building suspense and climax in an organic way” (Crawford). The shift from handwritten letters to digital messages represents not only a change in medium but also a transformation in how narratives are constructed and experienced, offering new avenues for character development and plot progression. Through a detailed analysis of The Word Exchange and The Circle, this research paper will investigate how digital communication forms are incorporated into contemporary epistolary narratives and their impact on storytelling and character development. By examining these modern texts, we aim to understand how the epistolary form continues to evolve, reflecting and shaping our digital identities and connections in the literary landscape.
The Word Exchange is set in a near-future dystopia where a digital device called the Meme has become ubiquitous, altering how people communicate. The story revolves around the disappearance of a lexicographer, Doug Johnson, and his daughter Anana’s quest to find him. The novel uses various digital forms to unravel the mystery, showcasing the profound impact of technology on language and cognition. Anana’s character is deeply influenced by her interactions with digital communication, particularly through her reliance on the Meme device and her receipt of cryptic emails from her father. These digital interactions reveal her growing anxiety and determination as she navigates a world where language and cognition are under threat. The emails from her father were filled with jumbled letters and symbols, such as “Stop u hui dome tode”, showcase Anana’s desperation and her father’s deteriorating state, highlighting her emotional journey (Graedon, 2014). Doug’s disappearance and his fragmented digital messages serve as a catalyst for the plot, propelling Anana into a dangerous quest. His reliance on digital communication to warn his daughter underscores his awareness of the digital threat and his helplessness as language disintegrates. Doug’s final messages, sent via the Meme, reflect his frantic attempts to communicate and his awareness of the impending linguistic collapse.
In The Word Exchange, Alena Graedon explores the profound consequences of digital dependency on cognitive functions and societal coherence. The disease “word flu” manifests as a progressive loss of language and cognitive abilities among the populace, symbolizing the detrimental effects of excessive reliance on technology. The Meme, originally designed to enhance communication and access to information, becomes a tool of cognitive degradation as people start to rely on it for even the most basic linguistic tasks. This dependency illustrates the broader theme of technology’s potential to undermine human intellect and autonomy. Graedon’s narrative critiques the commodification of language, where words and meanings are bought and sold, emphasizing the fragility of human cognition in a technology-driven society. The novel warns of the dangers inherent in allowing technology to supplant fundamental human skills, highlighting the need for a balanced and mindful approach to technological integration.
In The Circle, Dave Eggers delves into the theme of surveillance and the erosion of privacy in the digital age. The novel presents a near-future scenario where a powerful tech company, The Circle, advocates for complete transparency and total connectivity. Through the protagonist Mae Holland’s journey, Eggers critiques the pervasive nature of social media and the corporate push for absolute transparency, which ultimately leads to the erosion of individual privacy and identity. The Circle’s technologies, designed to monitor and share every aspect of an individual’s life, create a society where privacy is deemed obsolete. This hyper-connectivity fosters an environment where constant public scrutiny becomes the norm, leading to profound psychological and societal costs. The novel explores the seductive allure of technological utopianism, where the promise of a perfectly connected society masks the insidious loss of personal freedom and autonomy. Eggers highlights the dangerous implications of living under constant digital surveillance, urging a reevaluation of the values of privacy and individualism in the face of advancing technology.
The plot of The Word Exchange follows Anana Johnson as she navigates a world unraveling due to the catastrophic effects of the Meme. Anana works at the North American Dictionary of the English Language (NADEL), a bastion of traditional lexicography. The sudden disappearance of her father, Doug Johnson, the chief editor at NADEL, propels Anana into a quest to uncover the truth behind the Meme and the origins of the “word flu.” As she delves deeper into the conspiracy, Anana discovers that the Meme’s developers have unleashed a linguistic virus that spreads through digital communication, corrupting the cognitive faculties of its users. The narrative structure interweaves Anana’s personal struggles with a broader societal collapse, illustrating the profound impacts of technological overdependence. Her journey is marked by efforts to rescue her father, decipher the origins of the linguistic epidemic, and ultimately, fight against the dehumanizing forces of unchecked technological advancement. The plot’s tension builds around the conflict between human intellect and technological control, culminating in a climactic struggle to preserve linguistic and cognitive integrity.
In The Circle, the plot centers on Mae Holland’s rapid ascent within The Circle, a tech giant that dominates the digital landscape. Mae, initially an enthusiastic and idealistic newcomer, quickly becomes engrossed in the company’s mission to achieve total transparency and connectivity. As she rises through the ranks, Mae becomes a fervent advocate for the Circle’s initiatives, including ubiquitous surveillance and data-sharing policies. The narrative follows her transformation as she succumbs to the power of the Circle’s technology, sacrificing her privacy and personal relationships in the process. Mae’s journey reflects the broader societal shift towards a culture of constant surveillance and digital conformity. The plot exposes the psychological manipulation employed by the Circle to maintain control over its employees and the public. Mae’s increasing immersion into the Circle’s ethos reveals the dangerous allure of technological utopianism, where the promise of a perfectly connected society masks the insidious loss of personal freedom and autonomy. The narrative reaches its zenith as Mae fully embraces the Circle’s vision, highlighting the profound ethical and personal costs of living in a digitally monitored world. The assertion, “Secrets are lies. Sharing is caring. Privacy is theft,” serves as a critical commentary on the societal expectations enforced by digital culture (Eggers, 2015). Here, the characters are pressured to conform to a collective identity, drastically reshaping personal relationships and self-representation. Through this lens, the novel critiques the kind of transparency demanded in modern communication and its implications for individual identity.
