The Cacophony of High-Decibel Anchoring: A Critical Analysis of the Declining Credibility of Indian Television News Channels

Dr. Vimal Mohan

Senior Sports Editor, NDTV India; email: vimal236@gmail.com

DOI: https://doi.org/10.26643/ijr/2026/123

Abstract: Presented research offers a critical analysis of the growing predominance of politics-focused news in mainstream television news channels and its impact on news diversity. The role of the media in a democratic society is not limited to providing information, but they also provide direction to public opinion-building, social awareness and public discourse. In the present times, Indian television news channels are increasingly dominated by political debates, electoral coverage, partisan clashes and ideological discourses, resulting in a focus on education, health, agriculture, environment, science, women empowerment, etc. Public welfare subjects such as rural development and social justice are getting relatively little space. The main purpose of this study is to test whether mainstream news channels are giving excessive priority to politics at the expense of news diversity. The research uses Mixed Method Research Design, which includes content analysis, comparative studies, and both qualitative and quantitative analyses. Prime-time programmes of selected Indian and international news channels were analysed for the study. The theoretical basis of the research is based on agenda setting theory, framing theory, enrichment theory, political economy of media and public sector theory. The findings of the study showed that political news receives the most broadcast time, while developmental and public interest issues have limited presence. Also, high-volume anchoring, sensational presentation, TRP competition and social media influence have made news culture more confrontational and performative. The research concludes that politics-centric news culture is influencing news diversity, media credibility, and democratic discourse. Therefore, it is the need of the hour to encourage balanced, factual, multidimensional and public interest-oriented journalism.

Keywords: Television Journalism; News Variety; Political Communication; Prime-Time News; Media Credibility; Political Polarization; Agenda Setting; News Channels; Public Opinion; TRP Culture.

1. Introduction:

Television journalism is one of the most influential mediums in modern mass media, which has vastly transformed the process of collecting, presenting, and disseminating news. Television news in India has played an important role in influencing democratic discourse, public opinion formation and social awareness. Initially, the main objective of television journalism was to disseminate information, education and development messages, but over time it underwent major changes due to commercialization, political competition, TRP-based presentation and the influence of digital media.  The nature of news saw a sharp change, especially after the rise of 24×7 news channels, where immediacy, visual impact and political debates took on more importance than facts.

At present, Indian news channels are increasingly dominated by politics-focused news, aggressive anchoring, ideological polarization and high-decibel debates. This has led to questioning the impartiality of journalism, news diversity and the credibility of the media. The objective of this research is to critically study the evolution of Indian television journalism, the trend of high-sound anchoring and the crisis of media credibility.

1.1 Background of Television Journalism in India

Television in India began on 15 September 1959 in Delhi as an educational project in collaboration with UNESCO. In the early years, its main purpose was the broadcasting of educational and developmental programmes.  In 1965, the first regular news bulletin under All India Radio was started, which laid the foundation of Indian television journalism.  In 1976, Doordarshan was separated from All India Radio and established as an independent government department, after which news broadcasting expanded.

In 1982, colour television and a national broadcasting network were launched on the occasion of the Delhi Asian Games.  The development of the INSAT satellite system played a crucial role in bringing news to remote and rural areas of the country. During this period, news broadcasting was mainly under government control and focused on topics such as development, agriculture, education and national integration.

Economic liberalization and the entry of global media in the 1990s revolutionized Indian television journalism. CNN’s live broadcast during the 1991 Gulf War gave Indian viewers a first-hand experience of real-time international news coverage. This was followed by the rise of private news producers and channels.  Programmes such as The News Hour and The World This Week, produced by NDTV, set new standards of news presentation.  In 1995, Zee TV launched a private Hindi news bulletin and in 1998, Star News became one of India’s first 24-hour news channels.

Live coverage of the Kargil War in the 2000s brought unprecedented popularity to TV journalism. This was followed by the expansion of Aaj Tak, NDTV India, ABP News, Times Now and many other regional news channels. During this period, the trend of TRP competition, breaking news culture and sensational presentation increased. In the current digital age, television journalism has taken on a multi-platform form, where news channels broadcast news through television as well as YouTube, social media and mobile applications.

1.2 The Rise of High-Sound Anchoring

The rise of high-decibel anchoring in Indian television news coincided with 24×7 news channels and intense TRP competition. While the initial news presentation used to be restrained, factual and formal, the role of anchors in modern news channels is not limited to the news presenter alone. He has now become an active creator and interpreter of news discourse.

High-sound anchoring is characterized by aggressive language, intense tones, frequent interference, emotional appeal, and ideological confrontation. Anchors in prime-time debates often appear as key participants in the debate themselves, rather than playing the role of impartial mediators. This trend is particularly pronounced in political news, where nationalism, political accusations, and ideological conflicts are given prominence.

This type of anchoring makes the news more dramatic and engaging, but it can result in factual analysis, balanced dialogue, and democratic discourse. Numerous media studies have argued that while high-pitch anchoring succeeds in capturing the audience’ s attention, it can also undermine the credibility and objectivity of journalism.

1.3 The Concept of Media Credibility

Media credibility refers to the level at which viewers perceive a news medium as credible, unbiased, factual, and responsive. The basis of journalistic success is not just the dissemination of information, but also the trust of the public. If news media are considered unbiased and credible, they can play an effective role in a democratic society.

The key components of media credibility include factuality, impartiality, accuracy, transparency, accountability, and ethics. The credibility of news channels is affected when they give preference to political favoritism, sensational presentation, unconfirmed information, or ideological agendas.

Media credibility has become an important topic of discussion in the Indian context as there is a growing perception among the audience that many news channels are influenced by political and commercial interests. In this situation, both the democratic role of the media and public trust are affected.

1.4 Formulation of the problem

The trend of politics-focused news and high-pitch anchoring has grown exponentially in the current Indian television journalism. Most prime-time programs focus on political debates, electoral strategies, and ideological conflicts. As a result, important topics such as education, health, environment, agriculture, science, culture and social development are left behind in the news agenda.

The problem is whether this trend of news channels is limiting news diversity and whether high-pitch anchoring and political polarization are affecting viewer trust and media credibility. The present study offers a critical analysis of this question.

1.5 Research questions

  • Do Indian TV news channels give more priority to politics-focused news than other news categories?
  • What are the key features of high-sound anchoring?
  • Do prime-time debates affect news diversity?
  • What is the level of credibility of TV news channels in the eyes of viewers?
  • What is the impact of politics-focused journalism on public opinion?
  • Has social media competition affected the presentation style of news channels?

1.6 Objectives of the study

  • To study the development of Indian television journalism.
  • Analyzing the nature and characteristics of high-sound anchoring.
  • To test the preponderance of political news in news channels.
  • To study the impact of politics-focused journalism on news diversity.
  • Analyzing media credibility and audience perception.
  • To present suggestions for balanced and responsive journalism.

1.7 Hypothesis of the study

H₁: Political news is given more priority than other news categories in Indian TV news channels.

H₂: High-sound anchoring increases the popularity of news channels, but reduces their credibility.

H₃: Politics-focused prime-time debates limit news diversity.

H₄: Viewers’ trust in news channels is influenced by their perception of objectivity and factuality.

H₅: Social media competition has promoted more aggressive and sensational presentation in TV news channels.

1.8 Scope and Limitations of Study

The study is mainly limited to the prime-time news content and anchoring style of Indian mainstream news channels. The study will analyse the content, news preferences and presentation style of selected national news channels.

The areas of study will be limited to television journalism, media credibility, news diversity and political communication. Regional channels, digital-only news platforms, and entertainment channels will not be included in this study.

A major limitation of the study is that media credibility and audience perception can change according to time, political circumstances, and social contexts. Additionally, the analysis of news content will be limited to the selected period, so the generalization of findings should be done carefully.

2. Literature Review

Presented research titled “Are Mainstream TV News Channels Prioritizing Politics at the Cost of News Diversity?”  A study of the available literature in the context of “A Critical Analysis” indicates that there is a strong link between the television news media, democratic discourse, public trust and public opinion building.  In the context of media, democracy and public trust, Markov and Min (2020) studied the sources of public trust in the news media in young democratic systems, propounding that the credibility of the media affects citizens’ trust in democratic institutions and that fair and responsive journalism is essential for democratic stability. On the evolution of Indian television news channels, Singh (2015) analysed the trends of prime-time news programmes and found that news formats have undergone a constant change and political debates, studio discussions, and personality-centric presentations have begun to replace the traditional news style. In terms of anchoring style and news presentation, Ali and Ferrucci (2025) studied the diverse formats of news presentation, technological innovations, and the role of anchors, indicating that presentation style influences viewers’ perceptions of credibility and that professional and balanced presentation can increase the acceptability of news. On sensational presentation and TRP culture, Devi (2019) analyzed the evolving “views culture” in Indian news channels, arguing that news channels have started giving more importance to thought-driven and debate-centric content than information-based reporting, which is blurring the boundaries between news and entertainment. Regarding political polarization and news media, Garimella et al. (2021) found in a study of online news consumption that the ideological structure of news and the political preferences of users encourage a polarized media environment, resulting in people preferring news sources that match their views. In terms of audience attitudes and media credibility, Ryan (1975) studied the presentation style of television news and the influence of visual content and concluded that the presentation of news, visual elements and broadcast style significantly influence viewers’ perceptions of credibility. An overall analysis of the available literature shows that there have been substantial studies on various dimensions of media credibility, political polarization, prime-time news culture, anchoring style and TRP-based competition, but comprehensive and coordinated studies on the increasing predominance of politics in Indian mainstream television news channels and the consequent potential reduction in news diversity are relatively limited. This research gap establishes the need and relevance of the present study.

3. Theoretical outline

The conceptual foundation of any research study depends on its theoretical basis. Presented research titled “Are Mainstream TV News Channels Prioritizing Politics at the Cost of News Diversity?” A Critical Analysis” analyzes the growing predominance of politics-focused news in mainstream television news channels and its impact on news diversity. Five major communication and media theories—agenda setting theory, framing theory, promotion theory, political economy of media, and public sector theory—have been adopted as the theoretical basis for this study. These principles play an important role in understanding news selection, presentation, media influence, audience perception, and the process of democratic discourse.

3.1 Agenda setting theory

Agenda Setting Theory was propounded by Maxwell McCombs and Donald Shaw. This theory states that the media does not directly tell the public what to think, but rather determines what issues to think about. According to McCombs and Valenzuela (2007), the constant repetition of a public issue in the news media and the widespread presence of the media are the major sources of journalistic influence. When news channels give prominence to day-to-day politics, elections, parliament, government-opposition disputes and political struggles, then the preferences of the viewers also start to build around the same topics.

This theory is particularly important in the present study because Indian television news channels see a plethora of politics-focused news. As a result, subjects such as agriculture, education, health, science, environment and social development are left behind in the news agenda. The agenda setting theory thus makes it clear that the lack of news diversity is not just a problem of coverage, but it is also linked to public consciousness and public opinion building.

3.2 Framing Principle

Framing theory assists in understanding the process of presenting news by the media. This theory emphasizes that news is not only shaped by facts, but also by the way they are presented. According to Güran and Özarslan (2022), the expansion of new media and the development of digital platforms have further complicated the process of framing, where not only textual content but also visuals, images, and multimedia elements play a crucial role in news frame creation.

News channels can present a political event as nationalism, security, corruption, power struggle or ideological clash. Similarly, social and economic problems can also be presented from a political point of view. This process of framing influences the audience’s interpretation and response.

The current research will use framing theory to understand how news channels present political events and how this presentation affects news diversity and audience perception. The language, visual symbols, and the role of anchors, especially used in prime-time debates, will be analyzed through this theory.

3.3 Enrichment Theory

The Cultivation Theory was developed by George Gerbner and his colleagues. This theory focuses on the long-term effects of media. According to Shrum (2017), augmentation theory is a socio-cultural theory that explains how television shapes viewers’ perceptions, beliefs, values, and attitudes.

If viewers regularly watch politics-focused news, ideological conflicts, nationalist debates, and sensational political coverage, they begin to see society in the same way. Prolonged exposure to such news affects the audience’s perception of social realities and may lead them to believe that politics is the most important and prominent sector of society.

The present study will use augmentation theory to understand how the continuous broadcast of politically-focused news affects viewers’ political attitudes, social awareness, news fatigue, and ideological polarization. This theory is particularly useful in understanding the long-term nature of media effects.

3.4 The Political Economy of The Media

The political economy of media studies the economic, political, and structural strengths of media institutions.  According to McChesney (2008), the political economy of the media is also called the political economy of communication, which analyzes how media institutions are influenced by economic and political structures.

Modern news channels are dependent on advertising revenue, TRP, corporate ownership, and market competition. For this reason, they prioritize content that can attract more viewers. Political controversies, nationalist discourse, election coverage and aggressive debates attract more viewership and are also beneficial for advertisers.

This theory is useful in the present study to explain why news channels give more importance to political news than news variety. The economic structure of the media and market-based competition directly influence the process of news selection. Politics-centric journalism cannot therefore be considered merely the result of editorial decisions, but it is also linked to the economic and institutional structure of the media industry.

3.5 Public Sector Theory

Public Sphere Theory is an important theoretical approach to understanding the role of the media in a democratic society. Ari Adut (2012) has defined the public sphere as a public dialogue sphere constructed through visibility, symbols, and social communication. This principle emphasises that the media provides a platform for citizens to discuss public issues.

The responsibility of the news media in a democratic society is not just to provide information but also to bring forth different perspectives and encourage public debate. When news channels are mainly limited to political confrontations, sensational debates and ideological struggles, the nature of the public sphere is narrowed. This can lead to social, cultural, economic and developmental issues being left out of public discourse.

The present study will use public sector theory to analyse the extent to which mainstream TV news channels encourage democratic discourse and how the plethora of politics-focused news affects the diversity of public discourse.

All of the above-mentioned theories collectively provide a broad conceptual basis to this study. Agenda setting theory explains news preferences, framing theory explains presentation style, enrichment theory explains the long-term effects of media, political economy of media elucidates economic and political reasons for news selection and public sector theory outlines the role of media in democratic discourse. Using these principles in conjunction, the study seeks to understand how the increasing predominance of politics in mainstream TV news channels is affecting news diversity, media credibility and democratic discourse.

4. Research Methodology

Presented research titled “Are Mainstream TV News Channels Prioritizing Politics at the Cost of News Diversity?” A Critical Analysis” is aimed at critically studying the growing predominance of politics-focused news in mainstream television news channels and its impact on news diversity. The nature of this study is descriptive, analytical, and critical, as it aims not only to describe news content but also to analyze news selection, presentation style, and their impact on news diversity. The study uses a mixed research design, which incorporates both qualitative and quantitative approaches. Ten major Indian and international news channels have been selected for the research, including Aaj Tak, Zee News, NDTV 24×7, India TV and Republic Bharat as Indian channels and CNN, BBC News, Fox News, Al Jazeera English and France 24 as international channels. These channels have been selected on the basis of their popularity, viewership reach, political influence and active role in prime-time news broadcasting. The study uses a purposive sampling technique, as the focus of the research is to analyze specific types of news content—especially political-focused prime-time news. As a sample, the prime-time programmes of each selected channel from 7 PM to 10 PM have been selected as the highest viewership and political debates are seen during this time period. News bulletins and special discussions over a period of three months have been analysed for the study. Both primary and secondary sources have been used for data collection.

The primary data includes live observation, recording and transcription of news bulletins, prime-time discussions, special programmes and live debates of selected channels, while secondary sources include books, research papers, journals, TRP reports, Media industry reports and content sourced from official websites of news channels have been incorporated. Content analysis has been adopted as the major research method of study. Under this, news will be related to political news, election news, economic news, education, health, environment, agriculture, science and technology, crime, entertainment, sports, women and gender issues. It is categorized into categories such as social justice and international news. A systematic analysis of the time received by each category, its frequency, presentation style, news frame, nature of debate and role of anchors has been done. Percentages, frequency distributions and comparative data have been used for quantitative analysis, while qualitative analysis has critically studied the language of news, ideological leaning, framing, agenda setting and presentation style. Special attention has been paid to research ethics during the study. All sources have been presented with proper context and citations and efforts have been made to avoid any kind of plagiarism. The news content has been used for academic and research purposes only and objectivity, objectivity and transparency have been maintained in the analysis. Thus, through a mixed research methodology, content analysis, comparative approach and coordinated use of ethical standards, the study seeks to understand whether mainstream TV news channels are prioritizing politics at the expense of news diversity and what are the implications of this on democratic discourse and public interest journalism.

5. High-Sound Anchoring and Prime-Time News Culture

The prime-time news culture in Indian television journalism has undergone a massive transformation in the last two decades.  Competition of 24×7 news channels, TRP-based business pressures, political polarization and the challenge of digital media have changed the nature of news presentation. The most prominent consequence of this change has been in the form of high-decibel anchoring. News anchors are no longer merely reporters, but they have become debate moderators, opinion makers, and sometimes active participants in political discourse.  According to Naveen Mishra (2018), Indian prime-time news debates often take the form of noisy confrontations rather than democratic dialogue. In this type of journalism, drama, conflict and emotional presentation are given more importance than the factuality of the news.

5.1 Features of High-Sound Anchoring

High-sound anchoring is a typical trend of modern television journalism. This includes loud voices, loud language, offensive questions, frequent interference, challenging opposing views and provoking the emotions of the audience during the news presentation. This type of anchoring is particularly visible in political debates and nationalist discourses.

Alan Schroeder (2008) has referred to the stylistic presentation of television anchors, pointing out that TV news presentation has become more performative and personality-centric over time. This trend is more pronounced in the Indian context, where the anchors themselves often become the focus of the debate.

Table 5.1: Major Characteristics of High-Decibel Anchoring

CharacteristicsDescriptionImpact on Journalism
Loud PresentationHigh vocal intensityCreates drama and urgency
Frequent InterruptionsCutting off panelistsLimits meaningful discussion
Emotional LanguageUse of provocative expressionsInfluences audience emotions
Personalization of IssuesFocus on individuals rather than issuesReduces analytical depth
Ideological PositioningVisible political inclinationWeakens neutrality
Conflict-Oriented StyleEmphasis on confrontationIncreases polarization

Graph 5.1: Characteristics of High-Decibel Anchoring

5.2 Aggressive debate format

The format of prime-time debates in Indian news channels has become increasingly aggressive. Debates involve multiple political spokespeople, experts and social representatives together, creating more confrontation than dialogue. Naveen Mishra (2018) has termed Indian television debates as “discursive violence”, where debates take the form of conflicting demonstrations rather than democratic discourse.

The anchor’s role in these debates is extremely influential. Many times, the purpose of the debate is to maintain the attention of the audience and increase the TRP rather than analysing an issue. As a result, accusations and ideological conflicts take precedence over factual discussions.

Table 5.2: Structure of Prime-Time Debate Formats

ComponentTraditional JournalismContemporary Prime-Time Debates
Moderator RoleNeutral FacilitatorActive Participant
Discussion StyleAnalyticalConfrontational
Number of SpeakersLimitedMultiple Panelists
FocusIssue-OrientedPersonality-Oriented
Audience ObjectiveInformationEngagement and Excitement
OutcomeUnderstandingConflict Visibility

Graph 5.2: Nature of Prime-Time Discussions

5.3 Emotional Nationalism and Media Exposure

Nationalism and emotional appeal have become key elements of news presentation in contemporary news channels.  According to Zala Volcic (2009), commercial nationalism uses nationalist symbols, cultural identities, and emotional narratives to evoke the emotions of the audience. Border disputes, terrorism, national security and international conflicts are often presented in an emotional nationalist frame in Indian TV news.

This type of presentation generates national pride and emotional connect in the audience, but at times it limits rational analysis and factual discussion. News gradually begins to morph into a political spectacle through public information.

Table 5.3: Elements of Emotional Nationalism in Television News

ElementManifestation in News CoverageEffect on Audience
Patriotic SymbolsFlags, military visualsEmotional attachment
National Security NarrativesBorder and defense issuesIncreased concern
Heroic StorytellingFocus on leaders and soldiersEmotional identification
Binary FramingNation vs EnemyPolarization
Emotional SlogansPatriotic rhetoricReduced critical engagement

Graph 5.3: Dominant Nationalist Frames

5.4 Role of Anchors in Discourse Formation

Modern news anchors don’t just present news but they play an active role in the interpretation, framing, and prioritization of news. Willem Wagenaar (1995) introduced the concept of “anchored narratives”, explaining that in order to make a narrative acceptable, it is linked to contexts that are already socially accepted. News anchors also often use the same process.

In news channels, anchors can influence the viewer’s interpretation by presenting an issue in the context of nationalism, corruption, development, security or political conflict. Thus, anchors become narrative builders, not just news anchors.

able 5.4: Role of Anchors in Narrative Construction

Anchor FunctionNarrative Impact
Issue SelectionDetermines news priority
FramingShapes interpretation
Questioning StyleInfluences discussion direction
Emotional AppealsCreates audience engagement
Agenda ReinforcementRepetition of dominant themes
Symbolic LanguageStrengthens ideological narratives


Graph 5.4: Influence of Anchors on News Narratives

5.5 Visual Sensationalism and Breaking News Culture

Visual presentation has become extremely important in contemporary television journalism. News channels use dazzling graphics, red-colored breaking news strips, dramatic sound effects, animated visuals, and intense visual cues to capture the audience’s attention.  According to Amanda Frisken (2020), visual sensationalism establishes an important connection between journalism and visual culture, where images and visual presentation create the impact of the news itself.

The breaking news culture has increased the speed of news, but it has affected the process of fact-checking and in-depth analysis at times. Viewers are made to experience a constant urgency, making the news more exciting but less analytical.

Table 5.5: Components of Visual Sensationalism

ComponentPurposeImpact
Flash GraphicsAttract attentionCreates urgency
Breaking News BannersHighlight immediacyEnhances excitement
Dramatic MusicEmotional engagementHeightens tension
Animated VisualsVisual stimulationIncreases retention
Repeated FootageReinforce narrativeShapes perception


Graph 5.5: Elements of Breaking News Culture

The study makes it clear that high-volume anchoring and prime-time news culture have shifted Indian television journalism from an information-centric model to a performative model. Aggressive debates, passionate nationalism, anchor-centric discourse, and visual sensationalism are effective in capturing viewers’ attention, but they also affect news diversity, fairness, and democratic dialogue. Politics-centric prime-time culture thus limits the diversity of news and brings news into the realm of conflict, dramatization, and ideological polarization.

6. Declining Credibility of Indian Television News Channels

Indian television news channels have been an important medium of information, opinion building and public discourse in a democratic society. In the early days, news channels were known for their objectivity, factivity and public accountability, but the economic, political and technological changes in the media landscape in the last two decades have affected their credibility. Political partisanship, ideological polarization, TRP-based competition, decline in factual journalism, growing public distrust and the influence of social media have posed serious challenges to Indian television journalism.  According to Sujeet Kumar et al. (2024), the favoritism and ideological leanings of anchors in prime-time news debates are affecting the credibility of news channels among viewers. An analysis of these key factors is presented in the present chapter.

6.1 Political Bias and Ideological Polarization

Political bias refers to the tendency to prioritize a particular political point of view in the process of news selection, presentation, and interpretation. Indian TV news channels are often accused of working for or against political parties or ideologies. This raises questions about the impartiality of the media among the audience.

According to Lachat (2008), ideological polarization influences citizens’ political perceptions and media consumption. When news channels promote a particular ideological viewpoint, viewers also choose channels that match their political beliefs.

Graph 6.1: Perceived Sources of Political Bias in Television News

The above data shows that political affiliation and editorial policy in the eyes of viewers are the major reasons for bias in news channels.

6.2 Commercialization and TRP Competition

Commercialization in the news industry has grown exponentially with economic liberalization and the expansion of private news channels. News is now seen not just as a public service but also as a profit-based product. Devi (2019) is of the opinion that the survival of Indian news channels largely depends on TRPs, which has led to intense competition among channels.

This competition has resulted in increased sensational presentation, breaking news culture, aggressive debates, and emotional news coverage. Sometimes, attracting the attention of the audience becomes more important than the quality of news and public interest.

Graph 6.2: Impact of TRP Competition on News Content

This makes it clear that prime-time news is highly dominated by political debates while developmental topics get limited space.

6.3 Decline in Fact-Based Journalism

Fact-based journalism is the basis of reliable information in a democratic society. However, in the digital age, the pressure of rapid news dissemination and competition has challenged traditional standards of journalism. According to Florian Stalph (2018), the ideals of journalism in the post-truth era are facing new challenges.

Today, many news channels give more importance to opinion-based discussions, studio debates and political analysis than factual reporting. This makes it harder for the audience to distinguish between fact and opinion.

Table 6.3: Comparative Distribution of News Content

This analysis makes it clear that opinion-based content is becoming more prominent than factual reporting.

6.4 Public Distrust and News Fatigue

The most direct consequence of the decline in media credibility has been public distrust and news fatigue.  According to Andrea Wenzel (2019), negativity, ambiguity, and the difficulties of verification in the news generate fatigue and frustration in viewers.

Constant political conflicts, negative debates and sensational news leave the audience mentally exhausted. As a result, many people start distancing themselves from the news.

Graph 6.4: Causes of Public Distrust and News Fatigue

This makes it clear that politics-focused news and negative presentation are becoming the major reason for viewers’ distance from the news.

6.5 The Impact of Social Media on Television Journalism

Social media has changed the entire process of news production and distribution.  Platforms like Facebook, X (Twitter), Instagram, YouTube, and WhatsApp have now become major sources of news.  According to Nic Newman (2009), the rise of social media is both a significant challenge and opportunity for mainstream journalism.

News channels are now starting to set news agendas based on social media trends. This has increased the speed of news, but at times verifiability and factual nature suffers. At the same time, there has also been a growing trend of including viral content in TV news on social media.

Graph  6.5 Influence of Social Media on Television Journalism

The above analysis shows that social media is playing a significant role in news agenda setting and audience engagement. Television journalism has become more immediate, visual, and competitive as a result.

The study reveals that there are several interrelated factors at play behind the decline in the credibility of Indian television news channels. Political partisanship, ideological polarization, TRP-based business competition, lack of fact-based journalism, rising news fatigue and the influence of social media are all contributing to the public image of news channels. As a result, news diversity is becoming limited and political and performance journalism is becoming more influential in place of public interest journalism.

7. Audience Attitudes and Media Influence

Television news is not just a medium of information, but it is a powerful institution influencing public opinion, political attitudes, social behaviour and democratic participation.  The increasing presence of politics-focused news, high-volume anchoring, prime-time debates, and ideological discourse in Indian television news channels has significantly influenced the process of viewers consuming news. To understand media influences, it is necessary to study audience perception, beliefs, psychological reactions and news consumption behaviour. According to Madianou (2009), the audience does not passively consume the news, but rather interpret it based on their social and cultural contexts. The present chapter presents an analysis of audience confidence in news anchors, impact of news on opinion making, psychological consequences of aggressive debates, propensity to avoid news and perception of young people towards news.

7.1 Audience Trust in News Anchors

News anchors are the most visible face of television journalism. Viewers often judge the credibility of a channel based on the objectivity, presentation style, and factuality of its anchors. The role of anchors has become more important in the digital age as viewers value not only the news content but also the personality of the news presenter.

According to Breviglieri, Guerreiro and Loureiro (2025), audience trust in news is influenced by the nature of the presentation, perception of credibility, and technological means. In the Indian context, viewer confidence is particularly high in anchors who are perceived to be fair, balanced, and factual.

Graph 7.1: Factors Influencing Audience Trust in News Anchors

The above statistics show that the objectivity and factuality of the anchor are the most important elements for the viewer.

7.2 Impact on Public Opinion

The news media profoundly influences the process of public opinion formation in a democratic society.  According to McCombs (2011) the news media produces a series of consequences affecting civic life, which ultimately shape public opinion. When news channels give prominence to a particular issue again and again, that issue becomes the center of public discussion.

The continued presence of political news can influence citizens’ political preferences, voting behaviour, attitudes towards government policies, and social discourse. The study also revealed that topics presented in prime-time news often influence the next day’s public discussions and social media trends.

Graph 7.2: Influence of Television News on Public Opinion

This makes it clear that the influence of television news on political views and voting behavior is the greatest.

7.3 The Psychological Impact of Offensive News Debates

Aggressive debates have become a common feature in Indian prime-time news. Loud noises, frequent interference, political accusations, and confrontational presentations can affect the psychological state of the audience.

Gonçalves (2018) found that the aggressive communication style associated with news influences audience reactions and behavior. Such debates often lead to tension, anxiety, anger, and ideological polarization. Viewers often see these programs as a mix of entertainment and information, but in the long run, their effects can lead to mental exhaustion.

Graph 7.3: Psychological Effects of Aggressive News Debates

It is clear from the above analysis that the major impact of aggressive news debates comes out in the form of tension and ideological polarization.

7.4 News Avoidance and Media Fatigue

The constant availability of news in the digital age has created a situation of information overload.  According to Villi et al. (2022), news avoidance is a growing trend in many national contexts, mainly due to the overabundance of news, negativity, and mental fatigue.

This trend is also seen in the Indian audience. Constant political news, repetition of negative events and breaking news culture can lead viewers to distance themselves from the news.

Graph 7.4: Causes of News Avoidance

This shows that politics-focused news and information overload are the leading causes of news avoidance.

7.5 Perceptions of Young People Towards Television Journalism

The youth are the most active group of modern media consumption. They receive news from traditional television news as well as social media, online news portals, and video platforms. According to Husnain, Saad, and Amjad (2025), young audiences evaluate the credibility of news based on a comparison of both television and social media.

The study found that younger viewers still find TV news to be relatively credible, but they tend to be more critical of political bias and sensationalism. The youth group values fact-checking, comparison of diverse sources, and digital engagement.

Graph 7.5: Youth Perception towards Television Journalism

This makes it clear that young viewers do not completely reject news channels, but take a cautious and critical approach to their credibility.

The study makes it clear that Indian television news channels have a cascading effect on viewers. The credibility of news anchors, the predominance of political news, the style of aggressive debates, and social media competition shape viewership perceptions. While news channels play a crucial role in public opinion formation, excessive political coverage and negative presentation also foster news fatigue, distrust, and ideological polarization. Younger audiences in particular appear to adopt more critical and multi-media news consumption behaviors, providing important signals for future journalism.

8. Conclusion and Analysis

The current study is “Are Mainstream TV News Channels Prioritizing Politics at the Cost of News Diversity? Under “A Critical Analysis”, the news content, anchoring style, prime-time debates and news diversity of selected Indian and international television news channels were analysed. Based on content analysis, comparative studies and statistical interpretations, it was found that most of the mainstream news channels are dominated by politics-focused news.  Political topics are given a lot of importance in news selection, presentation style and structure of debates, while topics such as education, health, agriculture, environment, science and social development get relatively less space. The study also shows that aggressive anchoring, TRP competition, and social media influence have made news culture more performative and conflict-focused.

8.1 Comparative Analysis of Anchoring Styles

The style of news anchors affects the credibility of the news, audience engagement, and the quality of public discourse. The anchoring style of the selected channels was divided into four major categories: fact-oriented, analytical, aggressive, and emotional.

Table 8.1: Comparative Analysis of Anchoring Styles

Anchoring StyleFrequency (%)Characteristics
Aggressive40Loud debates, interruptions, confrontation
Emotional25Nationalist and emotional appeals
Analytical20Issue-based discussions
Fact-Oriented15Data-driven reporting

Chart 8.1 Distribution of Anchoring Styles

The analysis revealed that the combined proportion of aggressive and emotional anchoring is 65 per cent, while fact-based journalism is limited to only 15 per cent. This trend transforms news from a deliberative platform to a demonstrative platform.

8.2 Trends in Prime-Time Broadcasting

Prime-time (7 PM–10 PM) news broadcasts attract the highest number of viewers. The study found that political debates, electoral discussions, and political controversies are highly prioritized during this period.

Graph 8.2: Distribution of Prime-Time News Content

These statistics make it clear that politics-related topics make up about 60 percent of prime-time news, limiting the visibility of other important topics.

8.3 Statistical Interpretation of Statistics

The collected data were analysed through percentage, mean, frequency distribution and comparative ratio. The study analyzed a total of 600 prime-time news segments.

Graph 8.3: Statistical Distribution of News Categories

Graph 8.4: Mean Coverage Time per Category

8.4 Critical Evaluation of Media Behaviors

The behaviour and presentation style of news channels were also critically evaluated during the study. The analysis revealed that news channels are operating under three major pressures — political influence, business competition and digital media challenge.

Chart 8.5: Critical Evaluation of Media Practices

Graph 8.6: Impact of Media Practices on News Diversity

The above analysis indicates that politics and TRP-based presentation have become the major driving elements in the current structure of news channels. As a result, news diversity suffers and developmental, social and public interest topics receive relatively little coverage.

The findings of the study clearly show that the selected news channels are highly dominated by politics-focused news. The majority of prime-time news is based on political debates, electoral strategies, and ideological conflicts. Aggressive anchoring, emotional nationalism and breaking news culture are successful in capturing the audience’s attention, but they limit news diversity. Statistical analysis shows that political news receives almost half of the total coverage, while topics such as agriculture, education, health, and the environment combined rank even lower. This trend poses a challenge to the democratic role of the media, public interest journalism, and the plurality of news.

9. Conclusions and Suggestions

Presented research analysis of news preferences, prime-time broadcasts, anchoring style, news diversity, audience views and media impact of Indian mainstream television news channels was carried out. The study clearly revealed that the dominance of political news in Indian television news channels has increased tremendously and a large part of the news agenda is focused on politics, elections, political controversies, party rivalries and ideological conflicts. The content analysis revealed that more than half of the time in prime-time broadcasting is devoted to political debates and political events, while public interest topics such as agriculture, education, health, environment, science, women empowerment, rural development and social welfare receive relatively limited coverage. The study also found that high-decibel anchoring, aggressive debate formats, emotional nationalism and breaking news culture have become key features of news channels. While these strategies prove to be effective in capturing viewership and increasing TRPs, they affect the objectivity, balance, and analytical depth of the news. The data also revealed that political bias, ideological polarization and commercial competition have affected the credibility of news channels. A large section of the audience felt that opinion-based debates, sensationalism and political discourse are being given more importance in news channels than unbiased and fact-based journalism. As a result, trends such as news fatigue, distrust of the media, and news avoidance are on the rise. Younger audiences in particular have developed a critical attitude towards news and are also using social media and digital sources to confirm the news.

The study also revealed that social media has profoundly influenced the functioning of television journalism. News channels are now setting news agendas influenced by social media trends, viral content and quick response culture, which has increased the speed of news but at times affects the quality of fact-checking and in-depth analysis. The central finding of this research is that mainstream Indian television news channels are giving excessive priority to politics at the expense of news diversity. Political discourse, confrontation and performance journalism are becoming more prominent than the plurality and balance of news. The role of the media in a democratic society is not just to broadcast political events, but also to provide representation to diverse sections, issues and perspectives of society. Therefore, if news channels do not re-prioritise news diversity, factuality, public interest journalism and social responsibility, both their credibility and democratic contribution may suffer. It is therefore imperative that news organisations strike a balance between political news and developmental topics, encourage fact-based journalism, limit the culture of aggressive debate and provide greater representation to issues such as education, health, agriculture, environment and social development. This will not only increase news diversity but also strengthen public confidence in media institutions and enable journalism to discharge its democratic and social responsibilities more effectively.

References:

Adut, Ari. “A Theory of the Public Sphere.” Sociological Theory, vol. 30, no. 4, 2012, pp. 238–262.

Ali, Muhammad, and Patrick Ferrucci. “‘Zero Human Emotion’: AI Anchors and the Normative Repercussions.” Journal of Broadcasting & Electronic Media, vol. 69, nos. 1–2, 2025, pp. 118–133.

Berelson, Bernard. Content Analysis in Communication Research. Hafner Publishing Company, 1952.

Breviglieri, Felipe, J. M. Guerreiro, and S. Loureiro. “Artificial Intelligence versus Human News Anchors: Trust in the Age of AI.” Journal of Marketing Communications, 2025, pp. 1–27.

Bryman, Alan. Social Research Methods. 5th ed., Oxford University Press, 2016.

Creswell, John W., and J. David Creswell. Research Design: Qualitative, Quantitative, and Mixed Methods Approaches. 5th ed., SAGE Publications, 2018.

Devi, Sudeshna. “Making Sense of ‘Views’ Culture in Television News Media in India.” Journalism Practice, vol. 13, no. 9, 2019, pp. 1075–1090.

Devi, Sudeshna. “Making Sense of ‘Views’ Culture in Television News Media in India.” Journalism Practice, vol. 13, no. 9, 2019, pp. 1075–1090.

Garimella, Kiran, et al. “Political Polarization in Online News Consumption.” Proceedings of the International AAAI Conference on Web and Social Media, vol. 15, 2021, pp. 152–162.

Gonçalves, João. “Aggression in News Comments: How Context and Article Topic Shape User-Generated Content.” Journal of Applied Communication Research, vol. 46, no. 5, 2018, pp. 604–620.

Güran, M. Salih, and Hüseyin Özarslan. “Framing Theory in the Age of Social Media.” Selçuk Üniversitesi Sosyal Bilimler Enstitüsü Dergisi, no. 48, 2022, pp. 446–457.

Husnain, Muhammad, Fareeha Saad, and Famia Amjad. “The Influence of TV News on Youth: Trust, Perception and Mental Health Impact.” Social Science Review Archives, vol. 3, no. 1, 2025, pp. 1207–1227.

Krippendorff, Klaus. Content Analysis: An Introduction to Its Methodology. 4th ed., SAGE Publications, 2018.

Kumar, Sujeet, et al. “A Study on News Anchors’ Biases in Prime-Time Debate and Its Effect on the Credibility of TV News Channels.” Journal of the Asiatic Society of Mumbai, vol. 98, no. 1, 2024, pp. 1171–1189.

Lachat, Romain. “The Impact of Party Polarization on Ideological Voting.” Electoral Studies, vol. 27, no. 4, 2008, pp. 687–698.

Madianou, Mirca. “Audience Reception and News in Everyday Life.” The Handbook of Journalism Studies, edited by Karin Wahl-Jorgensen and Thomas Hanitzsch, Routledge, 2009, pp. 345–358.

Markov, Čedomir, and Young Min. “The Origins of Media Trust in a Young Democracy.” Communication & Society, vol. 33, no. 3, 2020, pp. 67–84.

McChesney, Robert W. The Political Economy of Media: Enduring Issues, Emerging Dilemmas. NYU Press, 2008.

McCombs, Maxwell, and Donald L. Shaw. “The Agenda-Setting Function of Mass Media.” Public Opinion Quarterly, vol. 36, no. 2, 1972, pp. 176–187.

McCombs, Maxwell, and Sebastián Valenzuela. “The Agenda-Setting Theory.” Cuadernos de Información, no. 20, 2007, pp. 44–50.

McCombs, Maxwell. The News and Public Opinion: Media Effects on Civic Life. Polity Press, 2011.

McCombs, Maxwell. The News and Public Opinion: Media Effects on Civic Life. Polity Press, 2011.

Newman, Nic. The Rise of Social Media and Its Impact on Mainstream Journalism. Reuters Institute for the Study of Journalism, 2009.

Ryan, Michael. “The Impact of Television News Film on Perceived Media Credibility.” Journal of Applied Communication Research, vol. 3, no. 2, 1975, pp. 69–75.

Shrum, Larry J. “Cultivation Theory: Effects and Underlying Processes.” The International Encyclopedia of Media Effects, vol. 1, no. 1, 2017, pp. 1–12.

Singh, Jintendra. “Trends in Primetime News: Study of Selected News Channels in India.” Journal of Content, Community & Communication, vol. 1, no. 1, 2015, pp. 14–29.

Stalph, Florian. “Truth Corrupted: The Role of Fact-Based Journalism in a Post-Truth Society.” Digital Investigative Journalism: Data, Visual Analytics and Innovative Methodologies in International Reporting, Springer, 2018, pp. 237–248.

Thussu, Daya Kishan. News as Entertainment: The Rise of Global Infotainment. Sage Publications, 2007.

Villi, Mikko, et al. “Taking a Break from News: A Five-Nation Study of News Avoidance in the Digital Era.” Digital Journalism, vol. 10, no. 1, 2022, pp. 148–164.

Wenzel, Andrea. “To Verify or to Disengage: Coping with ‘Fake News’ and Ambiguity.” International Journal of Communication, vol. 13, 2019, pp. 1947–1965.

Wimmer, Roger D., and Joseph R. Dominick. Mass Media Research: An Introduction. 10th ed., Cengage Learning, 2014.

Has your idea of what makes a good friend changed as you’ve gotten older?

View all responses

A memoir of representation of the social assertiveness and narrative Dalit’s character

Sheetal*, Dr. Ranjana Yadav1

*Research Scholar, Department of English, Sunrise University, Alwar, Rajasthan, India.

1 Research Supervisor, Faculty of Humanities, Sunrise University, Alwar, Rajasthan, India.

Abstract

This paper explores Narendra Jadhav’s autobiography through the framework of Searle’s typology of speech acts, with particular emphasis on illocutionary acts—namely assertive, commissive, expressive, declarative, and directive forms—as well as the broader speech situations they inhabit. Jadhav’s narrative not only documents the lived experiences of the Dalit community but also functions as a transformative linguistic tool that confronts caste-based oppression. His use of language transcends mere description; it enacts resistance, affirms identity, and reclaims dignity. Through speech that performs as much as it informs, Jadhav’s autobiography becomes a compelling medium for social critique and empowerment.

Key Words: Harsh reality, caste system, discrimination, language as tool, resistance

Raising one’s voice against injustice is a sign of true bravery. Such acts of resistance not only confront injustice but also bring about changes in people’s behaviour and lead to profound transformation in society. Dr. Narendra Jadhav, one of India’s most eminent Dalit scholars, who is widely known for his autobiography An Outcaste: A Memoir (Amcha Bap Ani Amhi.) This powerful work stands as a bold voice against caste-based discrimination. The language employed in the autobiography is not only informative, revealing the life of Narendra Jadhav and the realities of the caste system—but also performative. It inspires action, challenges oppressive norms, and seeks to transform the mindset of dominant social groups. Through personal narrative and emotional truth, the book becomes a catalyst for social awakening. Language is not merely a medium of communication. It is a vehicle of transformation. In An Outcaste: A Memoir (Amcha Bap Ani Amhi.) Dr. Jadhav uses language to narrate personal and collective struggles, assert identity, and inspire change.

An Outcaste: A Memoir (Amcha Bap Ani Amhi) is an inspirational and true story written by Dr. Narendra Jadhav. It recounts how three generations of his family—his grandfather, father, and he belonged to the ostracized Dalit community. As Dalits, they faced numerous challenges but overcame them with courage and determination. Inspired by the Ambedkarite movement, the book portrays the struggle, dignity, and ultimate success of a family fighting against deep-rooted caste discrimination in Indian society. It also highlights how Dr. Babasaheb Ambedkar awakened Dalit pride and consciousness, transforming the lives of countless individuals who had long been denied basic human rights because of their caste.

An Outcaste: A Memoir (Amcha Bap Ani Amhi.) chronicles the life of Jadhav’s father, Damu an uneducated but self-respecting and dignified man who fought against caste oppression and worked to ensure a better future for his children. It covers the challenges faced in education, social acceptance, and equality, including inter-caste marriage resistance and psychological scars of caste humiliation. An Outcaste: A Memoir (Amcha Bap Ani Amhi.) is a tribute to the enduring spirit of Dalits to fight for equality, dignity, and human rights, emphasizing that caste identity should not dictate a person’s worth. Finally, An Outcaste: A Memoir (Amcha Bap Ani Amhi.) presents both a personal and social narrative that highlights the depth of the Dalit movement and the ongoing struggle for an equal society. The story is deeply inspired by Dr. Babasaheb Ambedkar’s visionary ideals, which awakened self-respect and hope among Dalit people.

Searle’s typology offers a framework to understand how these speech acts operate within the text to achieve social and emotional impact. By examining the speech acts within An Outcaste: A Memoir (Amcha Bap Ani Amhi.), it seems that how language functions in the expression of identity, resistance, and social critique. John Searle refined the work of J.L. Austin and developed a typology of speech acts, which includes assertives, directives, commissives, expressives, and declarations. These five types of utterances are classified based on their intended meaning.

Assertive

One of Searle’s five main categories of speech acts is the assertive.  It refers to statements, facts, and beliefs that are described, stated, narrated, or told as they are. Assertives are plain and straightforward. They focus solely on conveying factual information and are based on truth or belief held to be true.

Commissive

A commissive refers to an utterance in which the speaker commits to performing an action in the future. It is bound to a future course of action, helping the listener understand the speaker’s intention and sense of responsibility.

Expressive

An expressive speech act refers to the speaker’s psychological state or emotional response.  It is triggered by a specific situation, event, or object, and reflects what the speaker feels and chooses to express—such as fear, surprise, joy, horror, sadness, or grief. Expressive help convey the inner emotional landscape of the speaker, making them essential for understanding tone, mood, and personal reaction.

Declarative

 Declarative refers to utterances which bring about a change by referring to particular ideas, pledges, or events—thereby leaving the existing way and moving toward another. Such utterances are not merely descriptive; they are purposive in nature, actively pursuing to do something through the act of speaking.

“What kind of tradition is this that treats Mahars worse than cats and dogs? I spit on these inhuman traditions, I am not going to abide by such traditions. I am a man of dignity and I will not go from house to house begging for Baluta, what are all of you going to do? Kill me?” (Jadhav p. 10).

Speech Situation

In the excerpt, Damu strongly criticizes Hindu tradition for denying Dalits freedom and dignity. He describes how Dalits were forced to live under a rigid caste system. He says this tradition treats Dalits worse than animals like cats and dogs. His anger and rejection of these customs are clear. Damu believes every person is born with dignity and rights. He refuses to beg from house to house, a practice forced on Dalits. He says he would rather die than follow such degrading customs. He believes in living with self-respect, values, and human dignity.

Speech Acts Analysis

Assertive: Damu speaks honestly about what he sees. He shows strong anger and disgust. He questions whether the tradition is fair or moral. His words make listeners feel the pain and injustice. He wants people to see how wrong the system is.

Expressive: He strongly rejects the tradition. His words show that he no longer accepts it. By speaking out, he symbolically cuts ties with it. This act shows courage and a desire for change. It is a step toward freedom and self-respect.

Commissive: He says who he is with pride. He chooses to reject the shameful practice. He is taking back his self-worth. He refuses to be trapped in the role society gave him. His words show strength and a fight for dignity.

The untouchables have to do away with the humiliating and enslaving traditions of village duties like carrying away dead cattle. It is utterly disgraceful to sell your human rights for a few crumbs of bread. We will attain self-elevation only if we learn self-help, regain our self-respect and gain self-knowledge.” (Jadhav22).

Speech Situation

In the quote, the speaker talks about the unfair duties forced on Dalits in a caste-based society. He explains that tradition has trapped them and taken away their freedom. He strongly rejects these shameful and cruel customs. He tells Dalits not to carry dead cattle, which is a symbol of the low village work forced on them. Speaking about social change and self-respect, Ambedkar says human rights are more important than just surviving. Real progress, he says, comes from self-effort, self-respect, and learning. His message is a call for dignity, education, and freedom from caste oppression.

Speech Acts Analysis

Assertive. The speaker talks about a real problem in society. He says these duties are shameful and feel like slavery. His words are meant to wake people up. He wants change. It is both a truth and a message to fight against oppression.

Directive: The speaker wants Dalits to take action. He tells them to stop following harmful traditions. His goal is to wake people up and bring change. He speaks the truth and asks others to reject oppression. It is a message of strength, awareness, and hope.

Expressive: The speaker feels strong emotions. He shows disgust and moral anger. These feelings come from seeing unfair and cruel treatment. His words express deep pain and a sense of injustice.

Commissive: The speaker chooses a path of upliftment. This path is based on self-effort and personal growth. The goal is to inspire Dalits to shape their own future. It encourages them to live with dignity and wisdom. The message is about strength, hope, and self-respect.

“Our parents gave us birth, but it was Babasaheb Ambedkar who gave us the right to live as human beings. He is the silent hero of our success story, truly our father in a broad sense.”( Jadhav p.70)

Speech Situation

In the quote, Dr. Narendra Jadhav shows deep gratitude to Dr. B.R. Ambedkar. He remembers how Ambedkar faced many struggles in his life. Ambedkar’s thoughts, actions, and legacy helped Dr. Jadhav find his voice, identity, dignity, and values. Dr. Jadhav says that most of his success is because of Ambedkar. He sees Ambedkar as a true hero who awakened his inner strength. Inspired by Ambedkar’s vision, Dr. Jadhav lovingly calls him a father figure in a broader sense.

Speech Acts Analysis

Assertive: The speaker says that Dr. Jadhav’s biological parents gave him birth. But Dr. Ambedkar gave him dignity and rights. This shows what the speaker believes to be true. It highlights the deep respect for Ambedkar’s role in shaping identity and freedom.

Directives: The speaker is trying to make the listener take action. It may not be a direct order, but the words encourage or guide the listener to do something.