In The Word Exchange, Anana Johnson’s character embodies resilience and the fight to retain human agency in a digitally dominated world. Anana’s initial reliance on the Meme device mirrors the societal trend towards technological dependence. However, as the narrative progresses, her character evolves from passive acceptance to active resistance. Anana’s journey is marked by her determination to uncover the truth behind her father’s disappearance and the origins of the “word flu.” Her evolving relationship with technology, from reliance to rebellion, mirrors the novel’s critique of technological overreach. A poignant line states, “Words are the currency of my life, and yet they are becoming worthless” (Graedon, 2014). This reflects how digital communication reduces the depth and significance of language, leading to a sense of disconnection. Secondary characters, such as Bart, Anana’s colleague and confidant, serve as foils to her, showcasing varying degrees of resistance and submission to digital dependence. Bart’s own struggle with the effects of the Meme device underscores the pervasive impact of technology on individual cognition and agency. Anana’s character arc highlights the theme of human resilience and the importance of safeguarding cognitive autonomy in the face of technological encroachment. Moreover, the line, “In this world, meaning is fluid, slipping through our fingers like sand,” resonates with the theme of lost identity in an era dominated by digital formats (Graedon, 2014). The fluidity of meaning indicates a broader existential dilemma, where the protagonist and, by extension, the readers must grapple with what authenticity and connection mean in a rapidly changing digital landscape.
In The Circle, Mae Holland’s character arc serves as a cautionary tale of the power of technology and the erosion of personal identity. Initially portrayed as an idealistic and ambitious young woman, Mae eagerly embraces the Circle’s mission to achieve total transparency. Her character’s transformation is driven by the company’s manipulative tactics, which exploit her desire for acceptance and success. As Mae becomes more enmeshed in the Circle’s surveillance culture, she gradually loses her individuality and critical thinking. Her increasing immersion in the company’s ethos leads to the deterioration of her personal relationships and ethical boundaries. Mae’s transformation from a private individual to a public figure illustrates the psychological impact of constant surveillance and the loss of personal autonomy. Her character’s journey serves as a critique of the pervasive influence of social media and the dangers of prioritizing connectivity and transparency over privacy and individualism. Eggers uses Mae’s character to highlight the broader societal implications of living in a digitally monitored world, urging a re-evaluation of the values of privacy and personal freedom in the face of advancing technology. Additionally, the line “We are defined by the connections we make, and the data we generate” illustrates the profound impact of technology on the characters’ identities (Eggers, 2015). Their self-worth becomes tied to their online interactions, further emphasizing how deeply modern epistolary forms intertwine with personal identity construction. This perspective challenges traditional notions of selfhood that are more static and less reliant on external validation.
The exploration of digital communication’s impact on storytelling and character development in The Word Exchange and The Circle reveals profound shifts in narrative techniques. In The Word Exchange, Graedon’s portrayal of a linguistic epidemic highlights the cognitive risks of technological dependency. The novel’s critique of language commodification emphasizes the necessity of maintaining cognitive integrity in a digital world. In contrast, The Circle by Eggers delves into the consequences of surveillance and privacy erosion, showing how constant digital scrutiny transforms individual identities and societal norms. Through Mae Holland’s experience, the narrative illustrates the seductive yet dangerous allure of technological utopianism. These contemporary works demonstrate how modern communication methods like emails, text messages, and social media reshape narrative structures and influence character development. Both novels highlight the significant impact of digital communication on contemporary narratives, urging a critical examination of how technology influences storytelling, character development, and broader societal dynamics.
Together, these works underscore the ongoing evolution of the epistolary form, adapting to contemporary digital realities. They highlight critical issues such as privacy, autonomy, and cognitive resilience, urging a re-evaluation of the relationship with technology. By juxtaposing these narratives, this paper emphasizes the dynamic nature of epistolary storytelling and its relevance in addressing modern technological challenges. This analysis enriches our understanding of how digital communication shapes literature and society, offering valuable insights into the future trajectory of narrative forms.
References
The contemporary role of the epistolary novel — Falmouth University English & Creative Writing. Falmouth University English & Creative Writing. https://falwriting.com/new-blog/2019/9/30/the-contemporary-role-of-the-epistolary-genre
Castle, T. (2016). Clarissa’s Ciphers: Meaning and Disruption in Richardson’s Clarissa.
Crawford, M. (2024). What are Epistolary Novels: A Guide to Letter-Based Stories. Filmmaking Lifestyle. https://filmlifestyle.com/what-are-epistolary-novels/
Eggers, D. (2015). The Circle. Large Print Press.
Graedon, A. (2014). The Word Exchange: A Novel. Doubleday Books.
Prince, G., & Altman, J. G. (1983). Epistolarity. Approaches to a Form. Poetics Today, 4(1), 199. www.academia.edu/78662315/Epistolarity_Approaches_to_a_Form.
Ryan, M. L. (2001). Narrative as Virtual Reality: Immersion and Interactivity in Literature and Electronic Media. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.
Whitting, G. J. (2009). Whitting Epistolary Writing by Contemporary Women.
www.semanticscholar.org/paper/Whitting-Epistolary-Writing-by-Contemporary-Women-hitting/5c50b610457fbb81d4bf8087bf075be300330d5a#:~:text=Contemporary%20epistolary%20novels%20are%20experiments%20in%20style%20and%20form.%20Unlike%20the%20nineteenth%2Dcentury%20sentimental.
[1] Research Scholar, KCE Society’s M. J. College, Jalgaon, Maharashtra, India. Email: raikomal2109@gmail.com https://orcid.org/0009-0004-3717-1070
[2] * Corresponding author: Professor and Head, P. G. Department of English, KCE Society’s M. J. College, Jalgaon, Maharashtra, India. Email: bnkesur@gmail.com https://orcid.org/0000-0002-5613-2198
International Journal of Research (IJR) 