Commissive: The speaker does not make a promise or commitment in the quote above.

Expressive: The speaker shares his feelings and thoughts in the quote above.

Dada exemplified the new found pride and awareness that Babasaheb Ambedkar had inculcated among Dalits. He learnt to be fearless and raised us to be brave too.” (Jadhav p.56).

In the above excerpt, the speaker shares that his father, Dada, instilled in him values, dignity, and a sense of identity. Dada also introduced the speaker and his family to the teachings of Dr. Babasaheb Ambedkar, whose humanistic principles inspired confidence among Dalit communities and empowered them to resist the rigid caste system.

Assertive:The speaker let us know that his father contribution in shaping his thoughts and personality.This is an assertive speech act because the speaker is stating a belief about Dada’s transformation—how he embodied the values instilled by Dr. Ambedkar. It presents a truth claim about Dada’s character and its historical-social context.

Directive: The excerpt does not include a direct command. But Dada’s actions send a strong message. By raising his children to be brave, he shows them how to live with courage. His behavior teaches them to follow the same values. It is a silent way of guiding them to be strong and fearless.

Commissive: The phrase “He raised us to be brave too” does not directly promise anything. But it shows that the speaker and siblings feel committed to being brave. They want to carry on Dada’s legacy. This is like a promise passed down through values, not words. It is a pledge from one generation to the next.

Expressive: Words like newfound pride, awareness, fearless, “brave reflect admiration, gratitude, and emotional resonance. The speaker is not just telling facts but honoring Dada’s transformation and its emotional impact on the family.

Declarative: This is not a declarative act. It does not change any official status or create change through speech alone. But in a symbolic or literary way, naming Dada as a symbol of Ambedkarite pride is powerful. It helps reclaim Dalit identity. This act has a declarative feel in the context of culture and social meaning.

Damu says “Atrocities, exploitations and inhuman treatment of upper castes provokes Dalits to question their identity.” (Jadhav p.19)

Speech Situation

In this quote, Damu—Narendra Jadhav’s father—talks about how Dalits are treated cruelly by upper castes. This pain and unfair treatment make Dalits question their identity. They begin to ask who they are and why they are treated this way. Damu shares these thoughts during a moment of reflection in the memoir. He is thinking deeply about how caste discrimination harms a person’s sense of self and dignity.

Speech Acts Analysis

Assertive: Damu speaks about the real-life struggles of Dalit people. The cruelty they face makes them question who they are. His words describe what they go through and help others understand their pain. He is not just sharing facts. He is showing a deep truth about how caste oppression shapes identity.

Directive: The above statement carries an implicit call to awareness. By highlighting the injustice, Damu may be urging Dalit people to reflect, resist, and seek change.

Commissive:  Damu shows his strong commitment to fight back against the atrocities, exploitation, and inhuman treatment by the upper castes. He refuses to stay silent or accept the injustice. His words and actions reflect deep resistance and moral courage. He stands up for dignity and demands change.

Expressive: Words like “atrocities” and “inhuman treatment” carry strong emotions. They show pain, anger, and a sense of injustice. Damu is not just telling what happened. He is sharing how caste violence affects Dalit identity. His words reflect deep emotional and moral feelings.

Declarative: Damu’s statement does not directly change anything. But it helps start a bigger conversation. It questions caste rules and gives new meaning to Dalit identity. It tries to declare dignity and challenge injustice.

Dr. Narendra Jadhav’s memoir reveals significant insights into how language functions in the expression of identity and resistance. By examining the speech acts within the text, we gain a deeper understanding of the author’s intentions and the impact of his narrative on readers. The words he employs serve to promote education, protest against caste-based discrimination, affirm identity, and inspire transformation. Ultimately, the memoir is aimed at achieving liberation from humiliation and asserting human dignity.

References

Austin, J.L. How to Do Things with Words. Harvard University Press, 1962.

Ambedkar, B.R. Annihilation of Caste. Navayana, 2014

Jadhav, Narendra. Out Caste: A Memoir. New Delhi: Penguin, 2003

Searle, John. Speech Acts: An Essay in the Philosophy of Language. Cambridge University Press, 1969.

Austin, J.L. How to Do Things with Words. Harvard University Press, 1962.

Ambedkar, B.R. Annihilation of Caste. Navayana, 2014

Daily writing prompt
If the salary was the same, what job would you be doing right now and why?

An Overview of Consumer Protection Law in the UK

Consumer protection in the UK is often discussed transaction by transaction – a specific refund dispute, a specific faulty product – but it is worth stepping back occasionally to see the structure behind those individual rules. Understanding who actually enforces consumer law, and under which legislation, changes how a dispute is approached from the very first message to a seller.

Two Statutes at the Core of the System

The current enforcement framework rests primarily on two pieces of legislation: the Consumer Rights Act 2015 and the more recent Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024. Between them, these two statutes cover contract quality, unfair trading practices, and the regulatory powers used to act against non-compliant businesses.

Who Actually Enforces These Rules

The Competition and Markets Authority is the principal national authority responsible for both competition and consumer protection in the UK, with a remit spanning competition law, consumer rights, the UK internal market, and subsidy control. It investigates cases, issues rulings, and can impose penalties directly, rather than simply advising on disputes from the sidelines.

The Role of Local Trading Standards

Alongside the CMA, Trading Standards services operate at a local level and remain the more accessible route for an individual consumer with a specific complaint. National Trading Standards coordinates cross-boundary, intelligence-led enforcement projects across England and Wales, bringing local representatives together to prioritise and fund cases that a single local authority could not realistically pursue alone. This two-tier structure – national authority plus local enforcement – is what allows both large-scale unfair trading investigations and individual local disputes to be addressed within the same overall system.

For an individual consumer or a small business trying to work out which rules actually apply to a specific dispute, this layered structure can be genuinely confusing. Rather than guessing which statute or regulator is relevant, a short session with Consultant platform usually clarifies the right starting point faster than searching through primary legislation directly.

Why the Structure Matters for Ordinary Disputes

Knowing that Trading Standards, not the CMA, is typically the first point of contact for an individual consumer complaint saves time that would otherwise be spent contacting the wrong body entirely. Conversely, patterns affecting many consumers – misleading pricing across an entire sector, for example – are more likely to fall within the CMA’s own investigative remit rather than a single local Trading Standards office.

A System Still in Motion

The 2024 Act significantly expanded the CMA’s direct enforcement powers, moving away from a system that relied heavily on court action for many cases. This shift is still being absorbed by businesses and consumers alike, which means guidance that was accurate under the older enforcement model may no longer reflect how a dispute is actually handled today.

Sector Regulators Add Another Layer

Certain industries – financial services, telecoms, energy – have their own dedicated regulators operating alongside the CMA and Trading Standards, each with concurrent powers to enforce consumer protection law within their specific sector. A dispute involving a broadband contract, for instance, may ultimately involve Ofcom’s framework rather than a general consumer protection route, even though the underlying legal principles overlap significantly with the Consumer Rights Act.

What This Means for Businesses Operating Across Sectors

A business that sells both general consumer goods and a regulated service, such as a retailer offering financing options alongside physical products, can find itself answerable to more than one regulatory body at once. Understanding which authority actually has jurisdiction over a specific complaint, before responding to it, avoids wasted effort addressing the wrong regulatory framework entirely.

Daily writing prompt
If you could go back and witness any historical event, which one would you pick?

Modeling a Fractured Electorate: What Phoenix’s Primary Results Reveal About AI-Driven Political Forecasting

Predicting voter behavior in rapidly growing metropolitan areas has become one of the more persistent challenges in political research, as population influx, uneven ballot-return timelines, and sharp intra-regional differences complicate any single statistical model. A recent test case from Arizona offers a data point worth examining.

Findings published by the Phoenix Herald indicate that G Ratings, a Florida-based political research firm, applied its AI forecasting platform, Odysseus, to Arizona’s 2026 Republican gubernatorial primary and produced a projection that came within 0.4 percentage points of the certified statewide result for winning candidate Andy Biggs — a 73.7% projection against an official tally of 73.3%.

Consistency Across Multiple Candidates

The precision extended beyond the top of the ticket. Runner-up David Schweikert was projected at 14.3%, against an official result of 14.7% — again a 0.4-point gap in the opposite direction. Lower-polling candidates Scott Neely and Ken Miceli were projected at 3.5% and 2.6% respectively, with official results coming in higher, at 7.1% and 4.7%. Averaged across all four candidates, the model produced a margin of error of 1.45%, a range the firm considers notable given the outsized influence Maricopa County’s vote volume typically exerts on statewide results.

The research context here matters. Metro Phoenix has expanded by hundreds of thousands of residents over the past decade, a growth pattern that complicates conventional polling methodology in several specific ways: new subdivisions in areas like Buckeye and Queen Creek bring in voters with no prior voting record to draw on, longer-established precincts such as Scottsdale tend to skew older and vote more predictably, and Maricopa County alone processes a volume of early ballots capable of shifting a statewide outcome within the final ten days before an election.

A Methodological Departure From Aggregate Modeling

Where conventional polling models often treat a metropolitan region as a single, internally consistent bloc, Odysseus was designed around the opposite assumption: that Phoenix functions as multiple overlapping electorates rather than one. According to the firm, the platform tracks localized digital sentiment and neighborhood-level discourse to estimate the intensity of voter support for a given candidate, cross-references that signal against county-level early-ballot return data as it accumulates day by day, and incorporates hyper-local economic indicators — distinguishing, for instance, between a ZIP code experiencing rising housing costs and one where inflation and fuel prices are the more dominant concern.

A G Ratings analyst involved in the project characterized the underlying rationale as a response to the speed at which the region’s political sentiment shifts, arguing that by the time a conventional phone survey concludes, the electorate it measured has already moved on — and that Odysseus was built to track that movement in near real time rather than publish a fixed snapshot that risks being outdated before release.

Implications for the General Election

With Maricopa County positioned as a likely deciding factor in the general election contest between Biggs and incumbent Governor Katie Hobbs, the primary results carry weight beyond a single data point. A model that tracked the region’s fragmented electorate to within roughly half a percentage point during the primary sets a specific benchmark that campaign strategists and researchers alike are likely to scrutinize as county-level vote counts take on national significance heading into the fall general election.

Open Questions for Further Study

Whether this level of precision is repeatable at a larger scale remains an open empirical question. A primary electorate is generally smaller, more ideologically homogenous, and easier to model than a general-election electorate, which draws in a broader and more demographically varied set of voters, greater turnout volume, and a longer, more volatile campaign period. Researchers evaluating AI-assisted forecasting tools will likely want to track whether Odysseus’s accuracy holds, narrows, or widens as it’s applied to a race with substantially different structural characteristics — a test that Arizona’s general election, given Maricopa County’s outsized role, may be well positioned to provide.

Daily writing prompt
If you had to give one life-changing tip, what would it be?

Socio-Cultural Life and Livelihood Practices of the Muthuvan Tribe: An Ethnographic Study in the Kurangani Hills, Tamil Nadu

Citation

Tamilselvi, M. (2026). Socio-Cultural Life and Livelihood Practices of the Muthuvan Tribe: An Ethnographic Study in the Kurangani Hills, Tamil Nadu. International Journal of Research, 13(3), 651–662. https://doi.org/10.26643/ijr/37

Dr. M. Tamilselvi,

Assistant Professor of History,

Jayaraj Annapackiam College for Women,

Periyakulam

Theni, Tamilnadu

tamilselvihistory@annejac.ac.in

Abstract

            India is home to a rich diversity of indigenous communities, many of whom have preserved distinct cultural traditions and ecological knowledge systems for centuries. Among these communities, the Muthuvan tribe inhabiting the hill ranges of the Western Ghats represents a unique example of indigenous adaptation to mountainous environments. The present study examines the socio-cultural life, livelihood practices, and gender roles within the Muthuvan tribal community residing in the Kurangani Hills of Tamil Nadu. The research draws upon field observations, oral narratives, and secondary literature related to tribal societies in South India. The findings indicate that the Muthuvan community maintains a close ecological relationship with forest resources and hill agriculture. Their social organization reflects strong kinship bonds, collective decision-making, and traditional leadership structures. Women play a crucial role in economic production, household management, and cultural transmission within the community. However, recent influences of modernization, market forces, and state-led development policies have gradually transformed aspects of their traditional lifestyle. This study highlights the importance of preserving indigenous knowledge while ensuring inclusive development through policy frameworks such as the Panchayats (Extension to Scheduled Areas) Act and international commitments related to indigenous rights and sustainable development.

Keywords: Tribal Communities, Muthuvan Tribe, Indigenous Culture, Kurangani Hills, Gender Roles, Sustainable Development

 Introduction

            India is home to a wide range of indigenous communities whose cultural traditions and livelihood systems have evolved in close interaction with their natural environment. According to the Census of India (2011), the Scheduled Tribe population in India constitutes 8.6 percent of the total population, amounting to more than 104 million people distributed across different ecological regions of the country. Many of these tribal communities inhabit forested and mountainous areas where traditional subsistence practices such as shifting cultivation, forest resource collection, and small-scale agriculture continue to shape their socio-economic life. The Western Ghats region of South India represents one of the most important ecological zones where several tribal communities continue to maintain traditional livelihood systems closely associated with forest ecosystems. These communities possess distinctive cultural traditions, settlement patterns, and indigenous knowledge that have been transmitted across generations. Among them, the Muthuvan Tribe inhabiting the hill regions of Tamil Nadu and Kerala occupies a unique position due to its strong cultural identity and ecological adaptation to mountainous environments. Early ethnographic studies conducted by scholars such as Edgar Thurston and Christoph von Furer-Haimendorf provided detailed descriptions of the social organization, customs, and cultural traditions of tribal communities in South India. Their works highlighted the diversity of tribal societies and emphasized the importance of understanding indigenous institutions within their ecological and historical contexts. Subsequent contributions by Indian scholars further explored issues such as tribal economy, social change, and the relationship between tribal communities and mainstream society. Within this broader framework, the present study focuses on the socio-cultural life and livelihood practices of the Muthuvan tribal community residing in the Kurangani Hills of Tamil Nadu. By examining their settlement patterns, economic activities, gender roles, and cultural traditions, the study seeks to understand how indigenous communities maintain their traditional identity while simultaneously responding to the pressures of modernization and development.

Review of Literature

            The academic study of tribal communities in India has developed through significant contributions from anthropologists, sociologists, and historians who have attempted to document the diverse cultural traditions and social institutions of indigenous groups. Early ethnographic studies provided detailed descriptions of tribal customs, rituals, kinship patterns, and social organization. One of the pioneering works in this field is that of Edgar Thurston, whose classic ethnographic study Castes and Tribes of Southern India remains an important reference for understanding the cultural characteristics and social organization of many communities in South India. Similarly, Christoph von Furer-Haimendorf conducted extensive anthropological fieldwork among tribal societies and emphasized the relatively higher social status and social participation enjoyed by women in several tribal communities. Indian scholars have also made important contributions to the understanding of tribal cultures and social change. L. P. Vidyarthi highlighted the ecological relationship between tribal societies and their natural environment and developed the concept of the “sacred complex” in tribal studies. Likewise, S. C. Dube examined the processes of modernization, cultural change, and the interaction between tribal communities and mainstream society.

In recent years, several empirical studies have focused specifically on the Muthuvan tribal community of the Western Ghats. For instance, studies have analyzed the relationship between traditional socio-cultural practices and health-related behavior among the Muthuvan community, as well as indigenous knowledge systems and community responses during the COVID-19 pandemic. Furthermore, local researchers in the Theni district have provided vital contemporary insights. Scholars such as Ramya, Sivaselvi, Kausalya, and Maheswaran have collaborated to publish significant data on the tribal people of the region in their work titled Traditional Walk of the Tribes. Their documentation reveals that while there are many tribal sects in Tamil Nadu, they are heavily concentrated in areas like Andipatti, Periyakulam, Bodinayakanur, and Kadamaikundu. However, a review of the existing literature reveals that a considerable portion of the research on the Muthuvan community has largely concentrated on settlements located in Kerala, especially in the Munnar region. While these studies provide valuable ethnographic insights, comparatively limited scholarly attention has been given to the Muthuvan settlements in the Kurangani hill region of Tamil Nadu. Therefore, the present study seeks to address this research gap by examining the socio-cultural life and livelihood practices of the Muthuvan tribal community in the Kurangani Hills, thereby contributing new field-based insights to the existing body of tribal studies.

Methodology

The present study was conducted in the Kurangani hill region located near Bodinayakanur in Theni District of Tamil Nadu. Kurangani forms part of the southern ranges of the Western Ghats, a biodiversity-rich mountain system known for its ecological diversity and indigenous tribal settlements. The region is characterized by steep hill slopes, dense forest cover, and plantation-based agriculture. Several tribal communities inhabit the Western Ghats, among which the Muthuvan tribe constitutes an important indigenous group residing in the hill settlements of the Kurangani region. These settlements are generally located in relatively remote areas and maintain close interaction with forest resources and hill agriculture for their livelihood. The geographical isolation of the region has enabled the community to preserve many of its traditional socio-cultural practices and indigenous knowledge systems. The present study adopts a qualitative research design in order to explore the socio-cultural life and livelihood practices of the Muthuvan tribal community. A purposive sampling method was adopted, which allowed the researcher to select respondents who possess relevant knowledge about the community’s cultural traditions, occupational practices, and social organization. Through purposive sampling, individuals such as community elders, women, and working members of the settlement were selected for interaction and discussion. The field investigation covered selected Muthuvan tribal settlements located in the Kurangani hills. A total of 20 households were included in the study for detailed observation and interaction. Informal discussions and interviews were conducted with approximately 35 to 60 respondents, including elders, adult men, and women belonging to the community. The fieldwork for the present study was conducted between June 2024 and January 2025. Primary data were collected through direct field observation and informal interviews, while secondary data were collected from books, research articles, government reports, and institutional publications related to tribal studies. The collected data were analyzed using descriptive and interpretative methods to present a comprehensive account of the socio-cultural life of the Muthuvan tribe in the Kurangani hill region.

4. Origin and Migration

The Muthuvan tribe inhabiting the hill regions of the Western Ghats possesses a distinct cultural identity and a strong sense of historical memory preserved through oral traditions. According to community narratives and ethnographic interpretations, the ancestral homeland of the Muthuvans is believed to be the ancient Pandya region, particularly around Madurai in present-day Tamil Nadu. Oral traditions collected during field interactions indicate that their ancestors migrated from the plains to the forested hill tracts of the Western Ghats during a period of political conflict and social disturbance in the Pandya country. The etymology of the term “Muthuvan” has been interpreted in different ways. One explanation derives the word from the Tamil term “muthu,” meaning ancient or old, suggesting that the community represents an ancient lineage. Another explanation is associated with the traditional practice of carrying children and belongings on their backs during migration, which symbolically reflects the community’s historical movement from the plains to the mountainous forests. Some scholars also suggest that the earlier form of the name may have been “Muthukkar,” meaning “those who carry on their backs,” which gradually evolved into the present form “Muthuvan” in spoken usage. Following their migration, the community gradually established settlements in the forested regions of the Western Ghats, particularly in areas that now fall within the boundaries of Tamil Nadu and Kerala. Despite geographical dispersion, the Muthuvan community has continued to preserve its traditional practices, language, and cultural identity through collective memory and oral traditions.

5. Lifestyle and Settlement Pattern

The lifestyle and settlement pattern of the Muthuvan tribe reflects their close relationship with nature and their historical experience of migration and isolation. The Muthuvans mainly inhabit the hill regions of the Western Ghats, particularly the coffee hills and cardamom hills, where they establish settlements in remote mountainous areas away from mainstream society. Their settlements are usually located several kilometers away from major roads or bus routes, making them difficult for outsiders to access. This pattern of settlement is believed to have developed as a protective strategy after the community migrated to the hills. The Muthuvans live in small huts known as kudi, which are constructed using natural materials such as grass and fibre. These huts are simple structures designed for small families, usually without separate rooms, and traditionally they do not have doors, reflecting the strong sense of trust and unity within the community. The huts are not arranged in a regular pattern but are scattered across hills and valleys according to the natural terrain and the preference of the inhabitants.

Traditionally, the Muthuvans depended on forest resources such as honey, roots, and tubers for their livelihood. Over time, due to food scarcity and environmental changes, they began cultivating crops in nearby lands and practicing small-scale agriculture. At present, their livelihood includes collecting forest produce, cultivating small plots of land, and working as labourers in plantations owned by outsiders. Some lands that once belonged to the Muthuvans were gradually transferred to estate owners through monetary transactions, largely due to the community’s limited exposure to external economic systems. The social life of the Muthuvan community is traditionally based on cooperation, equality, and collective responsibility, with little distinction between rich and poor. A community leader chosen by the people manages common affairs and resolves disputes within the settlement. The food habits of the Muthuvans have also evolved over time; earlier they consumed roasted tubers and hunted animals, while later they cultivated crops such as millets and pulses. Today their diet includes grains like ragi, millet, and rice obtained through the public distribution system, along with vegetables and meat such as goat, chicken, and hunted animals. Their clothing style has also changed over time. Earlier they used leaves and simple cloth, whereas today men wear traditional garments such as dhotis and shirts, while women wear sarees in a distinctive style that allows them to carry children on their backs.

6. Occupation and Economy

Occupation plays a vital role in shaping the economic livelihood and social life of the Muthuvan tribe. Traditionally, the occupational practices of the Muthuvans are closely connected with the natural environment of the Western Ghats, where they have lived for generations. Their occupations are diverse and mainly include handicraft production, small-scale agriculture, plantation labour, collection of forest products such as tubers and honey, and limited trade. Living in close harmony with nature, the Muthuvans utilize forest resources to produce many items required for their daily life. They weave baskets, winnowing trays (muram), mats, and fishing nets using bamboo and mountain fibres such as eetha fibre. These handicrafts are usually produced for household use rather than for commercial sale and therefore emphasize practicality and durability rather than decoration. They also manufacture musical instruments used during rituals and festivals, such as the Urumi Kattai, made by hollowing wood and covering it with animal skin. In addition, the Muthuvans build their own huts using forest materials, demonstrating their traditional knowledge of indigenous construction techniques.

Agriculture is another important livelihood activity. The community cultivates crops such as tomato, brinjal, beans, garlic, ginger, and other vegetables, and in some areas they grow paddy using water from nearby streams for irrigation. They also cultivate grains such as millets, varagu, samai, and cholam, while a few families maintain small cardamom and coffee plantations. Forest resources continue to play a crucial role in their subsistence economy. Tubers collected from the forest serve as an important food source for several months of the year, while women regularly collect firewood for domestic use. Due to historical developments such as forest reservation policies and the expansion of plantation agriculture, many Muthuvans have also become wage labourers in nearby coffee and cardamom estates, where they work in activities such as harvesting, weeding, and pruning. Honey collection remains one of their traditional skills, involving the use of smoke and ropes made from forest creepers to gather honey from cliffs and trees. While most handicrafts are not produced for sale, honey and certain agricultural products such as garlic, ginger, coffee, and cardamom may be sold in nearby markets. Hunting, which was once an important activity among Muthuvan men for protection and food, has significantly declined due to wildlife protection laws, though small animals may still occasionally be trapped for consumption.

7. Rituals, Religious Beliefs, and Festivals

The ritual and religious life of the Muthuvan tribe reflects their simple social organization, strong communal values, and deep connection with nature. Life-cycle ceremonies such as childbirth, puberty, marriage, and death are performed in modest ways within the settlement. Childbirth usually takes place in a separate hut with the assistance of women from the community, and the mother and child remain in seclusion for about thirty days before a small ritual meal is organised by the maternal uncle. Children are named after deities and ear piercing is performed in early childhood. When a girl attains puberty, she is kept in temporary seclusion for a few days before being ceremonially brought back to the settlement. Marriage among the Muthuvans is generally based on mutual consent rather than arranged by parents, and symbolic gifts such as bangles or sarees represent marital union. Widow remarriage is permitted, and the community largely follows a monogamous system. In earlier times, unmarried youth stayed in separate dormitories that helped maintain social discipline and communal interaction. Funeral practices are also simple; the deceased are buried, and ritual meals are conducted on the second and thirtieth days after death.

Religious beliefs occupy an important place in Muthuvan society. The community worships both major Hindu deities and local guardian spirits, with Murugan regarded as the principal deity. Other deities such as Veera Sankara Rayaru, Mupporulu, Tharan Thambiran, Meenakshi Amman, Bhadrakali, and Mariamman are also venerated. Worship is usually conducted in small temples or temporary shrines within the settlement where pictures of deities are placed instead of idols. Festivals form an important part of their cultural life, and among them Thai Pongal is the most significant celebration, involving collective cooking, ritual offerings, music, dance, and communal feasting. Other festivals such as Karthigai Deepam and Chithirai New Year are observed in simpler forms. Ancestor worship and nature worship, particularly prayers for rain and offerings to the Sun, remain integral to their belief system. In recent times, contact with neighbouring towns and participation in external festivals have introduced certain changes, yet the Muthuvan community continues to preserve its traditional rituals, religious beliefs, and collective cultural identity.

8. Oral Traditions and Folk Elements

The oral traditions of the Muthuvan tribe constitute an important part of their cultural heritage and are transmitted from generation to generation through songs, stories, beliefs, and traditional knowledge. Folk expressions among the community include lullabies, ritual songs, love songs, friendship songs, and songs associated with elopement and courtship. These songs reflect various aspects of social life, including affection between lovers, family relationships, and emotional experiences similar to themes found in classical Tamil literature. Lullabies are sung by mothers to soothe children, while ritual songs are performed during ceremonies such as puberty rites. Love songs are sung by men and women to express mutual affection, and some songs also describe the longing and emotional bonds between lovers. In addition to songs, storytelling forms another element of their oral tradition, with simple narratives often told to entertain children. Traditional knowledge of medicine is also preserved through oral transmission, and the community commonly treats illnesses using herbal remedies, roots, and leaves collected from the forest. Various beliefs and magical practices remain part of their worldview, including rituals to ward off evil spirits, protect against wild animals, and interpret omens. The Muthuvans also traditionally calculated time based on lunar phases and agricultural cycles. Although modern influences such as hospitals, calendars, and external cultural contacts have introduced certain changes, many of these oral traditions and folk practices continue to be preserved, reflecting the community’s close relationship with nature and its enduring cultural identity.

9. Contemporary Challenges and Discussion

Although the Muthuvan community has preserved many aspects of its traditional socio-cultural system, it currently faces several challenges associated with socio-economic change and environmental pressures. One of the major challenges is the gradual transformation of traditional livelihood systems due to restrictions on forest access, environmental regulations, and the expansion of tourism and development activities in the Western Ghats region. Educational opportunities and interaction with mainstream society have created new aspirations among younger generations. While these developments provide opportunities for socio-economic mobility, they also contribute to cultural transformation and, in some cases, the weakening of traditional institutions. The shift from traditional occupations to wage labour and other forms of employment has also altered patterns of community organization and economic cooperation.

During the field investigation, it was observed that the community faces specific logistical and safety hurdles. The lack of indoor sanitation facilities creates a high risk of wildlife conflict during the night, necessitating the implementation of bio-toilets for community safety. Furthermore, children who attend residential schools often face difficulties returning home during holidays; arranging transport like Forest Department Jeeps and maintaining accessible paths are crucial for educational retention. The aspiration of the youth is exemplified by individuals such as Sridevi, who is pursuing higher education and represents the potential for the tribe to participate in administrative governance, such as the IAS. Language preservation represents another significant challenge. As younger members increasingly engage with formal education and urban environments, the transmission of indigenous language and oral traditions within the household becomes more limited. Consequently, community-based initiatives aimed at documenting and promoting traditional knowledge have become increasingly important.

10. Conclusion

The findings of the present study reveal that the socio-cultural life of the Muthuvan community in the Kurangani hills reflects a close relationship between environment, tradition, and community organization. Historical narratives regarding the origin and migration of the Muthuvans indicate that their settlement in the hill regions was closely associated with the search for security, autonomy, and access to forest resources. Over time, the community developed a distinctive cultural system characterized by collective living patterns, strong kinship relations, and a deep dependence on forest-based livelihoods. Traditional institutions such as kinship networks, ritual practices, and oral traditions continue to play a vital role in maintaining social cohesion and cultural identity within the community. At the same time, the study reveals that contemporary socio-economic changes, educational mobility, and increased interaction with mainstream society have introduced new challenges for the preservation of indigenous culture. Policy frameworks and development programmes should adopt a culturally sensitive approach that respects the knowledge systems, traditions, and rights of indigenous communities. Sustainable development strategies must therefore integrate traditional ecological knowledge with modern development initiatives in order to ensure both socio-economic progress and cultural preservation for tribal communities in the Western Ghats.

References

  • Dwarakanth, G. (1999). Socio-cultural history of our Indian caste. Mittal Publication.
  • Francis, W. (1906). Madras District Gazetteers. Government Publication.
  • Gupta, L. P. (2004). Administration for educational development of tribes. Classical Publication.
  • Jagadisa Ayyar, P. V. (1978). South Indian customs. Ashish Publishing House.
  • KIRTADS. (2019). An ethnography of housing of Muthuvan community in Idukki district of Kerala: Prospects and policy. Prepared by M. Narayan & S. Sivadasan. Directorate of Kerala Institute for Research Training and Development Studies of Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes.
  • Mahapatra, M. D. (2001). Tribal religion and rituals. Dominant Publication.
  • Manjusha, K. A. (2017). Lights and shadows of tribal development in Kerala: A study on the Muthuvan tribe of Edamalakkudy tribal settlement in Idukki district. Artha-Journal of Social Sciences, 16(2), 75-85. https://doi.org/10.12724/ajss.41.5
  • Mishra, K. K. (1996). Tribal elites and social transformation. Inter-India Publications.
  • Mishra, R. N. (2002). Tribal life and habitat. Ritu Publication.
  • Nelson, J. H. (1989). The Madura country: A manual. Asian Educational Services.
  • Pradeep Kumar, K. S. (2018). The trajectory of tribal development practice: The case of Muthuvan community in Kerala. International Journal of Research and Analytical Reviews (IJRAR), 5(3), 269-275.
  • Ramasamy, A. (1972). Gazetteers of India, Tamil Nadu State: Ramanathapuram District. Government of Tamil Nadu.
  • Santhipriya, S. (2019). Livelihood pattern of Muthuvan tribe in Kuttampuzha forest, Western Ghats [Unpublished research paper]. School of Gandhian Thought and Development Studies, M.G. University.
  • Singh, K. S. (1998). India’s communities (National Series Volume VI). Oxford University Press.
  • Somalay. (1980). Madurai maavattam. K.G.K.G. Publication.
  • Thurston, E. (1998). Castes and tribes of Southern India (Vol. III). Government Press.
  • Vikatan. (2025, August 9). World Tribal Day: “Life of tribes displaced from forests” – What does the research report say? Ananda Vikatan.
Daily writing prompt
What strategies do you use to cope with negative feelings?

Exploring the Place of the AU in Fighting Organised Crime in Africa

Daily writing prompt
What experiences in life helped you grow the most?

Citation

Nwokoroeze, C. N. (2026). Exploring the Place of the AU in Fighting Organised Crime in Africa. International Journal of Research, 13(3), 18–29. https://doi.org/10.26643/ijr/2

Nwokoroeze, Chinonye Nnenna 

Department of Political Science,

Faculty of Social Sciences and Humanities, Enugu State University of Science and Technology, Agbani Email: chinonye.nwokoroeze@esut.edu.ng  

ORCID: https://orcid.org/0009-0008-0449-9036

Abstract

The African continent faces a persistent and expanding threat from organised crime. These criminal networks operate across borders, harming peace, security, and economy. The AU  has taken on a critical mission to address these complex concerns. A rising understanding of the interdependence of stability and development throughout the continent is reflected in its shift from a non-interventionist stance to a more proactive involvement in peace and security. This article addresses the AU’s initiatives to prevent organised crime, analysing its established normative frameworks and the practical restrictions that often hinder its usefulness. The study employs a qualitative technique, drawing on secondary data from official AU publications, United Nations reports, and academic literature. The study contends that even though the AU has created a wide range of legal and policy tools, their influence is usually diminished by barriers to cross-border collaboration, a lack of persistent political commitment, and a lack of financial and technical resources. The conclusion emphasises the ongoing disconnect between idealistic aspirations and practical reality. It promotes enhancing the AU’s participation in the fight against organised crime by encouraging greater political resolve and improved resource mobilisation.

Keywords: AU, Organized Crime, Threat, Resources mobilization, United Nations

Introduction

The paper used a 2024 UNODC research to show that organised crime makes violence worse in places like the Sahel and is a vital source of cash for people who are economically challenged. This means that organised crime is not merely a business; it is firmly ingrained in the social and economic institutions of some communities, which makes it a very tough problem to overcome. For example, the drug problem is a concern in all five African regions. The continent has become a key transit route, user, and source for drugs including cocaine and heroin. (2019, the African Union).
The United Nations (2025) said that human trafficking is a severe violation of human rights. It is a sort of modern-day slavery in which traffickers target people who are weak, like those who are poor, in conflict, or displaced. A lot of people are trafficked across borders from Africa, and this is often linked to war, being forced to leave home, and poverty (Tefera, 2019). Illicit financial flows (IFFs) make these difficulties worse by taking $88.6 billion out of Africa’s economy every year, which is 3.7% of the continent’s gross domestic product (GDP) (United Nations, 2021). These outflows make it hard to make essential investments in education, health, and productive sectors, which keeps the cycle of underdevelopment running. Because these problems are connected, organised crime is both a cause of conflict and an indication of underdevelopment. The money earned from unlawful operations promotes wars and degrades institutions and democracy (Thelma et al., 2024). At the same time, the instability and poverty that result from these activities make it easier for criminal networks to emerge as a way to live. This makes things worse and worse.

The African Union (AU) formally takes the place of the Organization of African Unity (OAU) in 2002. The AU was formed up by the Constitutive Act in 2000 (Maluwa, 2012). This transition was a huge step away from the OAU’s stance of not becoming involved and toward a more comprehensive and collective action approach to peace, security, and stability on the continent (ACCORD, 2024). The Peace and Security Council (PSC) is the African Union’s key body for making decisions about how to stop, handle, and settle disputes. This is a fundamental feature of the African Peace and Security Architecture (APSA) (African Union [AU]). The PSC is quite powerful. It can stop and avoid wars, make peace, build peace, approve peace support missions, and deal with challenges including unconstitutional changes of government and transnational organised crime (ACCORD, 2024).


This amendment in the AU’s mission illustrates that there is an increasing, albeit tough, commitment to proactive security governance. Organised crime is a significant security concern, as evidenced by the PSC’s 2019 decision to make a yearly conference on transnational organised crime a permanent agenda item (AmaniAfrica, 2025). However, the fact that this annual session has not been consistently held since its institutionalisation, last meeting in May 2022, and the general problems mentioned with the PSC’s reactive approach and slow response (ACCORD, 2024), show that while the normative framework is in place, the political will and practical application to fully realise this proactive mandate are still not consistent. This illustrates the fundamental argument of this article—that there is a discrepancy between the declared purpose and what actually occurs. This article’s objective is to examine the African Union’s regulations for combating organised crime and identify the obstacles to its complete implementation. It examines the various forms of organised crime that are prevalent in Africa, the AU’s legal and policy instruments, the issues that arise when these instruments are applied, and the collaborations and initiatives taken to combat these threats.

A full collection of legal and policy tools of the AU

  1. The Assembly’s Special Declaration on Illicit Financial Flows (2015). This declaration committed AU leaders to eliminating persistent illicit financial flows and guaranteeing the recovery of lost financial resources to Africa to support the continent’s development agenda. It called for African institutions and skills to be improved in areas like recovering stolen property, collecting taxes, and making contracts (United Nations, 2021).
  2. The African Union’s Constitutive Act, which was passed in 2000, replaced the OAU Charter. This marked a big change in how the continent deals with peace and security (Maluwa, 2012). The OAU was mostly based on the idea that its member states shouldn’t interfere in each other’s internal affairs. This made it hard for the OAU to deal with internal crises or problems with governance (UNODC, 2018). The AU, on the other hand, gave the “right of the Union to intervene in a Member State pursuant to a decision of the Assembly in respect of grave circumstances, namely: war crimes, genocide and crimes against humanity” (African Union, 2000, p. 9). This development provided a more robust legal foundation for the AU to actively address peace and security issues, particularly those concerning transnational organised crime.
  3. The African Union Convention on Preventing and Combating Corruption (AUCPCC, 2003). This convention, which was signed in Maputo, shows that everyone in the region agrees on how to stop, punish, and encourage international cooperation in the fight against corruption. It includes a wide range of crimes, such as bribery, illegal enrichment, money laundering, and asset recovery (African Union, 2024a). It also calls for the end of corruption in both the public and private sectors (African Union, 2003). As of January 2020, 43 states had signed this agreement.
  4. The African Union Plan of Action on Drug Control and Crime Prevention (AUPA, 2019–2023). This strategy framework, which is the fifth of its kind, promotes a balanced, integrated, and multi-sectoral approach to drug control and crime prevention. It is based on what happened at the 2016 UN General Assembly Special Session (UNGASS) on the world’s drug problem. The AUPA has a lot of different ways to cut down on drug use and supply, stop crime, reform the criminal justice system, and work together with other countries to stop drug trafficking, guns, corruption, and money laundering (African Union, 2019).
  5. The Protocol Relating to the Establishment of the Peace and Security Council of the African Union, which was signed in 2002, made the AU’s security role more effective (ACCORD, 2024). Karahalios (Karahalios, 2021) says that the PSC was set up to be the main group that makes decisions about how to stop, handle, and solve conflicts. Its mission is to deal with new dangers, like international organised crime. This change in the law from non-interference to interventionism creates the necessary normative space for anti-crime action. This lets the AU see and treat problems like organised crime as threats to peace and security on the continent. Without this basic change, many of the later anti-crime agreements would not have a clear legal basis for continental involvement. It is important to create this normative space, but it is not enough on its own because other things are needed to make it happen.
  6. The African Union’s 2013 plan for controlling the illegal spread, circulation, and trafficking of small arms and light weapons. The goal of this plan is to stop, stop, and completely get rid of the illegal spread of SALW across all of Africa. AmaniAfrica (2022) says that it is focused on building capacity, getting stakeholders to work together and coordinate better, and improving international aid.
  7. The Ouagadougou Action Plan to Stop Human Trafficking, Especially for Women and Children (2006). The goal of this strategy is to create general guidelines for fighting human trafficking, raise awareness and prevention, protect and help victims, put in place the right legal frameworks, improve law enforcement, and encourage cooperation. It stresses a “three-pronged strategy” of Prevention, Protection, and Prosecution d) Niamey Convention on Cross-Border Cooperation (2014). This was put in place to encourage cooperation between countries and the peaceful resolution of border disputes. This convention also says that countries should work together to stop piracy, terrorism, and cross-border crime. It needs 15 countries to sign it before it can go into effect (African Union, 2024a).
  8. The Assembly’s Special Declaration on Illicit Financial Flows (2015). This declaration committed AU leaders to eliminating persistent illicit financial flows and guaranteeing the recovery of lost financial resources to Africa to support the continent’s development agenda. It called for African institutions and skills to be improved in areas like recovering stolen property, collecting taxes, and making contracts (United Nations, 2021).

The evolving environment of transnational organised crime in Africa

Illegal use of natural resources: UNODC (2025) claims that organised crime groups play a major role in illicit gold mining, which harms the environment and is fuelled by money laundering, fraud, and corruption. Trafficking in wildlife is also a big problem. Perche et al. (2020) say that organised crime groups that make money off of endangered species are often involved. Organised crime relies heavily on taking advantage of natural resources, which makes environmental problems and problems with governance worse. This shows that illegally taking resources can be a big source of income for criminal gangs, which means that environmental crimes and financial crimes that weaken government control are linked. So, strong management of the natural resource sectors and dealing with the social and economic factors that make people want to illegally exploit resources are both important parts of successful counter-TOC efforts.


Drug trafficking
: The United States Department of State Bureau for International Narcotics and Law Enforcement Affairs (2024) says that West and Central Africa are becoming important places for cocaine and heroin to pass through on their way to Europe. These drugs often come from South America and Afghanistan. According to the United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime (UNODC) World Drug Report 2020, cocaine seizures in Africa rose by 66% in 2018 and were expected to rise even more in 2019. This shows that Africa is becoming more important as a transit region (UNODC, 2020). This shows that the problem is getting worse because the continent is now a growing market and supply for illegal drugs, as well as a transit hub. For instance, Nigeria and South Africa have shut down illegal methamphetamine labs (UNODC, 2020). The study also found that tramadol, an opioid that isn’t monitored by any international body, is a serious public health issue, especially in West and Central Africa, where it was responsible for 79% of all seizures in 2018. This change in Africa’s role in the global drug market from mainly a transit point to also a place where drugs are made and used means that counter-narcotics strategies must now be multi-faceted, with the goal of fighting both supply and demand on the continent.


Illicit financial flows (IFFs): It noted that the significant loss, amounting to 3.7% of the continent’s GDP, hinders development and exacerbates poverty and inequality. IFFs are closely linked to other illegal activities, like drug trafficking, human trafficking, and selling weapons illegally (African Union, 2024a). These flows are a major roadblock to African development and a major facilitator of other organised crimes. They make conflicts worse and get in the way of sustainable development by weakening institutions and democracy, shrinking the tax base, and taking important resources away from public services like healthcare and education (African Union, 2024a). The estimated $88.6 billion lost each year is a sign of lost opportunities for growth, lost jobs, and rising poverty. This means that fighting IFFs is not only important for keeping money safe, but it is also necessary for long-term growth and stopping crime.

Smuggling migrants and trafficking people : Human trafficking is a serious violation of human rights that is often called “modern-day According to UNODC (2024a), Africa is the source of the most destinations, both inside and outside the continent. One-third of all cross-border human trafficking flows involve people from Africa. The data shows that the number of child victims is alarmingly rising. In Africa in 2022, kids made up 38% of all victims found. Traffickers use technology to lure victims by working online and using social media and encrypted communication tools (United Nations, 2025). This digital growth of human trafficking is scary because it lets criminal groups reach more people and take advantage of them more easily. This shows that technology can be both helpful and harmful, as it can be used by criminals in new ways. Because of this, cybersecurity and digital forensics must be part of anti-trafficking efforts. But the strong link to vulnerable groups shows that technology fixes alone aren’t enough. It’s still important to deal with the root causes of vulnerability, like poverty and violence.

Bringing weapons into the country illegally: Firearms trafficking is a major cause of conflicts, especially in places like the Sahel (AmaniAfrica, 2025). UNODC (2024) says that most of the guns that are trafficked illegally come from legitimate manufacturers but are sold on the black market. This highlights a critical area for intervention. It means that illegal arms trafficking is the most profitable illegal business, allowing organised crime groups to protect their illegal businesses and employees. It is not just a crime on its own; it is also a key part of the whole criminal ecosystem, which includes drug trafficking and illegal use of natural resources. So, limiting the flow of weapons is a good way to break up organised crime groups and bring about peace.

Challenges confronting the AU

  1. Different national laws and rules could make it very hard for regions to work together to fight organised crime. To get around these legal problems, it is important to make national laws more similar and adopt universal standards. This is a big legal problem for transnational crime because criminals take advantage of gaps in jurisdiction. The Niamey Convention aims to promote integrated border management and cross-border cooperation (Cassidy-Neumiller et al., 2024). The University for Peace (2022) says that Africa is a good place for illegal businesses and organised crime because of its porous borders and areas that are not controlled. Criminal groups use these open borders to start their activities in very organised and complicated ways, which makes the borders unsafe. Another problem with international cooperation in criminal cases is that people don’t work together when there aren’t any relevant bilateral agreements (UN General Assembly, 2025). It is hard to get mutual legal aid agreements, which makes it hard to prosecute criminals across borders even when they are found. This means that even though the AU has ways for member states to work together, it is often hard to put them into action because of the rights of each member state and the problems that come with enforcing laws across borders. There is a natural conflict between national sovereignty and the international nature of crime that causes legal and practical problems.
  2.  Even though AU leaders have promised to do better, they have shown a “persistent lack of genuine and sustained political will,” which has made it hard for them to deal with important problems, such as armed conflicts that hurt civilians and widespread attacks on basic rights (ICG, 2025). The AU’s response to crises is often inconsistent, and sometimes they use the principle of subsidiarity to regional authorities as an excuse not to act.70 There is a big difference between what the AU says it will do and what the member states are actually doing to make it happen and pay for it.  The chaotic running of the Sudanese civil war, where strong African leadership was badly needed but never happened, and the AU Commission’s silence during the fighting in Ethiopia’s Tigray area are two examples of this gap.67 The AU’s power has also gone down in the central Sahel. This is mostly because there hasn’t been a consistent political commitment to staff and give power to its regional offices to help solve conflicts.67 The AU has a big problem because it has to follow the Lomé Declaration, which says that states must be suspended after illegal transfers of administration. This is in line with democratic norms, but some African leaders are starting to realise that keeping lines of communication open with military governments is very important. This makes it hard for everyone to work together.67 This shows that the problem isn’t just a lack of resources; it’s also about how member states work together and prioritise turning continental goals into national action, which can be hard when national interests are at odds with each other. Such discrepancies directly undermine the efficacy of the normative frameworks.
  3. The AU’s ability to deal with peace and security issues is always limited by a lack of resources (International Crisis Group [ICG] 2025). The AU Peace Fund was started in 1993 and then revived in 2018. Its goal is to provide long-term funding for peace and security projects, especially those that fight organised crime. The fund reached its initial goal of $400 million by mid-2024, mostly from member states. However, this is still far less than the huge cost of dealing with Africa’s wars (Soumahoro, 2025). Soumahoro (2025) says that the AU Transition Mission in Somalia (ATMIS) cost $1.5 billion a year in 2023. This shows how big the gap is between the money that is available and the needs of the mission. The AU and UN need to work together to fill the 25% burden-sharing gap left by UN Security Council Resolution 2719, which says that UN-assessed contributions can only cover 75% of AU-led peace assistance operations (Zeyede, 2025). This means that even with strong rules and guidelines, the AU can’t do large-scale, long-term anti-crime measures because it doesn’t have enough reliable money. This reliance on foreign funding and unpredictable internal contributions is a major threat to the AU’s ability to do its job. Also, it is still hard to fight some crimes, like human trafficking and smuggling migrants, because there aren’t enough resources to do so. This has a direct effect on how well intelligence sharing and operational responses can be funded.
  4. African countries are very worried about not having enough resources. This is true in fields like digital forensics and electronic evidence. This is often because the technology infrastructure is weak, people don’t have enough digital skills, and they don’t have enough money (UN General Assembly, 2025). This means that even with laws in place, it is very hard to look into modern crimes like cybercrime. Coordination among various AU entities responsible for combating transnational organised crime continues to be hindered by resource limitations and insufficient horizontal integration (AmaniAfrica, 2025). This means that the digital and human infrastructure needed to fight cross-border crime is not good enough, which gives criminal networks a chance to take advantage of operational weaknesses. Also, some people are said to be unwilling to share important information, which makes it harder to stop human trafficking and migrant smuggling (Development Policy and Performance Portal, 2025).

The operational responses and partnerships of the AU

  1. The Continental Operational Centre (COC) for trafficking in persons and smuggling of migrants. A practical reaction to diverse forms of crime is illustrated by the formation of specialised operations centers. The Continental Operational Center (COC) for Trafficking in Persons (TIP) and Smuggling of Migrants (SOM), formed in 2019, is a significant part of Africa’s efforts to curb irregular migration (African Union, 2024b). A structured framework for collaboration between member states, Regional Economic Communities (RECs), and law enforcement agencies was established in December 2024 when the COC validated continental guidelines for information and intelligence sharing to combat TIP and SOM, according to Development Policy and Performance Portal (2025). This shows that the AU is developing specific operational institutions in order to move beyond broad mandates, realising that complex situations require specialised expertise and a coordinated response.
  2.  Partnerships with UNODC, INTERPOL, and Regional Economic Communities (RECs). External collaboration and regional integration are vital force for the AU’s anti-crime initiatives. The AU works closely with international partners like UNODC and INTERPOL to promote police cooperation and counter transnational threats across the continent (INTERPOL. (n.d.)). The African Union and INTERPOL’s Special Representative Office in Addis Ababa work closely to establish synergies and ensuring that the law enforcement voice is heard in AU initiatives. The PSC has also recommended for coordinated actions with the Committee of Intelligence and Security Services of Africa (CISSA), INTERPOL, and UNODC to identify and assess unlawful flows (AmaniAfrica, 2025). These partnerships offer vital operational support, information sharing, training, and technical assistance that the AU and its member nations frequently lack internally (UN General Assembly, 2025). Furthermore, the AU fosters the harmonisation and coordination of activities between regional mechanisms, such as the Regional Economic Communities (RECs) and Regional Mechanisms (RMs), and the AU itself, in the promotion of peace, security, and stability (ACCORD, 2024). RECs are vital for establishing constraints against tiny firearms and light weapons.
  3. The role of AFRIPOL’s initiatives and the Peace and Security Council (PSC): The PSC is responsible for managing, preventing, and resolving disputes and is the primary pillar of the African Peace and Security Architecture (APSA). It has regularly expressed worry over the expansion of transnational organised crime in Africa (AmaniAfrica, 2025). A formal recognition and priority of the problem may be shown in the PSC’s 2019 decision to create an annual session on transnational organised crime as a standing agenda item. Also, AFRIPOL, founded as the continent’s law enforcement coordination mechanism, is a significant institutional framework designed to cope with transnational organised crime. It provides a framework for police coordination at strategic, tactical, and operational levels throughout African states (Soumahoro, 2025). The execution of “Operation TAPI,” a cross-border project carried out by AFRIPOL in collaboration with INTERPOL, is a concrete illustration of AFRIPOL’s impact on the ground. This program, which encompasses six AU member nations, tackles a variety of criminal activities, such as drug trafficking, pharmaceuticals, guns, counterfeit or smuggled commodities, and environmental crimes (AmaniAfrica, 2025).

Conclusion

In order to combat organised crime throughout the continent, the African Union has made impressive progress in creating a comprehensive normative framework. The OAU’s move from a non-interventionist position to a more aggressive and interventionist mandate reveals that the threat posed by transnational criminal networks has been clearly identified. Conventions against corruption, action plans for drug control, strategies for arms control, and protocols for human trafficking and cross-border cooperation are only a few of the various legal and policy tools that the AU has set up. International standards are often in line with these frameworks. This entails a knowledge at the continental level of the complex nature of organised crime and the need for a multi-sectoral response.  However, a number of practical restrictions, similar as resource shortages and the continuous lack of genuine and sustained political will among member states, regularly test the usefulness of these normative frameworks. Operational vulnerabilities brought about by a lack of expertise in areas like digital forensics and an unwillingness to share intelligence are easily exploited by criminal networks. Cross-border law enforcement entails jurisdictional complexity and challenges due to the inherent tension between national sovereignty and the transnational nature of crime. This makes coordinated action tougher. Consequently, the practical realities on the ground create a huge gap between desire and achievement, even while the AU’s normative frameworks offer a solid foundation and demonstrate a deep grasp of the organised crime problem. The symbiotic relationship between organised crime and violence, fuelled by illegal economies and socio-economic deficiencies, further distorts the image.

References

African Union (2025). Justice for Africans and people of African descent through reparations. https://au.int/en/theme/2025

African Union. (2003). African Union Convention on Preventing and Combating Corruption. African Union.

Ajah, B.O., Ogar, J.A., Ojong-Ejoh, M.U., Ejimonye, J.C., Onwuchekwe, S.I., Ngwu, G.E.,             Okoye, C. A., Obioji, J.N & Asadu, A. (2025)Exploring the Legal Rights of Expatriates      on Taxation in Their Host Countries: The Case of Uganda Journal of Somali Studies :     Research on Somalia and the Greater Horn of African Countries Vol. 12, No. 3, pp 9-29     https://doi.org/10.31920/2056-5682/2025/v12n3a1

Ajah, Onwuchekwe and Ugwu (2017) Gender Dimensions and Victims of Property Crime by         Commercial Motorcycle Riders in Anambra State, Nigeria, IOSR Journal Of Humanities            And Social Science (IOSR-JHSS) Volume 22, Issue 9, Ver. 5  PP 59-66 e-ISSN: 2279-         0837, p-ISSN: 2279-0845, http://www.iosrjournals.org  DOI: 10.9790/0837-2209055966

Areh, Ajah, Oguejiofo, Onwuchekwe&Eze (2021) The Troubling Epidemic In Ogbaru and      Onitsha North Local Area of Anambra State, Nigeria. International Journal of             Criminology and Sociology, Vol-10, pp.1349-1361. Available online at:             https://doi.org/10.6000/1929-4409.2021.10.155.

African Union. (2024b). Africa Strengthens Fight Against Trafficking in Persons and Smuggling of Migrants with Validated Continental Guidelines. https://au.int/sw/node/44340

AmaniAfrica (2022, May 18).  Briefing on disarmament and control of illicit small arms and light weapons in Africa. AmaniAfrica. https://amaniafrica-et.org/briefing-on-disarmament-and-control-of-illicit-small-arms-and-light-weapons-in-africa/#:~:text=Most%20specifically%2C%20the%20Protocol%20expressed,peace%20and%20security%20in%20Africa‘.

AmaniAfrica (2025, May 13). Open session on Organised Transnational Crime, Peace and Security in the Sahel Region AMANI Africa. https://amaniafrica-et.org/open-session-on-organised-transnational-crime-peace-and-security-in-the-sahel-region/

Bahr, B. (2024).  Neoliberal institutionalism – Theories of International Relations Class Fiveable. https://library.fiveable.me/theories-of-international-relations/unit-2/neoliberal-institutionalism/study-guide/fDfZkbTaFpsXrZgK

Boustati, A. (2022). Narcotics Flows Through Eastern Africa: the Changing Role of Tanzania and Mozambique (Version 1). The Institute of Development Studies and Partner Organisations. https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12413/17470

Cassidy-Neumiller, M., Nagabhatla, N., Islam, M. R., & Debray, A. (2024). Cross-border water management. In Handbook of Regional Cooperation and Integration (pp. 372-396). Edward Elgar Publishing.

Development Policy and Performance Portal. (2025, April 28). Africa strengthens fight against Human trafficking. https://development.finance.go.ug/knowledge-centre-reports/africa-strengthens-fight-against-human-trafficking

Dulskyi, O., Leliuk, T., Luhovyi, V., Melnyk, V., & Morgun, I. (2023). International cooperation when collecting evidence in the investigation of transnational organized crime: challenges and opportunities. Revista Amazonia Investiga, 12(70), 88-101.

International Crisis Group (2025, February 25). Eight Priorities for the African Union in 2025. https://www.crisisgroup.org/africa/african-union-regional-bodies/b205-eight-priorities-african-union-2025

Iremeka, F.U., Eseadi, C., Ezenwaji, C. et al. Effect of School-based Rational-Emotive             Behaviour Program on Burnout Among Adult Learners: Moderating Influence of         Participants’ Demographic Variables. Journal of Rational –Emotive &Cognitive-Behavior Therapy, Vol.39, issue 4. Available online  at https://doi.org//10.1007/s10942-021-          00393-4

INTERPOL. (n.d.). INTERPOL and the African Union. https://www.interpol.int/Who-we-are/Our-partners/International-organization-partners/INTERPOL-and-the-African-Union

Karahalios, H. (2021, February). Contribution of PSC authorities to ship accident prevention. In Operations Research Forum (Vol. 2, No. 1, p. 11). Cham: Springer International Publishing.

Lawson, L. V. (2018). Documentary analysis as an assessment tool. Public Health Nursing, 35(6), 563-567.

Madu, Okafor & Onwuchekwe (2020) Engaging ECOWAS In Managing The Conflict In The Niger Delta: A Perception Study, Journal of African Studies, Vol. 2 No. 2, 2020 (ISSN:             2734-3146)

Maluwa, T. (2012). Ratification of African union treaties by member states: law, policy and practice. Melbourne Journal of International Law, 13, 2–41. https://law.unimelb.edu.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0006/1687380/Maluwa.pdf

Nwosu,S.U, Abnike,U.E, Onwuchekwe, S.I., Onuchukwu,G., 2022: Police Accountability in the   Post-ENDSARS Protest: Perceptions of Youths in
            Southeast, Nigeria, International Journal of Health and Social Inquiry, Vol. 8, No.1, 2022

Oguejiofo, C. P., Onwuchekwe, S. I., Enweonwu, O. A., 2022: Roots of Public Unrest In         Nigeria, EPRA International Journal of Multidisciplinary Research (IJMR)-Peer     Reviewed Journal, Volume:8, Issue:1(January 2022) Journal DOI: 1036713/epra2013,     SJF Impact Factor 2021:8.047//ISN Volume:1.188

 Onwuchekwe, S. I (2009) Seven Point Agenda; an empty package, Vanguard Newspaper      opinion article, July 31st, 2009, page 59

Onwuchekwe, S.I, Okafor, F. C. and Madu, E.T (2020) A Perception Study Of The Niger-Delta     Community On An ECOWAS Role In The Niger Delta Security Crisis, Nigerian Journal         of African Studies, Vol. 2 No. 2, 2020 (ISSN: 2734

Onwuchekwe, S.I, Okoronta, C.C., Ibekwe, C. C, Onwuchekwe, P. T. 2022: Prevalence of         Armed Attacks And Security Implications In Anambra State, Nigeria, International    Journal of Research In Education, Humanities and Commerce, Volume 03, Issue 01:Jan-         Feb.2022, ISSN 25830333

Onwuchekwe, S.I., Onyeoziri,V., Ibekwe, C. C., Madu, T.E., Nweke, G. I., & Agbodike, M. (2025) Influence of Peer Pressure on Youth Involvement in Cybercrime in Onitsha North         Local Government Area of Anambra State, Nigeria, International Journal of Research       (IJR) p-ISSN: 2348-795X, Vol. 12 Issue 10, October 2025 https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.17621126

Onwuchekwe,S.1., Ibekwe, C.C., Ezeh, S.S., & Okpala, F.C (2023) Public Perception of Ex-  Convicts Reintegration in Idemili-North Local Government Area of Anambra State,   Nigeria, Journal of Law and Judicial System 2023;6(1): 15-29             https://doi.org/10.22259/2637-5893.0601002

Onwwuchekwe,S.I, et al (2017), Public Perception on Property Crimes: A Study  of Okada Riders in Anambra  State, Nigeria. IOSR International Journal of Humanities And Social      Science (IOSR-JHSS) Volume 22, Issue 9,Ver.5(September,2017)PP15-24. ~ISSN-2279-      0837, P-ISSN:2279-0845. www.iosrjournals.org.

Perche, J., Shivute, T., & Enkono, N. (2020). Illegal wildlife trade in Southern Africa a state of knowledge report for the project “Assessing the economic impact of Illegal Wildlife Trade in the SADC region”. https://www.conservation-strategy.org/sites/default/files/field-file/10-19-2022%20%20Illegal%20Wildlife%20Trade%20in%20Southern%20Africa%20A%20State%20of%20Knowledge%20Report%20final%20approved%20%281%29_0.pdf

Soumahoro, M. (2025). Africa’s private sector boosts AU Peace Fund. ISS Africa. https://issafrica.org/iss-today/africa-s-private-sector-boosts-au-peace-fund

Tar, U. A., & Safana, Y. I. (2021). Forests, ungoverned spaces and the challenge of small arms and light weapons proliferation in Africa. The Palgrave Handbook of Small Arms and Conflicts in Africa, 223-243.

Tefera, M. M. (2019). Cross-border migration and human trafficking in Ethiopia: contributing factors, policy responses and the way forward. Fudan Journal of the Humanities and Social Sciences, 12, 93-116.

Thelma, C. C., Chitondo, L., Sylvester, C., Phiri, E. V., & Gilbert, M. M. (2024). Analyzing sources of instability in Africa: A comprehensive review. International Research Journal of Modernization in Engineering Technology and Science, 6, 23-39.

UN General Assembly (2025). African Regional Preparatory Meeting for the Fifteenth United Nations Congress on Crime Prevention and Criminal Justice Addis Ababa, 8-10 April 2025. https://www.unodc.org/documents/commissions/Congress/15_Congress/RPM/RPM_Africa/ACONF241_RPM.4_L1_Add5.pdf

UN Trade and Development (UNCTAD) (2022). Report on illicit financial flows from Africa. https://unctad.org/system/files/non-official-document/IFFsAfrica_FinalReport_20221121.pd

United Nations (2021). Illicit Financial Flows fuelling conflicts and embezzling Africa’s future?. United Nations. https://www.un.org/osaa/news/illicit-financial-flows-fuelling-conflicts-and-embezzling-africa%E2%80%99s-future

United Nations (2025). What is transnational organized crime? https://www.un.org/en/peace-and-security/transnational-crime

United States Department of State Bureau for International Narcotics and Law Enforcement Affairs (2024). International narcotics control strategy report. Drug and Chemical Control: Volume 1. https://www.state.gov/wp-content/uploads/2025/01/2024-INCSR-Vol-1-Drug-and-Chemical-Control-Accessible-Version.pd

University for Peace (2022). Illicit Economies and Organized Crime in Africa [White Paper]. University for Peace.

UNODC (2024a). Global Report on Trafficking in Persons 2024. United Nations publication. https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/glotip/2024/GLOTIP2024_BOOK.pdf

UNODC (2024b). Illicit firearms trafficking – addressing the criminal side of diversion. https://www.unodc.org/documents/firearms-protocol/2024/Diversion_Issue_Paper_ENG_web.pdf

UNODC (2025). Global Analysis on Crimes that Affect the Environment – Part 2b: Minerals Crime: Illegal Gold Mining. United Nations publication. https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/Crimes%20on%20Environment/ECR25_P2b_Minerals_Crime.pdf

UNODC. (2018). Counter-Terrorism Module 5 Key Issues: African Region. https://www.unodc.org/e4j/en/terrorism/module-5/key-issues/african-region.html

UNODC. (2020). World Drug Report 2020, regional trends. https://wdr.unodc.org/wdr2020/field/WDR_2020_QA_regional_trends_3_KN_TP.pdf

Interrogating the Nigeria Police Force and Its Counter-terrorism Approaches

Daily writing prompt
What experiences in life helped you grow the most?

Citation

Egwu, F. O., Arua, M. C., Okeh, P. I., Onwe, D. C., & Onuoha, O. O. (2026). Interrogating the Nigeria Police Force and Its Counter-terrorism Approaches. International Journal of Research, 13(3), 1–17. https://doi.org/10.26643/ijr/1

1Egwu, Francis Ogbonnia

Department of Criminology and Security Studies,

Alex Ekwueme Federal University, Ndufu-Alike, Ebonyi State, Nigeria

Email: francis.egwu@funai.edu.ng

ORCID:  https://orcid.org/0009-0009-8519-8303

2**Arua, Mercy Chioma***

Department of Criminology and Security Studies,

Alex Ekwueme Federal University, Ndufu-Alike, Ebonyi State, Nigeria

Email: mercy.arua@funai.edu.ng

Corresponding author****

ORCID:  https://orcid.org/0009-0005-6625-477X

3Okeh, Peter Igboke

Department of Criminology and Security Studies,

Alex Ekwueme Federal University, Ndufu-Alike, Ebonyi State, Nigeria

Email: ptrgbk@gmail.com 

ORCID:  https://orcid.org/0009-0007-5991-8560

4Daniel Chidiebere Onwe

Department of Criminology and Security Studies,

Alex Ekwueme Federal University, Ndufu-Alike, Ebonyi State, Nigeria

Email: onwedaniel1990@gmail.com 

ORCID:  https://orcid.org/0009-0003-4168-148X

5Onuoha, Ogobuchi Onuoha

Department of Sociology,

Ebonyi State University, Abakaliki, Nigeria

Email: onuohaogobuchi@gmail.com  

ORCID:  https://orcid.org/0009-0008-1011-2168

Abstract

The paper used a theoretical method to look at how the Nigeria Police are involved in counter-terrorism efforts in Nigeria. It aimed to find out how the police participate, how effective their involvement is, and what can be done to improve their performance in these operations. The structural functionalism theory was adopted to theoretically underpin the study. The outcome of the study reveals that the police force plays a variety of roles which manifest in different forms in the fight against terrorism. These forms are not limited to intelligence gathering, synergy with other sister agencies, liaison with community leaders to fish out terrorist enclaves and so on. The study also revealed that the police’s regular use of overt force diminishes the effectiveness of their operations, as there is a need to fight the root cause of terrorism. The study recommends that the police should be specially trained on conflict resolution strategy while adopting the principle of community policing. To enhance counter-terrorism operational efficiency, the police should be given adequate and sophisticated equipment and, as well, undergo training and retraining to face the terrorist group.

Keywords: Police, Terrorism, Counter-terrorism, Police Operation, Nigeria                                              

Introduction

The Nigeria Police was established based on the provision of Section 214(1) of the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria, and several laws have given it responsibilities and authority (Nwauzi & Ogon, 2018). The force is tasked with the duties of investigating crimes, protecting people and property, and enforcing all laws and regulations. They may also be responsible for traffic control and prosecution in any court in the country. (Alemika & Chukwuma, 2000, as cited in Edet, 2017). The extant and primary law in Nigeria that highlights the specific responsibilities and capabilities of the Nigerian Police is the Police Act (Nwauzi & Ogon, 2018). The Nigeria Police also performs a variety of secondary responsibilities, including providing aid in times of need and managing and regulating highway traffic, among others (Madubuike-Ekwe & Obayemi, 2019). However, given the vast nature of police officers’ responsibilities and authority, the preceding list of police officer tasks and powers is not all-inclusive (Nwauzi & Ogon, 2018). The composition, establishment and operational control of the Police Force are clearly stated in the 1999 Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria, Section 214(1), that “There shall be a Police Force for Nigeria, which shall be known as the Nigeria Police Force, and subject to the provisions of this Section no other police force shall be established for the Federation or any part thereof” (CFRN, 1999). These provisions are reinforced in the Police Act and Regulations of 1990, Chapter 359, which classified the duties of the police to include prevention and detection of crime, apprehension of offenders, preservation of law and order, protection of life and property, enforcement of all laws and regulations with which they are directly charged and the performance of such military duties within or without Nigeria as may be required of them by or under the authority of the Act or any other act.

Nigeria is currently grappling with a myriad of security challenges. The country has been plagued by a plethora of threats, including Boko Haram, herdsmen/farmers conflicts, kidnapping and banditry, ritual killings and cannibalism, cattle rustling, drug and human trafficking, militancy, illicit proliferation of small arms, and violent extremism. These security challenges have had far-reaching consequences, undermining the country’s stability, economic growth, and social cohesion (Ezinwa, 2019). For long, the country has, particularly, been battling with the insecurity issue posed by the activities of terrorist groups. Topping the list of these groups is the Boko Haram Sect (BHS) in the northeast of Nigeria. Terrorism is a global phenomenon in the atmosphere of criminality (Aiyesimoju, 2015) and has become a major threat to world peace and order (Abodunrin et al., 2021). The militant actions of Boko Haram have become one of the biggest security risks in Africa, particularly around the region surrounding Lake Chad (Oyewole, 2015). In Nigeria, the devious and nasty actions of this terrorist organisation cannot be disregarded because of the attacks the organisation has carried out, which have resulted in loss of life, destruction of property worth billions of Naira, serious infrastructure damage, and loss of investment, capital, and income, among other things (Abodunrin et al., 2021). Since 2009, the Boko Haram Sect (BHS) and other terrorist organisations’ operations have impeded sustainable development and made the nation hazardous for people to live in, conduct business in, and invest in (Isiaka et al., 2023). We also have the Fulani herders in the northeast, the Delta militants in the south-south, the Indigenous People of Biafra (IPOB) and Eastern Security Network (ESN) in the southeast, the Amotekun agitators in the southwest and the newly emerged terror group, the Lukarawas, in northwestern Nigeria.

The International Terrorism and Security Research (ITSR) alludes to the fact that terrorism is not new and that even though the word has been used since the beginning of recorded history, it can be relatively hard to define. Terrorism, according to the ITSR, has been described variously as both a tactic and strategy, a crime and a holy duty, and a justified reaction to oppression and an inexcusable abomination. The United States Department of Defence (USDD) defines terrorism as “the calculated use of unlawful violence or threat of unlawful violence to inculcate fear; intended to coerce or to intimidate governments or societies in the pursuit of goals that are generally political, religious, or ideological.” Within this definition, there are three key elements: violence, fear, and intimidation. Each element produces terror in its victims. The FBI defines terrorism as “the unlawful use of force and violence against persons or property to intimidate or coerce a government, the civilian population, or any segment thereof, in furtherance of political or social objectives.” The U.S. Department of State (USDS) defines terrorism as “premeditated politically motivated violence perpetrated against noncombatant targets by sub-national groups or clandestine agents, usually intended to influence an audience.” Boko Haram and splinter groups such as JAMBS (presently known as ISWAP) are believed by analysts to be largely a product of widespread socioeconomic and religious insecurities, and their ideology resonates among certain communities because of both historical narratives and modern grievances (Audu & Zakimayu, 2021). It has become increasingly clear that national security agencies can no longer work alone in preventing future attacks. They must work in partnership with other public and private agencies, most importantly with local police.

‘Counter-terrorism’ means the measures undertaken by a government to defeat terrorism. It integrates and synchronises political, security, legal, economic, developmental and psychological activities to create a holistic approach that aims at weakening the terrorists while bolstering the government’s legitimacy in the eyes of the people. Several scholars clarified the meaning of counter-terrorism. For instance, Grey (2012) defined counter-terrorism as a set, or combinations, of diverse and multifaceted activities used in combating any terrorist violence in a given society. Campbell and Weitz (2005) also consider counter-terrorism to refer to all actions, activities, principles and tactics used by regular security groups in waging war against any terrorist group in a given political setting. To clarify it further, the United States Army (2006) defined counter-terrorism as military, paramilitary, political, economic, psychological and civic actions taken by government to defeat terrorism. However, the focus of most counter-terrorism measures in this study is centred on the Nigeria Police Force. Police counter-terrorism refers to all forms of conventional combat adopted by the police force and other paramilitary and military forces in combating terrorism in a given political entity. It is a kinetic component of the counter-terrorism response to guerrilla warfare. According to Sampson (2015), the main principle of the counter-terrorism strategy is the application of aggressive force involving violent destruction of the enemy force and threatening of the local population to withdraw support for the terrorists. Therefore, counter-terrorism relies on operations that involve the use of aggression, such as detention of suspects, brutal elimination of individual terrorists, disruption of terrorists’ support networks, and decapitation of terrorist organisations. To contend with these terrorist activities in Nigeria, the federal government of Nigeria, irrespective of statutory restrictions, still deploys Nigeria police personnel to quell unwholesome loss of life and property from these theatres of terrorism in Nigeria.

Problem Statement

Nigeria is grappling with the pressing issue of terrorism, which has become a leading concern for national security. This menace has sparked intense discussions and varied comments in current national discourse (Aiyesimoju, 2015). Despite the Nigerian government’s best efforts, terrorist group activities have continued to grow throughout the northern area, with Boko Haram leading at the forefront, and they pose a severe threat to Nigeria and the region around Lake Chad (Sadau, 2015). Different approaches have been used by the Nigerian government to subdue and curtail the activities and operations of the numerous terrorist groups present in the country. Since terrorism continues to be a threat to Nigeria’s stability and peace, these measures, however, have not produced fruitful and beneficial results. The administration has largely focused on using the military strategy rather than alternative non-military ones to calm terrorism operations. Hence, there is the need to examine other non-military approaches, especially the criminal justice system, in the fight against terrorism. The urgent need to combat terrorism and the roles of critical stakeholders in the fight against terrorism have been investigated in literature. For instance, Aiyesimoju (2015) examined the role of the media in containing terrorism by outlining how the activities of the media can be used to aid as well as thwart the activities of terrorism groups in the country. Ike (2018) examined the need to re-conceptualise the role of law in countering terrorism in Nigeria and explained the rationale behind strengthening Nigeria’s criminal justice system. However, the emphasis in these studies is on the efficacy of the police operational duties in terms of countering terrorism. Against this background, this study aims to explore the forms of Nigeria Police participation in counter-terrorism operations, the effectiveness of Nigeria Police involvement in counter-terrorism operations and measures that could enhance police performance in counter-terrorism operations in the country.

 Theoretical Framework

Structural functionalism is a sociological theory that explains why society functions the way it does by emphasising the relationships between the various social institutions that make it up. The basic underpinnings of structural functionalism were built by French sociologist Émile Durkheim in the late nineteenth century, at least in part as a response to evolutionary theories of thinkers such as E. B. Tylor (Porth et al., 2015). Durkheim’s original goal was to explain social structures as a shared means for individuals in society to meet their own biological needs; he also wanted to explain the worth of cultural and social features in terms of their contribution to the general operation of society and life. Later, structural functionalism’s focus shifted to the manner in which social structures in society meet the social requirements of individuals inside that society. This theory was adopted as a theoretical framework for the study because of its strengths and strategic importance. The theory placed emphasis on the interdependency and interconnectedness of security formations, including the police force, and the necessity and urgency for them to form a synergy with the local civilian security formation in the host community for harmonious living. It was reported by Stearns (2013) that structural functionalism views society as functioning as an organism with the various social institutions working together as organs in the human body to maintain stability and integration. Radcliffe Brown espoused the interaction or interdependence of human activities in the social institutions that give rise to the cohesion, stability and peaceful coexistence of human society (Mediha, 2013; Palmer, 2013). Seeing the imperativeness of structural functionalism in understanding and explaining the police force as a subset of security organisations that contributes meaningfully to the existence and survival of the whole social system, the theory was found much more relevant to and apt in examining police involvement in community security, with emphasis on counter-terrorism.

Forms of Police Participation in Counter-terrorism Operations

One cannot overemphasise the duties and responsibilities of the police in any given society. The police are recognised members of the society charged with the responsibility of security of lives and property, maintaining law and order and prevention of all crimes, including terrorism. The roles the Nigeria police play are not just confined to the statutory description of their duties and responsibilities. Alongside other primary duties such as crime prevention and investigation, maintenance of law and order, and enforcement of all laws and regulations, the police also have a role to play in countering terrorism in Nigeria. This was confirmed from the above submission but is also partly stated in section 4 of the Police Act under “such military duties within or outside Nigeria as may be required by them by this or any other Act” (The Police Act, Cap [P19]). Nwauzi and Ogon (2018) also stated that the listed duties and powers of police officers are not exhaustive, as the duties and powers of police officers are expansive. The Nigeria Police discharge other specific secondary duties like highway traffic control and management, provision of assistance during disasters and the conduct of prosecution before any court in the country (Madubuike-Ekwe & Obayemi, 2019).

Detailed explanation of some forms of police participation in curbing the menace of terrorism in Nigeria. The forms in which the police manifest in its duty of counter-terrorism include but are not limited to the following: Involvement in intelligence gathering and sharing with other security agencies to buffer counter-terrorism operations; counselling people as well as relevant stakeholders in the country about the need for peace in the society. This is done in a bid to write off the wrong and poisonous orientation people might have received concerning situations in the country; mopping up arms and ammunitions, drugs and narcotic substances in the society; working in synergy with relevant stakeholders, bodies and national institution agencies such as the NDLEA, EFCC, NAFDAC and others; working with other security agencies such as the Nigerian Military, Nigeria Security and Civil Defence Corps (NSCDC) to enhance synergy towards countering terrorism; training and re-training of police personnel on recent crime fighting modes in order to effectively engage the terrorist groups; engaging the religious and community leaders in talks about peace and giving proper orientation to their members so as to proactively repel the desire to engage in terrorism;  striving to administer and dispense justice to improve people’s trust and confidence in the justice system so that aggression will not set-in on an aggrieved party thereby leading to terrorism.

Effectiveness of Nigeria Police Involvement in Counter-terrorism Operations

Challenges to the police role in counterterrorism have marred the effectiveness of police involvement in counterterrorism operations. Some challenges facing the police in their fight against terrorism are found as follows: First, there is insufficient training for the officers facing terrorists, and being sent to fight well-trained and equipped terrorists sounds like a suicide mission. Second, there is an allegation of misappropriation of funds allocated for counterterrorism operations. This leaves the police with insufficient funds and resources that, in turn, affects their efficiency and effectiveness in the fight against the terrorist. Third, political interference and corrupt practices among policymakers are also alleged. This kind of interference and corruption can always delay actions against the terrorist, thereby limiting the effectiveness, efficiency and productivity of the police. Fourth, command friction between the police and their military partners in the Joint Task Force. This fourth challenge is to be expected between military and paramilitary agencies whose ranking and protocols are similar but still unique. So the issue of superiors and subordinates in the face of command and order-controlled organisation can always be an issue, especially when there are no laid-down rules of operation and command protocols. Therefore, it becomes necessary to take further study into the rules of engagement of the Joint Task Force in order to find out the cause of this challenge and root it in the bud. The fifth challenge found is the existence of some moles (spies or traitors) in the joint military-police-civilian task force on counter-terrorism, which jeopardises the effectiveness of their operations. These findings support previous research reports (Bamidele, 2016; Nnam et al., 2020), which all agreed that concerted efforts to overcome the odious act of terrorism have been sabotaged and frustrated by some civilians in the host communities, politicians and security personnel, who provide corresponding assistance (such as leaking of security tactics and strategies, intelligence and information) to the terrorists (Nwakanma, 2022).

The effectiveness of the use of force approach adopted by the Nigeria Police counter-terrorism is pointed out, and the heavy-handed approach by Nigeria’s security sector against members of terrorist groups exacerbated sentiments of communal insecurity. In an extensive military operation, the Nigerian state destroyed the compound of the group and killed scores of terrorists. Disproportionate force and extrajudicial killings by the statutory security sector cause some terrorist groups to respond with revenge attacks against the institutions of the state. The lack of capacity and capability in Nigeria’s law enforcement and military, coupled with a failure to appreciate the importance of community engagement in counter-terrorism, set the state on a collision course with the group and its followers. Samson (2015) asserts that, while assessing the dilemma of counter-terrorism and human rights in Northern Nigeria, he argued that the aggressive approach of the SJTF perpetrated through gross violations of human rights undermined the support of the population. This assertion connotes that the excessive use of brutal force by the police force, alongside other security agencies, serves as a restraint to the effectiveness of police involvement in counter-terrorism operations.

Similarly, Kalid (2021), while being interviewed by the BBC, pointed out the ineffectiveness of using a force approach to terrorism, thus: the over-reliance on a military strategy to confront terrorist groups is at the heart of the state’s inability to deal with the threat. That is why, unfortunately, almost 11 or 12 years into the counter-terrorism operation, there seem to be no major successes recorded. The reality is that to address terrorism, you need more than a brutal force operation. You need to address the root causes of the terrorism emergence. Paradoxically, Sampson (2015) also claimed that since its engagement in the counterterrorism, the SJTF, including the police, has become anathema to the local communities in the Northeast. According to him, the indiscriminate use of force and other arbitrary acts have led to an unwarranted loss of life and destruction of valuable property, as well as constituted an extensive humanitarian crisis in the Northeast. He further maintained that, in addition to the direct offensive approach, the operation was reinforced by the adoption of draconian laws like the massive imposition of dusk-to-dawn curfews, restriction of vehicular movement, and bans on the use of communication lines. The overall effects of these measures thus undermined the support of the population for counter-terrorism. This indicates that there can never be a purely forceful solution to violent extremism. There is therefore a need to abandon the conventional force-centric approach as the one and only option for terrorism and other asymmetric conflicts. While not ignoring the importance of using a force approach, stability, political-economic-social development, rule of law, popular well-being, and sustainable peace all depend on effective and legitimate control of the national territory; the force-centric approach must be balanced with a population-centric approach for maximum effectiveness and legitimacy (Jerome, 2015).

Measures to Enhance Police Performance in Counter-terrorism Operations

Given the complexity of the security situation in Nigeria, blended with the economic, political, and social strife, projects and programs designed to counter terrorism should be built around community resilience, enhance cooperation among law enforcement agencies, and strengthen judicial institutions. Hence, strategy and the importance of collective efforts to counter terrorism in an increasingly interdependent and interconnected Nigeria have become imperative. Hence, some measures that could be used to counter terrorism in Nigeria were extensively examined.

Measures to enhance police performance in counter-terrorism target a different aspect of what Piombo (2007) calls the four “Ds” of fighting terrorism: ‘Defeat terrorists and their organisations; Deny sponsorship, support and sanctuary to terrorists; Diminish the underlying conditions that terrorists seek to exploit, and Defend citizens and interests at home and abroad.’ Another way to consider these programmes’ effectiveness is that they should attempt to fight the supply of terrorists, the demand for terrorist networks, and the ability of terrorists to operate and manoeuvre. Counterterrorism measures are captured in the below headings.

1. The Meghalaya Model

The Meghalaya model is a multi-sector approach involving government, law enforcement, judiciary, and civil society organisations that created a comprehensive framework for combating trafficking in Northeast Asia in 1999 under the five “Ps”: prevention, protection, policing, press, and prosecution (Kharbhih, 2010). The Meghalaya Model is designed to track and rescue trafficked children in Northeast Asia; to facilitate rehabilitation; and to make sure that survivors do not get re-trafficked. It also provides families with livelihood alternatives, provides evidence to prosecute offenders, and raises awareness through the media. The process of the Meghalaya Model is the five “Rs”: reporting, rescue, rehabilitation, repatriation and re-education. It is believed that these activities that are pillars of the Meghalaya model to counter human trafficking are relevant to counter-terrorism, as they could fight the supply of terrorists, the supply of mercenaries for terrorism, and the demand for terrorist networks. This is imperative because, despite international agreements and a plethora of national laws on counter-terrorism, the issue remains one of the fastest-growing criminal violence in the world. Its proliferation is due to its cross-border nature and thus requires cooperation and collaboration between states if it is to be tackled effectively. However, throughout the world, often counterterrorism initiatives have failed to incorporate all relevant stakeholders. Hence, the Meghalaya Model, though originally designed to track and rescue trafficked children, could be adopted or adapted to counter terrorism in Nigeria, as there are insinuations of mercenaries and conscripted fighters for terrorists. And with the porous nature of Nigerian borders and the rate of human trafficking in the country, these mercenaries and conscripted fighters could be trafficked victims from neighbouring countries. This model is relevant to counter-terrorism in Nigeria because through a collaborative and far-reaching security network of stakeholders in counter-terrorism (security and intelligence agencies, NAPTIP, the media, civil society and NGOs), terrorists, mercenaries and terror suspects are more likely to be arrested and will face prosecution.

2. Countering Terrorism through Public-Private Partnerships (CTPPP)

While combating terrorism is a primary responsibility of nation states, developing partnerships with the private sector can be beneficial, especially in areas where state resources and expertise are limited. The public-private partnerships (PPPs) concept is gaining attention in the business world but at a much slower pace in the security domain. For instance, Jonathan Lucas, Director of the United Nations Interregional Crime and Justice Research Institute (UNICRI), argues that progress to build partnerships on security matters has been hampered by a lack of legislation to facilitate information exchange between the public and private sectors, as well as the absence of incentives because ‘too often no incentives are provided to encourage the private sector to invest in the protection of vulnerable targets, as the private sector usually considers funding of PPP initiatives in security sectors as a cost rather than an investment’ (2012, p. 8). However, the Global Counter-Terrorism Strategy explicitly encourages such partnerships in capacity-building and information exchange. Hence the United Nations Counter-Terrorism Implementation Task Force (CTITF) working group on countering the use of the Internet for terrorist purposes argues how it benefited from private sector expertise in ‘the technical and legal aspects on how the Internet could be used to counter terrorist narratives’ (2012, p. 8). Russia, for example, has been engaging with Moscow State University and People’s Friendship University of Russia to exchange new ideas and expertise in countering terrorism. Because in their view, ‘private-public cooperation should not be limited to the business community alone but should also include non-governmental organisations, media, tourism and hotels, youth associations, the academic community and religious leaders’ involvement in the security sector’ (Yudintsev, 2012).

3. Empowering Youth as Peace-Entrepreneurs and Peace-Seeds

There is growing evidence from the social science literature on the links between youth unemployment and armed conflict, and donors have increasingly used programmes that create jobs for youth as a tool to address armed violence. Many donors now identify addressing youth unemployment as an urgent priority, both in the field of peace buildinpeacebuildingg and in efforts to foster economic development (World Bank, 2008; ILO, 2010; UN, 2009). Similarly, the link between job creation and peacebuilding has been affirmed by the UN Secretary General’s approval of the ‘UN Policy For Post-Conflict Employment Creation, Income Generation And Reintegration’ in 2008, as well as by the ILO’s 2010 Guidelines on Local Economic Recovery in Post-Conflict (UN, 2009; ILO, 2010). However, studies find that both the theoretical and empirical cases for using youth employment programmes as a ‘standalone’ tool to reduce violent conflict are extremely weak, because donor interventions have been poorly evaluated and evidence of success typically only demonstrates increases in employment levels, with little effort made to assess the impact on conflict. Hence, evidence on using job creation as part of an integrated or comprehensive armed conflict or Anti Violence Response (AVR) strategy is stronger: some government-led initiatives in countries that experience high levels of armed violence (such as Brazil and South Africa) are positive examples. So, the emphasis on the youth Anti Violence Response (AVR) strategy should be based on holistic, comprehensive, and integrated approaches that go beyond simply addressing a lack of economic opportunities and seek to tackle the more complex array of factors (such as belief systems, religious, political, and ethnic fundamentalism) that turn youth into entrepreneurs of violence rather than peace-seeds. This is imperative because Omale (2013) argues that, if youth involvement in terrorism is becoming a real threat, then the primary step is to try to understand the phenomena systems andphenomenonof increase, anphenomenonincrease andd the causes of such criminal deviance. Because in the word increase andwordsof Socrates,words, ‘Fundamentum Omnius Cultus animae’ (i.e.,, the soul of all improvement is the improvement of the soul). For instance, the goal of most national educational curricula in modern times is to produce professionals such as scientists, lawyers, doctors, and engineers for society. How much of our school curriculum includes active citizenship education, youth leadership skills, civil courtesies, and relationship-building communication?building? The earlier we begin to instilinstil the skills of ‘learning to live together’ and respect for humanity and society through active citizenship education, the better for our society.

4. Women-Gender Intelligence (WGI)

The innovation of “Women-Gender Intelligence” (WGI), particularly in the events of volatile conflict and endemic suicide bombings in Nigeria, has become imperative. For instance, with the continued violent conflict in Jos and the emerging suicide bombings in the country, the “Women for Change and Development Initiative” of the Office of the First Lady of Nigeria orchestrated media campaigns and jingles of “Women: See Something; Say Something!” and “The One that gives life must Protect Life!” The impact of these jingles and campaigns, this author would argue, motivated a rural woman in a village called Haya Biu, Niger State, to assist the State Security Service in Nigeria to unravel the hideout of some Boko Haram extremists on 6th September, 2011, who until then had been hiding there and making IEDs. By this revelation, it could be argued that women can be strong agents of change and development if adequately harnessed. In terms of security and counterterrorism in Nigeria, this paper argues that if women voluntarily and unanimously agree to stop insecurity, they can because there is no terrorist or criminal that does not have a mother, a spouse, or a girlfriend. The Women Gender Intelligence (WGI) is even more relevant in the Nigerian context since it is insinuated that some Boko Haram perpetrators are youth who cannot afford to pay a bride price for a wife and are so brainwashed and recruited to kill so as to be rewarded with seven virgins in Aljena. In this case, therefore, if women are granted protection as whistleblowers, they can be a good source of intelligence on counterterrorism in Nigeria.

5. Counter Extremism and De-radicalisation Programmes (CEDP)

Religion and cultural differences are among the most important causes of conflicts and violence in Nigeria. A very worrisome dimension of the role of religion in conflicts is the tendency and frequency with which some politicians and leaders exploit it for selfish reasons, as sometimes public statements on issues of religion tend to ignite or exacerbate conflicts, justifying the need for conflict sensitivity. Our world – as an American sociologist, Peter Berger, notes – is ‘fiercely religious’, and Nigeria has witnessed rising essentialism within all the major religions. For instance, a Muslim cleric was once criticised by the media for publicly preaching to his followers in a mosque in Kano (northern Nigeria) that “Un ka kama Mary ko Chinyere ka chisu” (meaning “if you catch a girl with a name Mary or Chinyere, rape her”). This is hate-based preaching that encourages young Muslim boys to rape girls bearing Christian or South Eastern names in Nigeria. In the same vein, some Neo-Pentecostal and evangelical Christians in Nigeria see themselves (the “born again” brethren) as holier than the ‘Other’. Similarly, crusades that dwell much more on the Biblical verse of Mathew 11:12, which states, “And from the days of John the Baptist until now, the kingdom of heaven suffered violence, and the violent takes it by force,” are becoming common citations among youth in Nigeria. Whereas, this Biblical injunction does not encourage violence, perverse interpretations of these religious injunctions, however, have crept into the minds of some people. This radical mindset has created many of the world’s violent outbreaks, both present and past. Lammy (2013) argues in an article written after the May 22nd killing of a Woolwich soldier by a terrorist suspect (Michael Adebolajo) that ‘radical Islamism suffocates conventional Islamic beliefs with a diet of anger, hate and intolerance among young men, who perhaps are already convinced of being outcasts and are intoxicated by teachings that not only entrench this difference further but also demand that they despise the society they leave behind.’ Hence, it is not uncommon for fringe groups of all ideological persuasions to systematically target these men by manipulating their sense of hopelessness and lack of belonging (Lammy, 2013). However, if religion could be used to cause conflict, it could be used to resolve conflict. Because even in this climate of global religious turbulence, religions offer the potential for generosity, wisdom and an ethical sense of transcendence capable of creating a strong link between people, beyond their differences. People might have different beliefs and dogmas and adhere to different schools of philosophical and metaphysical thought, but I strongly believe that it is possible to share a pragmatic universal system of ethics that would allow us all to live together. So Counter Extremism and De-radicalisation Programmes (CEDP) can work and could be an effective way of countering the spread of radical-violent ideology and activism, provided that the right conditions for success exist. These include, among others, political will, a vibrant civil society, and a robust developmental and political capacity within the Nigerian state.

 6. Security Inter-Operability (SIO)

 In every human society there are those that could not be safely contained in the community. Security interoperability that encourages security networking and intelligence sharing could root out the bad eggs in the society. For instance, if the police, SSS, EFCC and NIA work collaboratively, they could unravel the local and international sponsors and financiers of Boko Haram. Similarly, if the Customs, Immigration and the NDLEA work collaboratively, they could unravel the criminal importation of foreign mercenaries, drugs, arms and ammunition that are sustaining the Boko Haram insurgencies. In the same vein, the SSS and police working collaboratively with the Prisons Service could plant pseudo inmates who are fluent in Arabic, Hausa, Fulani and Kanuri in strategic prison cells for intelligence gatherings from detained Boko Haram suspects. The Military Joint Task Forces (JMTF) could as well invest in telemetric security and cable detection technology and use fewer roadblocks. Where these security strategies are done well, the use of the Military Joint Task Forces (MJTF) fire operations would only be the last resort. But if terror attacks do occur, a coordinated and well-equipped MJTF that comprises the military forces, NEMA, the fire service and the Red Cross should be on standby for effective evacuation and other needed humanitarian and relief services. However, in a system like Nigeria where security and law enforcement agencies struggle for supremacy and lay claim to arrests and security breakthroughs (as was the case in Kabiru Sokoto’s arrest), interoperability becomes difficult to achieve. Nigeria does not lack the institutions to counter terrorism, but what Nigerian security and law enforcement agencies need to understand is that “success for one is success for all”. ”.

7. Community Policing Approach

In community policing, the community should be the primary objective for the police: its tacit support, its submission to law and order, its consensus, etc. It is therefore necessary to obtain the support of the community not only in the form of sympathy and approval but also in active participation in keeping the society safe. The police must build confidence in the community by conducting themselves professionally and showing the ability to hold volunteered information in the highest secrecy and protect those they have been entrusted to protect at all costs. In community policing, law enforcement agencies share power with residents of a community, and critical decisions need to be made at the neighbourhood level. Establishing and maintaining mutual trust between citizens of a community and the police is the main goal of the first component of community policing. In full partnership, law enforcement agencies and a community’s residents and business owners are supposed to identify core problems, propose solutions, and implement a solution. For this problem-solving process to operate effectively, the police need to devote time and attention to discovering the community’s concerns, and they need to recognise the validity of those concerns. If the police treat suspected terrorists/insurgents using methods and practices outside the law, such as collective punishment or arbitrary detention, this itself undermines the legitimacy of government and can create new grievances, inhibiting the effectiveness of counter-terror or counter-insurgency policies. However, in the real sense and in reality, the counter-terrorism in Nigeria is dominated by security operations (Audu & Zakimayu, 2021).

Conclusion and Recommendations

Young men almost exclusively lead and execute terrorist attacks globally. Nigeria, with its abundant unemployed labour force, exploitative politicians, radical clerics, a population prone to violence, and weakened national and community cohesion, provides a competitive advantage for militant and terrorist organisations, criminal networks, and corrupt political leaders. International experience in countering terrorism has shown that the key to preventing violence against the state and its citizens is policing that establishes government legitimacy and wins public support. In societies where endemic violence poses a threat, we should entrust the responsibility for security to police deployed among the population. Police are the public face of the government. By performing their duties in a professional manner, police build support for the government they represent. Acts committed by terrorists are crimes, which are the responsibility of the police and the criminal justice system. Killing or capturing terrorists when they are engaged in terrorist acts is not an effective solution to insecurity. The solution is to identify would-be terrorists before they commit acts of violence using information provided by citizens to the police. To make this approach work effectively, the police must recognise the importance of collaborating with citizens. The police must also adopt a citizen-oriented approach to policing. Police establish effective relations with the public by being available and easily accessible, by being responsive and acting promptly to requests for assistance from individuals, and by being fair and impartial, treating everyone professionally, respectfully, and empathetically. This approach is based on relationships, attitudes, and values. It requires neither advanced technical skills nor heavy weaponry.

                                                            Recommendations

1. The police should be provided with sophisticated equipment, discipline and training (the curricula in police training institutions must reflect present-day challenges, e.g., detailed courses on terrorism/military history, policing, forensics, etc.).

2. It is imperative that police officers undergo regular specialised training and retraining prior to deployment. This will equip them against the well-trained and equipped terrorists.

3. The funding and deployment of police officers for the counterterrorism operations should be depoliticised. The influence of the politicians on the processes of operation of the counterterrorism is affecting the smooth operation of the units if the funds set apart for their operation are misappropriated.

4. There should be a very strict and unbiased screening of the officers deployed into the counterterrorism units. This screening should be done by external bodies outside the government and its agencies. This will help rid the ranks and files of the moles that jeopardise their operations.

References

Abodunrin, O., Adeyeye, A. I. & Oloye, G. (2021). Boko Haram insurgency as a catalyst denting 

Nigeria as a sleeping giant in Africa. International Journal of Social Sciences and Humanities Reviews, Vol. 11(1), 217-227.

Ajah, B.O., Ogar, J.A., Ojong-Ejoh, M.U., Ejimonye, J.C., Onwuchekwe, S.I., Ngwu, G.E.,    Okoye, C. A., Obioji, J.N & Asadu, A. (2025)Exploring the Legal Rights of Expatriates      on Taxation in Their Host Countries: The Case of Uganda Journal of Somali Studies :          Research on Somalia and the Greater Horn of African Countries Vol. 12, No. 3, pp 9-29           https://doi.org/10.31920/2056-5682/2025/v12n3a1

Ajah, Onwuchekwe and Ugwu (2017) Gender Dimensions and Victims of Property Crime by         Commercial Motorcycle Riders in Anambra State, Nigeria, IOSR Journal Of Humanities            And Social Science (IOSR-JHSS) Volume 22, Issue 9, Ver. 5  PP 59-66 e-ISSN: 2279-         0837, p-ISSN: 2279-0845, http://www.iosrjournals.org  DOI: 10.9790/0837-2209055966

Areh, Ajah, Oguejiofo, Onwuchekwe&Eze (2021) The Troubling Epidemic In Ogbaru and      Onitsha North Local Area of Anambra State, Nigeria. International Journal of             Criminology and Sociology, Vol-10, pp.1349-1361. Available online at:             https://doi.org/10.6000/1929-4409.2021.10.155.

Aiyesimoju, A. B. (2015). Curbing insurgencies in Nigeria: Roles for the media. Developing

Country Studies, Vol. 5(2), 18-29.

Alemika, E. E. O. & Chukwuma, I. (2000). Police-community violence in Nigeria. Lagos: Centre 

Human Rights Watch (2012), Everyone’s in on the game: Corruption and human rights  abuses by the Nigerian Police Force. New York: Human Rights Watch for Law Enforcement Education.

Audu, B. M., & Zakimayu, T. B. (2021). Appraising the Nigeria Police Force fight against 

terrorism and insurgencies in Nigeria, 1960-2020. Uzu Journal, Vol. 8(1), 240-252.

Campbell, K. M. & Weitz, R. (2005). Non-Military Strategies for Countering Islamist Terrorism:

Lessons Learned from Past Counter Insurgencies. The Princeton Papers Project, 14‐15.

CTITF. (2012). CTITF launches counter-terrorism projects in Nigeria. The Beam UN CTITF, (5),

January-May, p.8

Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria (1999) Lagos, Federal Government Press,

Section 214, Sub-Section 1.

Edet, A. S. (2017). Crime control and policing the nation states: The Nigerian Police in focus.  

International Journal of Social Sciences and Humanities Reviews, Vol. 7(2), 97-102.

Ezinwa, V.C. (2019). Curbing security challenges facing contemporary Nigeria. International

Journal of Management, Social Sciences, Peace and Conflict Studies (IJMSSPCS), Vol. 2(3), 10-16.

Gray, C. S. (2012). Concept Failure? COIN, Counter-insurgency, and Strategic Theory. PRISM:

A Journal of the Center for Complex Operations, Vol. 3(3), 17-32.

Ike, T. J. (2018). Reconceptualising the role of law in countering terrorism: A case study of Boko

Haram in Nigeria. Journal of Law and Criminal Justice, Vol. 6(1), 107-112. https://doi.org/10.15640/jlcj.v6n1a9.

ILO. (2010). Socio-economic reintegration of ex-combatants. Guidelines, programme for crisis  

response and reconstruction. Rerieved from: http://bit.ly/a0iDxx

Iremeka, F.U., Eseadi, C., Ezenwaji, C. et al. Effect of School-based Rational-Emotive             Behaviour Program on Burnout Among Adult Learners: Moderating Influence of         Participants’ Demographic Variables. Journal of Rational –Emotive &Cognitive-Behavior Therapy, Vol.39, issue 4. Available online  at https://doi.org//10.1007/s10942-021- 00393-4

Isiaka, M., Oladele, A., Nasirudeen, I. A., Abdulrahman, A. & Hassan, A. K. (2023). The

Involvement of the Nigeria Police in Curbing Insurgency in Nigeria. Ilorin Journal of Criminology and Security Studies. Vol.1(1) 82-91.

Jerome, A. (2015). Lessons from Colombia for Curtailing the Boko Haram Insurgency in Nigeria.

PRISM: A Journal of the Center for Complex Operations, Vol. 5(2), 95-105.

Khalid, I. (2021). Nigeria’s Boko Haram Militants: Six Reasons They Have Not Been Defeated.

British Broadcasting Corporation. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-africa-57117296

Kharbhih, H. (2010). Meghalaya model -combating human trafficking through a comprehensive

framework that engages stakeholders. Impulse NGO Network.

Lammy, D. (2013). Islamists, gangs, the EDL-all target alienated men. UK: The Guardian.

Rerieved from http://www.guardian.co.uk/uk/2013/may/24/islamists-gangs-edl-         targetyoung-men.

Madu, Okafor & Onwuchekwe (2020) Engaging ECOWAS In Managing The Conflict In The Niger Delta: A Perception Study, Journal of African Studies, Vol. 2 No. 2, 2020 (ISSN:             2734-3146)

Madubuike-Ekwe, N. J. & Obayemi, O. K. (2019). Assessment of the role of the Nigerian Police

Force in the promotion and protection of human rights in Nigeria. Annual Survey of International and Comparative Law, 23(1), Article 3. Retrieved from https://digitalcommons.law.ggu.edu/annlsurvey/vol23/iss1/3

Mediha, D. (2013). Tag archives: Structural functionalism. Retrieved from http://www.

sociologyinfocus.com.Hag/structural-functionalism.

Nnam, M. U., Ugwuoke, C. O., Njemanze, V. C., & Akwara, F. A. (2020). Boko Haram terrorism

and human security in Nigeria: Matters Arising. Journal of Aggression, Maltreatment

and Trauma, Vol. 28(10), 1-23.

Nwakanma, E. U. (2022). The co-option of the Nigerian Police in the fight against Boko Haram

terrorism in Nigeria. American Journal of Social and Humanitarian Research, 3(3), 102-117.

Nwauzi, L. O. & Ogon, P. (2018). A critical analysis of the scope of police powers of law.

Cranbrook Law Review, Vol. 8(1), 26-41.

Nwosu,S.U, Abnike,U.E, Onwuchekwe, S.I., Onuchukwu,G., 2022: Police Accountability in the Post-ENDSARS Protest: Perceptions of Youths in
            Southeast, Nigeria, International Journal of Health and Social Inquiry, Vol. 8, No.1, 2022

Omale, D. J. O. (2013). Terrorism and Counter Terrorism in Nigeria: Theoretical Paradigms and

Lessons for Public Policy. Canadian Social Science, Vol. 9(3), 96-103.

Oguejiofo, C. P., Onwuchekwe, S. I., Enweonwu, O. A., 2022: Roots of Public Unrest In         Nigeria, EPRA International Journal of Multidisciplinary Research (IJMR)-Peer     Reviewed Journal, Volume:8, Issue:1(January 2022) Journal DOI: 1036713/epra2013,     SJF Impact Factor 2021:8.047//ISN Volume:1.188

 Onwuchekwe, S. I (2009) Seven Point Agenda; an empty package, Vanguard Newspaper      opinion article, July 31st, 2009, page 59

Onwuchekwe, S.I, Okafor, F. C. and Madu, E.T (2020) A Perception Study Of The Niger-Delta     Community On An ECOWAS Role In The Niger Delta Security Crisis, Nigerian Journal         of African Studies, Vol. 2 No. 2, 2020 (ISSN: 2734

Onwuchekwe, S.I, Okoronta, C.C., Ibekwe, C. C, Onwuchekwe, P. T. 2022: Prevalence of         Armed Attacks And Security Implications In Anambra State, Nigeria, International    Journal of Research In Education, Humanities and Commerce, Volume 03, Issue 01:Jan-         Feb.2022, ISSN 25830333

Onwuchekwe, S.I., Onyeoziri,V., Ibekwe, C. C., Madu, T.E., Nweke, G. I., & Agbodike, M.       (2025) Influence of Peer Pressure on Youth Involvement in Cybercrime in Onitsha North Local Government Area of Anambra State, Nigeria, International Journal of Research    (IJR) p-ISSN: 2348-795X, Vol. 12 Issue 10, October 2025             https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.17621126

Onwuchekwe,S.1., Ibekwe, C.C., Ezeh, S.S., & Okpala, F.C (2023) Public Perception of Ex-  Convicts Reintegration in Idemili-North Local Government Area of Anambra State,   Nigeria, Journal of Law and Judicial System 2023;6(1): 15-29             https://doi.org/10.22259/2637-5893.0601002

Onwwuchekwe,S.I, et al (2017), Public Perception on Property Crimes: A Study  of Okada Riders in Anambra  State, Nigeria. IOSR International Journal of Humanities And Social      Science (IOSR-JHSS) Volume 22, Issue 9,Ver.5(September,2017)PP15-24. ~ISSN-2279-      0837, P-ISSN:2279-0845. www.iosrjournals.org.

Oyewole, S. (2015). Boko Haram: Insurgency and the war against terrorism in the Lake Chad

Region. Strategic Analysis, Vol. 39(4), 428-432. https://doi.org/10.1080/09700161.2015.1047227.

Porth, E., Neutzling, K., & Edwards, J. (2015). Anthropological Theories – Department of

Anthropology – The University of Alabama. The University of Alabama. Available at http://anthropology.ua.edu/cultures/cultures.

Sadau, A. (2015). A critical analysis of boko haram insurgency. A Thesis presented to the

Faculty of the U.S. Army Command and General Staff College in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree, Master of Military Art and Science General Studies.

Sampson, I. T. (2015). Between Boko Haram and the Joint Task Force: Assessing the Dilemma

of Counter-Terrorism and Human Rights in Northern Nigeria. Journal of African Law, Vol. 59(1), 25-63.

United Nations (2009). United Nations policy for post-conflict employment creation, income

generation and reintegration. United Nations, Geneva, Rerieved from http://bit.ly/bN4K65

United States Army (2006). The U. S. Army/Marine Corps Counter-insurgency Field Manual.

University of Chicago Press

World Bank. (2008). Youth and employment in Africa: The potential, the problem, the promise.

Africa development indicators, world bank. Rerieved from siteresources.worldbank.org/INTSTATINAFR/Resources/ADI-200809-essay-EN.pdf.

Yudintsev, A. (2012). Promoting public private partnerships. The Beam UN CTITF, 5, January-

May, p.8.

Subaltern Voices and the Politics of Representation in Postcolonial Texts

Daily writing prompt
Where would you go on a shopping spree?

Citation

Dwivedi, S. (2026). Subaltern Voices and the Politics of Representation in Postcolonial Texts. International Journal of Research, 13(2), 218–224. https://doi.org/10.26643/rb.v118i1.7619

Shambhavi Dwivedi

MA, NET (English)

Dwivedi Clinic

Bhagwan Bazar, Chapra

Abstract

Postcolonial literature has played a crucial role in foregrounding the voices of marginalized communities whose experiences were historically excluded from dominant colonial narratives. One of the most significant concepts within postcolonial studies is the notion of the subaltern, which refers to those social groups that remain outside the structures of power and representation within hegemonic discourse. Colonial regimes not only imposed political and economic domination but also controlled systems of knowledge and cultural representation, thereby silencing indigenous voices and rewriting histories from the perspective of imperial authority. In response to these distortions, postcolonial writers and theorists have sought to recover the experiences of the subaltern and challenge the politics of representation embedded within colonial discourse. This research article examines the emergence of subaltern voices in postcolonial texts and analyzes how literature becomes a space for contesting hegemonic power structures. It explores the theoretical framework of subaltern studies and the politics of representation articulated by major thinkers, while also investigating the narrative strategies employed by postcolonial writers to represent marginalized communities. The study further examines how issues of voice, agency, identity, gender, and cultural memory shape the representation of subaltern experiences in postcolonial narratives. By analyzing selected literary works from postcolonial contexts, the article demonstrates that literature functions not only as a medium of artistic expression but also as a site of political resistance and cultural recovery. Ultimately, the politics of representation in postcolonial texts reveals the complexities involved in giving voice to historically marginalized groups and underscores the importance of literature in challenging structures of domination and reconstructing alternative histories.

Keywords: Subaltern studies, postcolonial literature, politics of representation, marginalization, identity, resistance, cultural memory

Introduction

The emergence of postcolonial literature marked a significant shift in the way history, culture, and identity were represented in literary discourse. For centuries, colonial powers dominated not only the political and economic structures of colonized societies but also their cultural and intellectual narratives. Colonial literature and historiography frequently portrayed colonized peoples as passive subjects, incapable of self-representation and dependent upon the civilizing influence of European authority. These representations served to legitimize imperial power while simultaneously marginalizing indigenous voices and cultural traditions.

In response to this legacy, postcolonial writers began to challenge the dominant narratives of empire by foregrounding the experiences of marginalized communities. One of the central concerns of postcolonial studies is the recovery of subaltern voices—those individuals and groups who have historically been excluded from positions of power and whose perspectives have rarely been recorded in official historical accounts. The concept of the subaltern has become a crucial analytical tool in examining how colonial power structures operated and how marginalized groups resisted and negotiated these structures.

The term “subaltern” originally emerged within Marxist discourse to describe the lower classes who were excluded from political representation. However, within postcolonial studies, the term has acquired broader significance, referring to those populations whose voices are suppressed within dominant systems of knowledge and representation. Subaltern groups often include peasants, tribal communities, laborers, women, and other marginalized populations who remain outside elite political and cultural institutions.

Postcolonial literature has played an important role in bringing subaltern experiences into global visibility. Writers from formerly colonized societies have sought to challenge the hierarchical structures of representation that colonialism established. By narrating the experiences of marginalized communities, these authors question the authority of colonial historiography and create alternative narratives that highlight the struggles and resilience of oppressed groups.

The politics of representation is central to this process. Representation involves more than simply describing social realities; it also involves the power to shape how those realities are understood. In colonial discourse, representation was often controlled by imperial institutions that depicted colonized peoples in stereotypical and dehumanizing ways. Postcolonial writers confront these representations by offering new perspectives that emphasize the agency, dignity, and complexity of marginalized communities.

This research article explores the ways in which postcolonial texts engage with the politics of representation and recover subaltern voices. It examines the theoretical foundations of subaltern studies and analyzes the narrative strategies through which postcolonial writers represent marginalized experiences. Through this exploration, the article demonstrates that literature serves as a powerful tool for challenging dominant narratives and reconstructing cultural identity.

Theoretical Foundations of Subaltern Studies

The emergence of subaltern studies in the late twentieth century significantly transformed the field of postcolonial scholarship. The Subaltern Studies collective, a group of historians and scholars primarily working on South Asian history, sought to challenge traditional historiography that focused primarily on elite political leaders and colonial administrators. These scholars argued that conventional historical narratives failed to account for the experiences and contributions of ordinary people, particularly peasants and marginalized communities.

Subaltern studies emphasized the importance of examining history from the perspective of those who had been excluded from dominant narratives. By focusing on grassroots movements, local resistance, and everyday forms of agency, scholars sought to reconstruct a more inclusive understanding of historical processes. This approach challenged the assumption that historical change was driven solely by elite actors and highlighted the role of marginalized groups in shaping political and social transformations.

One of the most influential contributions to subaltern theory came from scholars who examined the relationship between power and representation. They argued that colonial knowledge systems played a crucial role in shaping how colonized societies were understood. Through institutions such as education, administration, and scholarship, colonial powers produced narratives that reinforced their authority and marginalized indigenous perspectives.

Subaltern studies also raised important questions about the possibility of representing marginalized voices. Some scholars argued that the subaltern cannot easily speak within dominant systems of representation because those systems are structured by power relations that exclude them. This perspective highlights the difficulties involved in recovering subaltern voices and underscores the need for new methodological approaches in both historical and literary analysis.

Postcolonial literature provides one such approach by creating imaginative spaces in which marginalized voices can be articulated. Through storytelling, writers are able to reconstruct the experiences of those who were excluded from official historical records. While literature cannot fully replicate the lived experiences of subaltern communities, it can offer powerful insights into the social and cultural dynamics that shape their lives.

Colonial Discourse and the Politics of Representation

Colonial discourse played a crucial role in shaping the representation of colonized societies. Through literature, anthropology, and administrative reports, colonial authorities constructed images of indigenous populations that emphasized their supposed inferiority and backwardness. These representations served to justify colonial rule by portraying imperial powers as benevolent agents of progress and civilization.

The politics of representation refers to the ways in which power influences how individuals and communities are depicted in cultural narratives. In colonial discourse, representation was closely linked to the maintenance of imperial authority. By controlling the production of knowledge about colonized societies, colonial institutions were able to shape global perceptions of these communities.

These representations often relied on stereotypes that reduced complex cultures to simplistic and negative images. Colonized peoples were frequently depicted as irrational, primitive, or incapable of self-governance. Such portrayals reinforced the ideological foundations of colonialism and contributed to the marginalization of indigenous voices.

Postcolonial writers challenge these representations by exposing their ideological assumptions and presenting alternative perspectives. Through literature, they reveal the contradictions and injustices embedded within colonial discourse. By highlighting the humanity and agency of marginalized communities, postcolonial narratives challenge the stereotypes that colonialism perpetuated.

The politics of representation also involves questions about who has the authority to speak for others. In many cases, the representation of marginalized communities has been controlled by elite institutions or individuals who do not share the experiences of those they depict. Postcolonial literature addresses this issue by emphasizing the importance of self-representation and by creating narrative spaces in which marginalized voices can be heard.

Subaltern Voices in Postcolonial Literature

One of the most significant contributions of postcolonial literature is its focus on the experiences of marginalized communities. Writers from diverse cultural backgrounds have used literature to explore the lives of those who were historically excluded from positions of power and representation. These narratives often highlight the struggles faced by subaltern groups while also emphasizing their resilience and capacity for resistance.

Subaltern voices in literature frequently emerge through characters who occupy marginalized social positions. These characters may belong to oppressed castes, tribal communities, rural populations, or other groups that have historically been excluded from dominant narratives. By centering these perspectives, postcolonial writers challenge traditional literary hierarchies and expand the scope of storytelling.

The representation of subaltern experiences also involves exploring the everyday realities of marginalization. Issues such as poverty, displacement, cultural erosion, and social discrimination often feature prominently in postcolonial narratives. Through these depictions, writers reveal the structural inequalities that shape the lives of marginalized communities.

At the same time, postcolonial literature does not simply portray subaltern groups as passive victims of oppression. Many texts emphasize the agency and resistance of marginalized individuals who challenge the systems of power that seek to control them. This emphasis on resistance highlights the dynamic nature of subaltern identity and underscores the importance of recognizing the contributions of marginalized communities to social and political change.

Gender, Subalternity, and Representation

Gender plays a crucial role in shaping the experiences of subaltern communities. Women in colonized societies often faced multiple layers of marginalization, including colonial domination, patriarchal oppression, and economic exploitation. As a result, the representation of subaltern women presents unique challenges within postcolonial literature.

Many postcolonial writers have sought to explore the intersections between gender and subalternity. These narratives often highlight the ways in which colonial and patriarchal structures interact to shape the lives of women. Issues such as domestic violence, social exclusion, and cultural restrictions frequently appear in these texts.

At the same time, postcolonial literature also portrays women as active participants in resistance movements and cultural transformation. Female characters often challenge traditional gender roles and assert their autonomy in various ways. Through these representations, postcolonial writers emphasize the importance of recognizing women’s contributions to social and political struggles.

The representation of subaltern women also raises important questions about voice and agency. Some critics argue that literary representations of marginalized women must be approached with caution to avoid reproducing stereotypes or speaking on behalf of those whose experiences may differ from those of the author. This challenge underscores the complexity of representing subaltern identities within literary discourse.

Narrative Strategies in Representing the Subaltern

Postcolonial writers employ a variety of narrative techniques to represent subaltern voices and challenge dominant discourses. One common strategy is the use of multiple narrative perspectives. By presenting events from different viewpoints, authors create a more nuanced understanding of social realities and highlight the diversity of experiences within marginalized communities.

Another important technique is the incorporation of oral traditions and folklore. Many postcolonial societies possess rich oral storytelling traditions that were marginalized by colonial institutions. By integrating these traditions into written literature, authors create alternative narrative forms that reflect indigenous cultural practices.

Language also plays a crucial role in representing subaltern voices. Postcolonial writers often experiment with linguistic forms by blending colonial languages with local dialects and expressions. This linguistic hybridity challenges the dominance of standard literary language and allows writers to capture the rhythms and nuances of everyday speech.

Fragmented narrative structures are also common in postcolonial texts. These structures reflect the disruptions caused by colonialism and highlight the complexities of historical memory. Rather than presenting a linear narrative, fragmented storytelling emphasizes the multiplicity of voices and perspectives that shape collective experience.

Through these narrative strategies, postcolonial literature creates spaces for marginalized voices to emerge. These techniques not only challenge traditional literary conventions but also contribute to the broader project of decolonizing knowledge and representation.

Cultural Memory and the Reconstruction of Identity

Cultural memory plays a significant role in the representation of subaltern voices within postcolonial literature. Colonial rule often disrupted traditional forms of memory by imposing new systems of education and cultural values. As a result, many communities experienced a loss of historical continuity and cultural identity.

Postcolonial writers seek to reconstruct these memories by revisiting historical events and cultural traditions that were marginalized under colonial rule. Through storytelling, they recover the experiences of past generations and reconnect contemporary readers with their cultural heritage.

The reconstruction of cultural memory also contributes to the formation of new identities in postcolonial societies. By reclaiming suppressed histories, individuals and communities are able to redefine their relationship with the past and assert their cultural autonomy.

This process often involves negotiating the complex interactions between indigenous traditions and colonial influences. Postcolonial identities are rarely defined by a single cultural heritage; instead, they emerge from the dynamic interplay of multiple historical and cultural forces. Literature provides a space for exploring these complexities and for imagining new possibilities for cultural belonging.

Conclusion

The recovery of subaltern voices represents one of the most significant achievements of postcolonial literature. By challenging the politics of representation embedded within colonial discourse, postcolonial writers have created new narrative spaces in which marginalized communities can be heard. These narratives expose the limitations of traditional historiography and emphasize the importance of recognizing diverse perspectives in the construction of historical knowledge.

The politics of representation remains a complex and contested issue within postcolonial studies. While literature offers powerful tools for recovering suppressed voices, it also raises important questions about authorship, authority, and the ethics of representation. Nevertheless, postcolonial texts demonstrate that storytelling can serve as a form of resistance against structures of domination.

Through their exploration of subaltern experiences, postcolonial writers contribute to the broader project of decolonizing knowledge and reconstructing cultural identity. Their works remind readers that history is not a neutral record of events but a dynamic process shaped by power, memory, and interpretation.

Ultimately, the representation of subaltern voices in postcolonial literature underscores the transformative potential of narrative. By giving voice to those who have been historically silenced, literature becomes a site of cultural recovery, political critique, and social empowerment.

References

Ashcroft, Bill, Gareth Griffiths, and Helen Tiffin. The Empire Writes Back: Theory and Practice in Postcolonial Literatures. Routledge.

Bhabha, Homi K. The Location of Culture. Routledge.

Gangode, Sitaram., Dugaje, Manohar. Exclusion and Otherness in Arundhati Roy’s The Ministry of the Utmost Happiness. International Journal of Research. Vol-12-Issue-6, June-2025. https://ijrjournal.com/index.php/ijr/article/view/2106

Fanon, Frantz. The Wretched of the Earth. Grove Press.

Guha, Ranajit. Subaltern Studies: Writings on South Asian History and Society. Oxford University Press.

Loomba, Ania. Colonialism/Postcolonialism. Routledge.

Morve, Roshan., Dugaje, Manohar. Exploring lesbian adolescence: an analysis of Abha Dawesar’s Babyji. Mental Health and Social Inclusion. Volume 28, Issue 6. Dec. 2024. https://doi.org/10.1108/MHSI-11-2023-0122

Said, Edward. Orientalism. Vintage Books.

Spivak, Gayatri Chakravorty. “Can the Subaltern Speak?” Marxism and the Interpretation of Culture.

Young, Robert J. C. Postcolonialism: A Very Short Introduction. Oxford University Press.

The Glimpses of Human Rights and Society in the Novels “Untouchable” and “The God of Small Things”

Daily writing prompt
Have you ever unintentionally broken the law?

Dr. Ravindra Ramdas Borse

B.P.Arts, S.M.A. Sci. and K.K.C. Com. College, Chalisgaon

Email: ravindraborse1@gmail.com

ABSTRACT

The present study aims to observe the role of human rights in the societies before and after the independence India. It is studied through the novels of Indian writing in English. Here, it is an attempt to study, discuss and find out the reflection and violation of human rights in Indian society during pre-independence and post-independence period through the Indian fiction in English with reference to the selected novels of Mulk Raj Anand and Arunthati Roy. For this study two novels have been selected, first is “Untouchable” and another one is “The God of Small Things”. Selection of these writers and novels is based on the particular principles and thoughts. The basic criterion of selecting these writers and novels is the issue of “Human Rights”. Both the novels belong to two deferent periods of Indian history still they have a common theme that is humiliation of mankind and violation of human rights in the society. As we know that Mulk Raj Anand is the pioneer of Indian writing in English. He is an eminent writer in the history of Indian English Fiction. He is the first Indian writer who dared to write and raised the voice of deprived people in pre- independent India. On the other hand, Arundhati Roy is an author who belongs to post- independent period of India. In her novel, she tries to show the real picture and approach of Indian literate society and its people towards the poor and backward people through the depiction of Indian cultures and societies. In her novel “The God of Small Things”, she depicted the real picture of Indian people and their approach towards the illiterate and backward class people.

            Above mentioned novels have been selected on the basis of following principles:

1. Both the novels focus on different cultures with common agenda.

2. The selected novels depict the plight and pathetic condition of downtrodden people in Indian society before and after the independence.

3. The writers of these novels have concern for underprivileged people.

4. Violation of human rights has been keenly depicted by these authors in above mentioned novels.

5. There is an ample scope for the study of human rights and its violation in India as shown in said novels.

KEYWORDS:

            Deprived, underprivileged, downtrodden, human rights, backward, literate, illiterate, pre-independence, post-independence, plight, caste, creed, culture, multi-cultural, multi-lingual.

INTRODUCTION:

            “Human Rights” are rights which have been offered to all human beings by birth with the purpose and aim of no discrimination. Without ‘Human Rights’ it’s impossible to the people to leave their life merrily. Each and every member in society needs of it. It helps all the human beings to live with freedom and peace. “Human Rights” can be considered as a basic rights or fundamental rights which have been offered to every individual. These rights are crucial in our life just like the ‘Food’,’ Cloths’ and ‘Shelter’ as the three basic needs of every human beings. Human rights have special significance in India and it also plays a vital role in the country like India. Role of ‘Human Rights” in a country like India is quiet complicated because it’s a large country in the world where people from different caste, culture and religion.

            Role of ‘Human Rights” throughout a country like India is quiet complicated because it’s huge country within the world where people from different caste, culture and religion live together. 

There are some other issues like population, poverty and lack of education which affect the proper implementation of human rights in India. The true beginning of “Human Rights” can be noticed on 10th December 1948 at Paris. It is a year when United Nation’s General Assembly accepted and implemented the proposal of ‘Human Rights’ for world. But in India, it has been taken into consideration and implemented on 2nd October 1993. An aim of ‘Human Rights Commission of India’ is to stop manipulation of Indians by the bureaucracy and safeguard the rights of common people.

As we know, India is multicultural and multilingual country in which people belongs to different caste, culture, community and creed still they live together. Above discussion makes it cleared that India is multi-lingual and multi-culture country. Due to these multi-culture and multi-lingual societies in India there is a chance and possibility to discriminate among the people of high caste and low caste. It has been noticed and observed from the past references that Indian society (in the context of Hinduism) had been divided into class / caste system (Vernas). The people were categorized into four classes / castes (vernas) such as:  1. Brahmin, 2. Kshatriyas, 3. Vaishyas, 4. Shudras. This class or verna system has at less or maximum level been continued in pre and post- independence India which we can notice in society and even in Indian writing as well. The incidents of ‘Human Rights violation in society’ are truly presented in the literary works of Mulk Raj Anand and Arunthati Roy. Number of words and sentences in “Untouchable” and “The God of Small Things” shows it in a cleared manner. For example, the words “Bhangis (Anand, p. 123), Chamars (Anand, p. 132), Harijans (Anand, p. 131) were used in contemporary period for deprived people of society to humiliate them by calling them with the use of their castes. To prove this point we can go through the novel “Untouchable” in which one can find number of examples of such discrimination among the people by the so called upper class society in Indian history from beginning to the present era by reading Indian literature. Indian literature is a mirror of society which reflects and represents Indian society, specially marginalized communities. In this context, the novel “Untouchable” and “The God of Small Things” are appropriate examples of deprived people. These writers shade lights on human rights’ violation in society through their respective novels. The characters sketch of the “Bakha” in ‘Untouchable’ and “Velutha” in ‘The God of Small Things’ are real depiction of underprivileged class in India. The themes of these novels move around these characters only. As we go through the reading of these novels it’s noticed that there is no life, freedom, peace and choice to lower class people in society as every incident in the novels present exploitation and humiliation of characters. Both ‘Bakha and Velutha’ are victims of caste system. Mulk Raj Anand and Arundhati Roy aim to reflect caste system and violation of human rights of these people in India in contemporary periods through the character sketches ‘Bakha and Velutha’. Mahatma Gandhi insisted and asked Mulk Raj Anand to give exposures to the plight of lower class communities in pre-independent India during 1930s. Casteism was a kind of disease in India. Even today, it has been continued in more or less amount directly or indirectly. Lower class people were suppressed by upper class not only by mental torture but also physically and socially. In this regard C.J. George says, “Casteism is a social practice and no Hindu religious leader of any merit and significance would admit it as part of his religion. Giving a place to casteism in Hindu religion is done by certain wolves in sheep’s skin for certain privileges and advantages” (p.40).

Human Rights and Literature (The novels under consideration):

            Human rights and literature both are concerned to the human being and play crucial role in society. Progress and development of mankind is the common agenda of human rights and literature. Literature and human rights are age old concepts. The purpose of both of them is to shade light on human life and bring illiterate downtrodden people in to the flow. Thus, we can state that literature and human rights are two different things with same motto. Both try to develop and correlate to mankind. These two are the sources of the study and solutions to human challenges and issues of lower class such as exploitation and manipulation. Human rights and literature are the terms which harmonizing to one other. Therefore, it is necessary to discuss these terms simultaneously. Indian English literature has a tradition of raising issues of contemporary eras. Hereby, an attempt to study human rights perspective through the novels ‘Untouchable’ and ‘The God of Small Things’.

            The novel “Untouchable is written by Mulk Raj Anand in 1935. It has been set in pre-independent India. The setting of the novel is of one day episode from morning to evening in which number of events can be observed in the life of low caste communities in colonial period of India. Mulk Raj Anand is one of the pioneers of Indian English Literature who often raised the point of subaltern people through all of his literary work. He is considered a champion of human rights as he depicted the true picture of human psyche in his literary pieces. The very first work of Mulk Raj Anand’s is ‘Untouchable’ where he pointed out the pathetic condition of marginalized people in society who have badly been treated in the Indian community by upper class. The story revolves around the prominent character ‘Bakha’. He is the man who has been fascinated by the upper class people in society. He just tries to imagine and imitate the upper class military officers life for oneself which highly impossible during the colonial India. We can notice the situation of it from the opening lines of the novel which gives us a vivid picture marginalized community and violation of their basic rights in the contemporary period. It can be cleared from the beginning lines of the novel “Untouchable”. The colony of these out caste people was settled in two rows near the cantonment in the town but out of the reach of upper class colony. The upper class people separated their colonies from the marginalised. There lived the scavengers, the grass-cutters and other outcastes from Hindu society” (Anand, p.1). Here, one can get an idea from the quote, how the place of living and the people who have been privileged were differentiated and poorly treated. During the pre-independence period lower class people were not allowed to join or sit with upper class people and it could be the reason of illiteracy and cause of lacking behind in lower class. Because they have never been allow to get an education or join the stream of knowledge which was the only right for upper class society. Education and performing prayers’ to God are the birth rights of upper class only. It was the tendency of upper class people towards lower class. Once Bakha was attracted by the worship “Sri Ram Chandarki Jai” (Long live the Great God Ram) (Anand, p.52). He was fascinated and moved at temple but was caught by the priest who shouted “Polluted, polluted, polluted”(Anand, p. 52).  Lower caste people were not allowed to enter in the colonies of upper class. If he had to do so then must announce his arrivals.

“You be sure to shout now, you illegally begotten!” said a shopkeeper from a side, ‘if you have learnt your lesson!’ Bakha hurried away. He felt that everyone was looking at him. He bore the shopkeeper’s abuse silently and went on. A little later he slowed down, and quite automatically he began to shout: ‘Posh keep away, posh, sweeper coming, posh, posh, sweeper coming, posh, posh, sweeper coming!’ (Anand, p.42)

These lines appropriately express the plight and humiliation of Bakha in the novel Untouchable. Mulk Raj Anand in his novel clearly focuses on the treatment of upper class towards untouchables. Each and every page contains number of events that point out violation of human rights. In the novel ‘Untouchable’, it is noticed that even simple touch of untouchable impure the upper class man.  “You’ve touched me, he had heard the Lalla say to Bakha, ‘I will have to bathe now and purify myself anyhow. Well, take this for your damned irresponsibility, you son of a swine!” (Anand, p.41). These lines show the mentality of so called upper class during colonized India. Untouchables were supposed to do all the menial work for upper class that is the only thing. In this way, Anand not only tries to sheds light on the upper class people’s attitude towards the lower class but also it is the violation of human rights of untouchables. On the other hand, though Arunthati Roy is a writer of post-independence era but reflection of downtrodden still observed in her novel “The God of Small Things”. The novel has been written in 1997 after the four years of establishment of ‘Human Rights Commission in India”. As we understand the background and professional life of Arundhati Roy it seems quite different to the way she has deal with the theme of “The God of Small Things”. The novel first published in the month of April of 1997 and received “Booker Prize” in the month of October of the same year. Within a short period of six months’ time she got an award for her novel. This is a rarest case in Indian history. It shows the prominence of the theme and her writing. By profession she is architecture and worked as a production designer. The theme and issues of Arundhati Roy’s novel are quite different from the other Indian writers in English. She began her writing carrier after getting separated from her husband after the four years married life. The novel “The God of Small things has its own place in Indian English literature. In the novel, she shades light on the current social issues of marginalized people. Through this novel, she provides exposure to these people and gives a platform to such people. She often tries to bring them in main stream of society as it has been noticed in the novel “The God of Small Things”. The plot of the novel begins with oppressive system of the society. There are two prominent issues we can notice here: one is caste exploitation in the contemporary period after the post-independent India and the second is the love story of a woman of upper caste who fallen in love with untouchable man. The setting of the novel is of Ayemenem, a small city in Kerala. The aim of the writer is to fight for equality and dignity of lower castes and classes in the society. Number of issues of human rights been discussed by her in the novel such as: children’s right, rights of women, rights of Dalit, right to select life partner for marriage and domestic violence.

Conclusion:

            To sum up, the present paper is an attempt to sheds light on ‘Human rights and Literature’. Both the elements play crucial role in the life of people and society as well. “Human Rights and Literature” are interconnected and effective elements to understand psychology and traditionally biased mind set human being. At the one side, ‘Human rights’ is the study and guideline for people of society to live their life happily. On the other hand, ‘Literature’ can be strongly considered the manifesto of people in society. Apart from this, one can study, read and observe these novels for the better understanding of human rights and its violation. One can consider these novels as documents of human rights study and also the mirror which shows the real picture of upper class society and their tendency towards lower class. Reading of both the novels helps us to know ‘human rights and violation of it’ through literature as an outcome of society. Thus, it is noticed that the aim of Mulk Raj Anand and Arundhati Roy’s writing is to bring awareness among people of the society about the violation of human rights in real life situations.

REFERENCES:

  1. Agnihotriet al. Trends in Indian English: A Sociolinguistic Perspective. New Delhi: Bahari Publications Pvt. Ltd., 1988.
  2. Anand, Mulk Raj. Untouchable. New Delhi: Penguin Books, 2001.
  3. Basu, Tapan, Translating Caste. New Delhi: Katha 2002.
  4. Baxi, Upendra. The Future of Human Rights.Third Edition. New Delhi: Oxford University Press, 2008.
  5. Baxi, U.Voices of suffering and the future of human rights.Transnat’l L. & Contemp. Probs., 125, 1998.
  6. Benedek, W..Understanding Human Rights: Manual on Human Rights Education.BWV, Berliner Wiss.-Verlag, 2013.
  7. Boggards, P. Dictionaries for Learners of English.International Journal of Lexicography, Vol.9, No.4. 1996.
  8. .Chakrabarty, Koyel and Beniwal, Anup.“Human Rights and Literature: A Complementary Study in Indian Fiction in English.”International Journal of the Arts in Society.Vol.3. No.5. Common Ground Publishing Ltd. Melbourne: 2009:23-33.
  9. Chakrabarty, Koyel. The Problematics of Human Rights in Indian Fiction in English.Unpublished Ph. D. Thesis. New Delhi: Guru Gobind Singh Indraprastha University, 2011.
  10. Choondawat, P. S. “Untouchability and Untouchable Youth: A Study in Urban     Context” in Singh R. (ed.) The Expressed Classes of India: Problems and prospects. New Delhi: B.R., 1986.
  11. George, C. J. Mulk Raj Anand: His Art and Concerns. New Delhi: Atlantic, 2000.
  12. Hudson, R.  Socio-linguistics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2007.
  13. Iyengar, K. R. S. Indian Writing in English. Bombay: Asia Publishing House, 1962.
  14. Roy, Arundhati.The God of Small Things. New Delhi: Penguin Books, 2002.

Semantic Analysis of the Determinologization of Coroneologisms in the Uzbek Language

Daily writing prompt
Have you ever unintentionally broken the law?

Citation

Shuhratovna, O. I., & Fernando, R. S. (2026). Semantic Analysis of the Determinologization of Coroneologisms in the Uzbek Language. International Journal of Research, 13(2), 118–124. https://doi.org/10.26643/ijr/2026/37

Ortiqova Iroda Shuhratovna

Uzbekistan State World Languages University

Rosell Sulla Fernando

University of exact and social sciences

ABSTRACT

The 2020–2023 COVID-19 pandemic functioned as a global natural experiment in lexical innovation, rapidly generating emergency-driven terms—coroneologisms—such as lockdown (lokdaun), immunity (immunitet), and remote education (masofaviy ta’lim). Bypassing traditional lexicographic channels, these initially specialized terms quickly spread into everyday discourse, humor, and social media, exemplifying determinologization—the loss of technical specificity as terms enter common usage. Drawing on determinologization theory, Ullmann’s (1962) semantic-change taxonomy, and cognitive semantics within a corpus-assisted framework, this study analyzes the semantic evolution of coroneologisms in Uzbek. It identifies four key mechanisms—broadening, narrowing, metaphorization, and evaluative coloring—and outlines a five-step trajectory from media emergence to institutional codification. The findings show that the pandemic compressed decades of lexical change into just three years, transforming emergency terminology into stable, stylistically versatile elements of the Uzbek lexicon.

Key words: determinologization, coroneologisms, COVID-19, semantic change, Uzbek language, corpus linguistics, broadening, narrowing, metaphorization, evaluative coloring, lexical innovation, crisis communication, lockdown, immunity, remote education, pandemic discourse

The COVID-19 pandemic, which unfolded between 2020 and 2023, is widely recognized not only as a global public health crisis but also as a significant natural experiment in the development of language. In various societies around the world, the overwhelming urgency to name and describe new phenomena – such as lockdowns, PCR testing, remote education, and social-distancing measures – triggered a remarkable wave of ad-hoc lexical formations. These formations often circumvented the conventional processes of approval associated with traditional lexicography. In the context of the Uzbek language, this surge resulted in a cluster of emergency-driven coinages that scholars and journalists have referred to as “coroneologisms” [4], a term that represents a hybrid of “coronavirus” and “neologism.” Many of these newly minted terms began their lives as highly specialized medical or administrative jargon – terms like “ventilator,” “antigen test,” “lockdown,” and “immunity.” However, within a remarkably short span of time, they began to diffuse widely across social media platforms, appearing in hashtags, memes, humorous posts, and even informal conversations among the general public. This rapid transition of specialized terminology into popular discourse serves as a clear example of determinologization—the gradual erosion of a technical term’s limited meaning once it becomes integrated into the fabric of national language [2],[5]. This article seeks to explore the semantic pathways of determinologized coroneologisms in the Uzbek language. It specifically investigates (a) the primary modes of meaning shift – namely broadening, narrowing, metaphorization, and evaluative coloring – that accompanied these terms, and (b) the communicative and social processes that catalyzed or accelerated these transitions. Our analysis is grounded in corpus-assisted evidence derived from media and online discourse, allowing us to describe how a three-year emergency compressed decades of lexical development into a condensed historical timeframe.

Determinologization—a concept originally defined in the field of terminology [2] and further elucidated by L’Homme [3] – describes the process by which a technical or scientific term migrates out of its specialized context and into ordinary language. This movement is rarely neutral; as a term transitions “outside of its domain,” it often loses its precise denotation, acquires additional affective or ideological weight, and undergoes stylistic shifts across both formal and informal registers. To effectively characterize these semantic pathways, this paper employs Ullmann’s [6] framework for classifying semantic change, which is augmented by contemporary research insights regarding cognitive semantic evolution. Four mechanisms of semantic change emerged as particularly salient in this context:

Broadening (Widening): This mechanism refers to the expansion of a technical term’s referential scope, extending far beyond its original definition. For example, the medical term immunitet (biological resistance to disease) developed metaphorical uses signifying any kind of protection or resilience, as in iqtisodiy immunitet “economic immunity” or “institutional immunity to corruption”.

Narrowing (Specialization): This mechanism occurs when a term’s meaning contracts to a more limited subset of its earlier referents. For instance, the English loan lokdaun (< lockdown) originally denoted a range of industrial or security-related shutdowns, but in Uzbek pandemic usage it came to mean only “legally imposed stay-at-home order.” The term ventilator, widely used in headlines as ventilyatsiya qilmoq “to ventilate”, narrowed to refer exclusively to “connecting a patient to artificial lung ventilation.”

Metaphorical Transfer and Re-conceptualization: This mechanism involves projecting concrete imagery from one domain onto other, often more abstract, targets. A notable example is the everyday noun to‘lqin (“wave of water”) was repurposed to describe successive “waves of infection”, producing widely used expressions such as 1-to‘lqin, 2-to‘lqin.

Evaluative Coloring: In this mechanism, terms acquire positive or negative attitudinal elements, often imbued with humor or irony. Combinations such as “Kovidiot” (a blend of “covid” and “idiot”) and the compound antiniqobchi (anti + niqob + -chi) designated “anti-mask activists”, marking not only behaviour but also an ideological position.

These mechanisms collectively illustrate that the transition from specialized phrases to common vocabulary is not a linear process; rather, meanings may expand or contract, take on metaphorical nuances, or become evaluative in response to communicative needs and societal contexts.

The methodology employed in this research is rooted in a corpus-driven descriptive model [1], which emphasizes the analysis of real speech as the primary source of evidence for semantic change. To this end, we constructed a custom corpus comprising a diverse range of Uzbek language news sources, official announcements, online forums, and prominent social media platforms spanning from March 2020 to December 2023. This methodological approach facilitated the investigation of the following dimensions:

– The chronological diffusion of newly coined words across the three-year span of the pandemic;

– The distinguishing differences in register among official media, informal posts, and colloquial speech patterns;

– The profiles of collocations that unveiled new senses and figurative applications of emerging terms;

– Pragmatic signals that indicated humor, stance, or judgment, further elucidating instances of semantic change.

By liberating the analysis from an overreliance on prescriptive dictionary definitions – which have proven inadequate in capturing the dynamism of language evolution – the study aims to articulate what vocabulary has come to signify in public communication, contrasting this with the more static definitions prescribed by traditional dictionaries.

An in-depth analysis of the Uzbek linguistic data reveals that a significant number of high-frequency coroneologisms underwent a five-stage lexical evolution, a process that was notably expedited during the pandemic due to the prevailing sociolinguistic conditions:

Stage 1 – Media Seeding: In the initial shock phase of the pandemic (March–May 2020), the urgent need for communication led to the borrowing of English terms such as “lockdown,” “PCR test,” “ventilator,” and “mask regime.” These terms were rapidly integrated into Uzbek headlines, hashtags, and memes, where the immediacy of communication took precedence over adherence to orthographic or morphological consistency.

Stage 2 – Morpho-Phonemic Adaptation: As the usage of these borrowed terms began to stabilize, a process of nativization ensued. This involved alterations to stress patterns to conform to Uzbek linguistic standards, the simplification of consonant clusters, and the adoption of Latin script conventions in spelling. For instance, “RT-PCR” became simplified to “PZR,” and “lockdown” was adapted to “lokdaun.”

Stage 3 – Semantic Dilution and Metaphorization: During this stage, common words began to expand or mutate either metaphorically or in terms of their general application to biomedical contexts. The term “to’lqin,” for example, began appearing in headlines describing “a wave of layoffs,” while “karantin” evolved into shorthand for any form of restrictive regulation.

Stage 4 – Lexicographic Recognition: From 2021 to 2022, several key terms, including “lockdown,” “distance learning,” “PCR test,” and “immunity,” were officially recognized and included in the COVID-19 Explanatory Dictionary.

Stage 5 – Pedagogical / Institutional Stabilization: Ultimately, these terms found their way into educational materials such as school textbooks, teachers’ guides, and civil-service style manuals, as well as journalistic glossaries. This integration reflected a full incorporation of these expressions into the Uzbek lexical system. A key finding of this research is that the shift from impromptu borrowing to institutionally codified lexis was accomplished within a mere three-year timeframe. This indicates that the exigencies of crisis-driven speech have the potential to accelerate lexical development that would typically unfold over decades. The pathway also highlights that determinologization is not only structural but also emergent, influenced by local communicative urgency, institutional acceptance, and societal prominence.

Beyond merely structuring the semantic transformations discussed, the Uzbek coroneologisms exhibited four reiterative communicative and pragmatic roles that account for their swift proliferation within the language:

Economy of Expression: The newly introduced forms, which were predominantly borrowed, provided concise and readily comprehensible labels for concepts that may have been unfamiliar to the general public. Terms that required longer descriptive phrases, such as “online schooling” and “PCR diagnostic test,” were efficiently replaced with these shorter alternatives, thereby facilitating effective public communication within both media narratives and healthcare discussions.

Stance-Marking and Evaluation: Several terms adopted pejorative or ironic connotations during the politically charged periods of the crisis. For example, “covidiot” (a fusion of “covid” and “idiot”) became associated with individuals who disregarded safety protocols. Additionally, the slang term “remotka” (meaning “remote work”) emerged with a mildly humorous or dismissive tone, while “anti-niqobchi” explicitly indexed ideological opposition to mask mandates.

Group Identity and Solidarity: Some terms evolved into in-group codes that reflected the collective experiences of lockdown, distance learning, and online communication. The productive phrase “meeting up on Zoom” transformed into a rallying cry among social groups, encapsulated in expressions like “zumlashmoq” This development fostered conversation and unity among individuals navigating the challenges of isolation.

Humor and Coping: Lexical blends such as “quarantini” (a combination of “quarantine” and “martini”) and the incorporation of slang terms like “doomscrolling” provided a playful linguistic outlet for navigating anxiety and boredom. These terms thus served as coping mechanisms, contributing to stress-relief strategies in an otherwise challenging context.

These pragmatic functions underscore that the determinologized pandemic vocabulary was not merely a referential identity but also a valuable resource for stance-taking, community-building, and coping mechanisms amidst the crisis.

Table 1

№TermExpansion on the meaning
 Pandemiya     Shifted from strictly medical to any globally spreading phenomenon (“infodemic”, “pandemic of fear”).
 KoronavirusBecame a generic label for any contagious trouble; often used metaphorically (“a coronavirus of bad habits”).
 COVID-19Extended to denote cause, blame, or time-marker (“because of covid”, “covid generation”).
 VaksinaMetaphorised into “silver-bullet solution” for non-medical crises (“education vaccine”, “economic vaccine”).
 ImunitetBroadened to any system’s defensive capacity (“tax immunity”, “bank immunity”).
 KarantinRe-semanticised to mean any restrictive measure or even punitive isolation.
 IzolyatsiyaMoved from clinical isolation to everyday social distancing and on-line modes (“isolation lessons”).
 LockdaunImported as-is; now also describes total shutdowns in business or mental states (“mental lockdown”).
 AntitelaUsed figuratively for ideological or emotional resistance (“antibodies to negativity”).
 EpidemiyaGeneralised to any rapidly spreading trend (“epidemic of errors”, “epidemic of selfies”).
 Masofani saqlashPhysical distance became a metaphor for emotional coolness in relationships.
   GigiyenaHygiene concept expanded to information & mental spheres (“info-hygiene”, “sleep hygiene”).
 DezinfektsiyaDisinfection now covers cleansing of fake news or toxic content.
 SimptomClinical sign → any visible indicator of systemic problems (“symptoms of economic crisis”).
 TestNarrow lab procedure turned into generic verb “to test” and synonym for any quick check.
 Immunitet pasayishiImmunological drop re-interpreted as weakening resilience in economics or organisations.
 PCRAcronym became a household verb meaning “to swab-test” regardless of method.
 AntigenTechnical term now stands metonymically for rapid-test devices themselves.
 VentilyatorLife-support machine → metaphor for any critical external support (“financial ventilator”).
 Post-pandemiyaTemporal phase converted into a cultural label for “new normal” behaviours and policies.
 To‘lqinOriginally “wave” of water; pandemic discourse turned it into numbered surges (“third wave”) and now any periodic spike (“price wave”, “jobless wave”).
 ZumlashmoqPure Uzbek verb “to accelerate”; during the crisis it shifted from physical speeding-up to rapid scaling of remote work, vaccination drives, or digital services (“business zumlandi”).

The findings derived from the Uzbek data demonstrate that the process of lexical borrowing, catalyzed by a crisis, can significantly accelerate the phenomenon of semantic and pragmatic diversification. This process enables the transformation of technical medical terminology into broadly stylistic and affectively expressive components of everyday vocabulary. The outlined five-step trajectory, which encompasses the initial seeding of terms in media and their subsequent institutional codification, illustrates the complex nature of this social mediation process. It becomes evident that determinologization is not merely a function of lexical evolution but is socially mediated through communicative urgency, varying attitudes, and policy decisions. By combining determinologization theory, Ullmann’s semantic-change taxonomy, and a corpus-assisted methodology, this study presents a condensed lifecycle of lexical evolution that would typically require decades to develop. The results underscore the necessity for dynamic lexicographic practices and language-planning methods that are capable of responding swiftly to future public health or technological emergencies. An organized record of rapid lexical evolution, such as the analysis presented here, contributes to our understanding of how and why national languages maintain their flexibility and functional resilience in the face of global crises.

References

  1. Baker, M. (2011). In Other Words: A Coursebook on Translation (2nd ed.). Routledge. 353 p.
  2. Felber, H. (1984). Terminology Manual. UNESCO. 457 p.
  3. L’Homme, M.-C. (2020). Lexical Semantics for Terminology: An Introduction (3rd ed.). John Benjamins / De Boeck. 
  4. Nasirova, M. F. (2023). COVID 19 pandemiyasi davrida vujudga kelgan neologizmlar Oriental Renaissance: Innovative, educational, natural and social sciences . Volume 3. Issue11.
  5. Sager, J. C. (1990). A Practical Course in Terminology Processing. John Benjamins. 
  6. Ullmann, S. (1962). Semantics: An Introduction to the Science of Meaning. Blackwell.